6 ms·
I wish you luck! I have the opposite issue. I'm ... what do you call it? neurodiverse (at one time, I was an "aspie"), and I can actually get locked into a fug
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I wish you luck!
I have the opposite issue. I'm ... what do you call it? neurodiverse (at one time, I was an "aspie"), and I can actually get locked into a fugue, so strong, that hours go by like minutes.
In the aggregate, it has worked out OK. I'm a damn good programmer (but a total nerd).
I do have family that have suffered from ADHD, and hope that your app may be helpful.
- guipsp 5y agoNot diagnosing you or anything like that, but you should know that hyper focus is a symptom of adhd.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoMaybe, but I know a family member with true ADHD, and it's quite different. For one thing, he gets along with other folks, much better than I ever did.
- jdavis703 5y agoAccording to a medical doctor I have true ADHD. Unfortunately I do not get along with other folks. I have no friends and family that refuses to see me. Work is a struggle to ensure I’m interacting with people in a neurotypical manner that puts folks at ease. That said, I also know people with ADHD who are the life of the party. It really depends on the person.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoThere are multiple types of ADHD, so you two may be discussing different ones. The commonly used categories are 1. primarily hyperactive (cannot stay physically still), 2. primarily inattentive (”daydreamer”), 3. combined type, with features from both 1. and 2.
- exhaze 5y agoThere's no true ADHD. ADHD has many different manifestations. The one trait I have seen described that seemed most common was "difficulty with impulse control"
- n1000 5y agoHyperfocus is actually one of the odd trades of ADHD. If people with ADHD work on a topic that motivates them, they can easily loose hours just like you describe. However, if the task is too mundane or overwhelming, I can easily procrastinate months on them.
- geocrasher 5y ago^ This. As a 45 year old recently diagnosed with ADHD, I realize how much of my life was described by things like this. The more I learn about ADD/ADHD, the more sense I make to myself.
- exdsq 5y agoThis sounds very much like me. Give me interesting work and I won’t stop, give me mundane work and I’ll find more interesting work till I have to do it. I’m 27, how did you end up getting diagnosed later into adult life?
- geocrasher 5y agoA new coworker, who was recently diagnosed, said to me "you have a lot of the traits that I have that led me to getting diagnosed." So I talked to my doctor, filled out a short questionnaire, and it was official. Before seeing the doctor, I mentioned it to my adult daughter and her response was "Well DUH." Seems like everyone knew but me lol.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoDamn. I spent $3000+ dollars and went through 7 hours of testing. I hope getting treatment was that easy for you as well.
- jdavis703 5y agoAre you in the US? I spent something like $200 on the initial appointment in the SF Bay Area. This was done without insurance, so that was the total cost. And I think I spent slightly less than 2 hours undergoing evaluation.
- mbrock 5y agoFor what it’s worth, that kind of time blindness induced by hyperfocus on some idiosyncratically captivating interest is also a classic manifestation of ADHD.
- jdavis703 5y agoThis isn’t part of the colloquial zeitgeist, but the executive functioning issues of ADHD and ASD share a lot of common symptoms around a lot of social behavior patterns. For example I am diagnosed as ADHD. But I feel I have some issues that put me on the autism spectrum. After doing a lot more in-depth reading I’m pretty convinced I am not autistic, even though many of my symptoms do intersect with autism. Strongly encourage you read more books about ASD and autism and then seek professional advice if you believe it would make your life better.
- TheFreim 5y ago> and I can actually get locked into a fugue, so strong, that hours go by like minutes. Is this not a normal occurrence? I thought this is just how it is for everyone when they encounter a problem that captivates them.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoSure. It's just that the rest of the time people without ADHD can sit still for longer than ten minutes and don't uncontrollably interrupt people while talking.
- playpause 5y agoYes. Pretty much all the symptoms of ADHD are things that everyone experiences from time to time. People with ADHD just experience them far, far more often, in a way that often negatively impacts their career and relationships. And their lives tend to get better after being diagnosed, as they can start using meds and learning ADHD-specific organisation strategies.
- fasteo 5y ago>> and I can actually get locked into a fugue, so strong, that hours go by like minutes. This is the norm for ADHD as far as I can tell seeing how my kid behaves. As I see it, ADHD is not an inability to focus, but an inability to control what you focus on.
- delecti 5y ago"Neurodiverse" is an umbrella term that covers a handful of things, including both ADHD and Autism Spectrum Disorder. What used to be Asperger's is now just one point along the autism spectrum. So you'd still be classified as neurodiverse if you had ADHD instead of being somewhere under the sub-umbrella ASD.
