4 ms·
Is it only me that think's this guy's a nutter that gets by by saying whatever Apple fans want to hear? Here's some of his startlingly wrong predictions about t
by ZeroGravitas 15y ago
Is it only me that think's this guy's a nutter that gets by by saying whatever Apple fans want to hear? Here's some of his startlingly wrong predictions about the smartphone market from last year:
http://www.asymco.com/2010/11/03/what-do-you-have-to-believe-for-an-android-dominated-future/ http://www.asymco.com/2010/11/03/what-do-you-have-to-believe...
His key arguments where that:
* Android wouldn't grow faster than the average of RIM, Nokia, HP and Apple.
* Nokia wouldn't dump Symbian&Meego for someone else's OS.
* Android wouldn't do a great deal better than Windows Mobile
* Android vendors wouldn't be profitable
So not very good really, in fact a total blowout. Maybe he knows stuff about Apple, to be honest I think he's just like a sports fan during a season when his team is playing well. His elaborate theories of why they are succeeding don't seem to mesh with reality much, except in that Apple is doing very well, and I'm not sure he cares if they do or not.
- ugh 15y ago“Nutter”? Really? Being wrong doesn’t make anyone a “nutter”.
- cooldeal 15y agoMaybe nutter is a strong word, but still, there is an obsession with taking numbers and 'facts' and trying to twist them into spin for Apple with dodgy long winded 'analysis/predictions' that doesn't stand five seconds of reason(except from the big Apple fanbase), all the while still trying to sound objective...
- barista 15y agoBesides android vendors aren't really profitable by big margins. Motorola in fact has continued losing money for past few years even after introducing android.
- cooldeal 15y ago>HTC announced that its first quarter 2011 profits were up by a staggering 191 per cent to $511 million from the same time last year. Revenue figures were not too shabby either, showing 174 per cent growth, meaning that profit growth outstripped revenue growth, something that is particularly desirable on any balance sheet. Do you get your news from Apple centered sites and blogs and the comments there? There seems to be an element of cognitive dissonance(or perhaps PR rhetoric?). If this was MS, there would be shouts of paid shills, but I am not going there. Edit: Samsung made a profit of 1.5 billion dollars off their phones just last quarter.
- rsynnott 15y agoSee here, however: http://www.intomobile.com/2011/05/02/apple-has-50-profit-share-smartphone-makers-cant-hear-haters-behind-huge-wall-cash/ http://www.intomobile.com/2011/05/02/apple-has-50-profit-sha... While HTC's profits are unquestionably growing, their profit share actually declined a bit; remember it's a very rapidly expanding industry. Motorola Mobility, SE and LG are loss-making or close to it. Only Samsung is in a really strong position.
- cooldeal 15y agoYou think that's enough to support the following statement? >Besides android vendors aren't really profitable by big margins
- rsynnott 15y agoSamsung's profit margin is good, and HTC's acceptable (though neither are as high as Apple's), but all other major manufacturers are either loss-making or making a tiny profit margin.
- barista 15y agoMy point was regarding profit margins. They are getting slimmer by the day as every device maker joins the downward spiral to get the phones out at a cheaper rate. Most these device makers outsource and do not have their own manufacturing. That's why sammy is is the one that is truly making money here. and note: opinions that to not match yours can be independent. They don't have to be disillusioned or paid. Learn to respect them.
- antrix 15y ago> Most these device makers outsource and do not have their own manufacturing. You mean like Apple?
- recoiledsnake 15y agoWhile I usually don't agree with the convoluted and twisted logic of Asymco, Gruber and Marco (they do get a lot of undeserved traction on HN thanks to its big section of Apple fans), I think this time he does have a point. It will be a tightrope walk for Google about who and how to share the longterm plans of the OS with etc.
- ellyagg 15y agoUndeserved traction? Isn't Apple performing outrageously well with consumers and as a company? Were they not the largest capitalized company in the world at one point recently? If Apple were not being reported on here heavily (and positively), a site devoted to the intersection of hacking and business, that would be awfully weird, no? As far as I know, developer revenue from iPhone apps still dwarfs Android. Shouldn't that be pretty interesting to a community more than partly devoted to making money off of programming? If anything, I suggest the extremely large number of Google employees who participate here swings the bias the other way. I found it exceedingly odd that--regarding a story about a company paying $12 billion to buy another company, the type of move that is normally considered incredibly risky, and the type of move which does not have a great track record in the annals of corporate history--after making it 3/4 of the way down the comment thread here on HN, there was virtually no criticism. Really? This move is a slam dunk?
- recoiledsnake 15y agoI was talking about _some_ posts from sites like Asymco, Gruber's and Marco and some HN comments. I don't know how you construed it as if my comment was against general(if a little overactive) Apple coverage, which is think is well deserved since Apple is doing a lot lately. You were attacking a strawman.
- amazingman 15y agoHe's making much longer-term assessments about the evolving market. You seem to be calling it a "total blowout" from the perspective of a reality that hasn't actually happened yet.
- benologist 15y agoIt's just one of many, many websites that makes their money by pandering to a niche. It's tasteless, but profitable.
- cooldeal 15y ago>It's tasteless, but profitable. The problem is that they are bandied about as independent opinion and analysis. Gruber sells ads on his RSS feeds, which seem to cost thousands of dollars each, thanks to advertising by iOS apps. No wonder he plays to his fanbase with the pro-Apple and anti-Google/Android/MS rhetoric. He must be laughing all the way to the bank while thinking up his next 'The precisely perfect placement of the Chair at Macworld' and 'Dirty Percent' article. Also, he gets invited to Apple events, which may quickly disappear if he gets too critical(see Gizmodo).
- ugh 15y agoJust because people don’t share your opinion doesn’t mean that they are purposefully lying. It’s a quite common fallacy, really.
- cooldeal 15y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" -Sinclair Regardless of the above quote, I do not accuse them of lying. But there's a strong elementy of hypocrisy and fanboyism, both in supporting Apple almost all the time, and screaming bloody murder and abject criticism of any moves by Apple's competitors. Do you seriously think analysis by Asymco, Gruber and Marco regarding Apple are the flawless gospel truth? The fallacy you mention would apply more to the accusations of commenters being paid MS shills, which happens all the time here on HN too.
- GHFigs 15y agoaccusations of commenters being paid MS shills, which happens all the time here on HN hnsearch disagrees with you.
- rsynnott 15y agoHe was largely right on profitability, no?
- fpgeek 15y agoNot really. He forgot to consider the other set of companies making money from Android: Arms merchants like Qualcomm,TI and NVIDIA. For example, NVIDIA is pretty thrilled with all the Tegra 2 design wins they got from Android manufacturers.
- msbarnett 15y agoHe didn't "forget" them; the profitability of component manufacturers has no more to do with the fact that most Android licensee Phone manufacturers aren't turning much profit off the business than the profitability of shovel salesmen has to do with the fact that most gold prospectors never found anything worth selling.
- fpgeek 15y agoYes, it does. "Arms merchants" like Qualcomm, TI and NVIDIA are more than just "shovel salesmen". Among other things, they're the ones who do the first ports of Android to their chipsets. I don't remember where I read this, but they compete just as much as the phone manufacturers do to make it into "Nexus / Google Experience" devices. One of the big reasons profitability matters is because it drives future investment. To the extent that component manufacturers are making money porting Android to their components and selling the combination, they're going to keep investing, even if their downstream customers are locked in a brutal price war.