5 ms·
Some NASA critic probably has a wonderful "last gasp of the monster" retrospective on this. "Build a telescope years after disposing of any launch methods", "de
by h2odragon 5y ago
Some NASA critic probably has a wonderful "last gasp of the monster" retrospective on this. "Build a telescope years after disposing of any launch methods", "design with no consideration for transport or launch, and so on.
I have heard "The NASA way" called a gold standard of inefficiency. As they fold up operations; who will take over that mantle of ludicrous largess? Not even Blue Origin can gold plate things "just because it looks better that way".
- ceejayoz 5y ago> after disposing of any launch methods Huh? They had a variety of launchers to pick from. > design with no consideration for transport or launch Again, huh? The folding nature of the JWST is specifically a launch consideration; fitting in the available fairing sizes.
- rsynnott 5y ago> Build a telescope years after disposing of any launch methods Eh? A variety of launch vehicles were available; they chose the most appropriate one.
- dylan604 5y agonone of those launch vehicles were theirs. to me, NASA is less of a space agency as much as a satellite builder/operator. to be a space agency, you must be able to get to space not being to hitch a ride. hell, the Space Force is more of a space agency than NASA.
- reportingsjr 5y agoThis makes absolutely no sense and I assume little thought went in to it. From the very start, the Pioneer 1 satellite, NASA has used rockets developed and operated by other entities. A major, if not the principle, reason for NASA to exist is space science, not rocket science. Their satellites, research stations, etc are seriously important work. The rockets are definitely important, but primarily as a way to enable the space research. This is like saying an airline isn't a true airline because they don't design their own planes. It just doesn't make any sense.
- dylan604 5y agoAnd then they went on to develop Mercury, Gemini, Apollo, Shuttles. All of them were able to launch payload into space. NASA can no longer do that. They have gone backwards in capability. The launch systems they are working on are so no where near working that multiple other company have been started and surpassed them in that amount of time. NASA is no longer a space launch company. They service existing missions that were planned/designed/launched when I was kid. This pretty much makes them a legacy. Where's the new?
- ceejayoz 5y ago> NASA is no longer a space launch company. Good. That was never the point of NASA. If they can contract out the launchers to SpaceX, ULA, etc., they can focus on the scientific aspects. Funding launch platforms via CRS and Commercial Crew was one of NASA's smartest and most cost effective decisions. > Where's the new? Quite a bit of it is on Mars actively exploring right now.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> NASA is no longer a space launch company. NASA has never been a space launch company. Or a company at all, for that matter. They’re a government administration that always contracted out most design work to private firms, with a mission much broader than space launch.
- ghaff 5y agoWho is "they"? You realize that most of the actual development work on all those programs was done by contractors/subcontractors in the aerospace industry?
- frosted-flakes 5y agoNASA just landed a highly advanced rover on Mars, with a helicopter that exceeded all expectations. They do new stuff all the time. And do you know how much funding they had during the moon landing era? Even then, the Lunar service module, LM, etc. were developed amd built by outside companies (North American, Northrup-Grumman, etc.). And then there's the political SLS debacle which soaks up so much of their funding.
- idiotsecant 5y agoI'm not sure it's important that NASA be in charge of rocketry. The fundementals are well understood and private industry is willing to handle it, so why not? As long as the bus exists why does NASA have to own the bus?
- prpl 5y agoJWST isn’t likely the most complex thing launched in space, just the most complex thing that is unclassified.
- idiotsecant 5y agoFor some reason those eggheads in labcoats insist we should point this telescope away from earth, can you imagine? What a waste.
- _dy2u 5y agoYep. 2012: "The secretive government agency that flies spy satellites has made a stunning gift to NASA: two exquisite telescopes as big and powerful as the Hubble Space Telescope. They’ve never left the ground and are in storage in Rochester, N.Y." Those were just outdated spares predating Hubble, and apparently more advanced: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/nasa-gets-military-spy-telescopes-for-astronomy/2012/06/04/gJQAsT6UDV_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/nasa-...
- RegnisGnaw 5y agoThey always had a launch vehicle. The JWST is a joint NASA-ESA-CSA project. The ESA is responsible for the launch as part of the project.