- boopmaster 5y agoI won’t argue with you about this, as I’m tied up arguing about it already with my inner aspie.
- playpause 5y agoTo echo the other comments here, you are describing ADHD, not its opposite. ADHD doesn’t mean you can’t hyperfocus, far from it. It means you find it much harder than a normal person to directly control, through pure will, what to focus on and how widely/narrowly. So at times you’re highly distractible and struggle to focus on things (sometimes even when you know they’re vitally important, like listening to the questions in a job interview), and at other times you struggle to tear yourself away from a task you’re engrossed in (even when you know there’s something urgent you should be doing) - the fugue state you describe. It’s a lack of ‘executive function’, and you can actually see this on an MRI scan - ADHD brains apparently tend to show much less of this type of activity. As a rough analogy, ADHD is to focus as bipolar disorder is to mood.
- bravura 5y ago"As a rough analogy, ADHD is to focus as bipolar disorder is to mood." Could you elaborate?
- playpause 5y agoWith bipolar disorder, you swing between extremes - depression and mania. Your mood seems to have a mind of its own, you can’t always control it. With ADHD, you swing between extremes - unfocused and hyperfocus. Your focus seems to have a mind of its own, you can’t always control it.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoAs others have mentioned, "Hyperfocus". is one of the symptoms of ADHD. ADHD is really a misnomer, it should be called Attention control disorder. The famous hyperactivity part that annoys parents and teachers is really just a way to self treat. Exercise in general helps, and one of the hypotheses I have heard is that the ADHD brain evolved to be constantly moving, and is only a problem with our modern stoic lifestyle. Though back to hyper focus, it is a curse and a blessing. Without it, I would never get anything done personally or professionally. Though I will also ignore family, friends, and work for entire days on things that are meaningless and I don't enjoy. Which really brings me to the core of ADHD. What you focus on has nothing to do with what you want, or what you enjoy. It is, to various degrees, out of your control. That said, I'm going to give the app a try, I have had some ideas for an app myself, but haven't found the focus to work on it.
- suzzer99 5y agoWhat's the difference between hyperfocus and flow state?
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoNot much. I would say that a flow state happens on purpose for something you want to do, and you can easily stop your flow even though it may be difficult to get it started again. With Hyper focus it may happen to something you don't want it to, and you can't easily stop. In the moment it is hard to tell the difference, at least when it's something you want to do. For example, I was late to an event for my child the other day because I was trying to improve the speed of a one time copy of data from an old computer to a new one. To the point that when I finally pulled myself away, after receiving multiple phone calls, it had been hours and the original method would have been finished if I had just let it run. I felt like I was being productive, but I was not. Once I realized I was wasting my time it took me two more hours to stop.
- jdavis703 5y agoAn example of a bad flow state is I’ll get locked in a Wikipedia hole. It might start on reading up on a topic I need for work (e.g. a class of algorithms), and then next thing I know I’m 6 degrees away from the topic I was supposed to be studying reading about a 16th century battle or whatever.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI strongly suggest that you engage with some professionals for this issue, not an app targeted at a single diagnosis. Issues like you describe are difficult to self-diagnose and impossible for others to diagnose over the internet. You could have an ADHD-like etiology, maladaptive daydreaming, or you could have a seizure disorder. Undiagnosed seizure disorders can be particularly draining but are often easily treated. Be wary of internet comments pushing you to a specific diagnosis, particularly ADHD. HN commenters frequently over-diagnose ADHD from comments about vague symptoms. Leave it to professionals who can evaluate you in person.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoAhh...it's all water under the bridge, for me. I've accepted my own proclivities, and learned to make them strengths. I have no interest in the app, but I agree that folks who believe they may have any type of issues like this, should start by seeking professional help. One of the things about HFA and ADHD, is that they can go undiagnosed for a lifetime; which is not always a bad thing. We can often be extremely productive members of society; despite challenges. A lot of times, the behaviors and habits we develop, as mitigations of the symptoms, can cause more problems that the issue, itself.
- elcritch 5y ago> A lot of times, the behaviors and habits we develop, as mitigations of the symptoms, can cause more problems that the issue, itself. Too true. If you can learn to leverage the mental differences it can become very valuable. Unfortunately behaviors/emotions/habits to counter symptoms that in the larger picture often aren't that significant can make life much more difficult than it needs to be.