10 ms·
This is simply a God of the gaps argument [0]. Just because we don't (yet) know how the universe was created does not mean that we must attribute it to some dei
by satvikpendem 5y ago
This is simply a God of the gaps argument [0]. Just because we don't (yet) know how the universe was created does not mean that we must attribute it to some deity.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAt some point it’s not a gap but an empty set.
- HenryKissinger 5y agoThe Universe has always existed. It does not have a beginning, and it won't have an end. I'm not talking about the 13.4B old Universe we live in. I'm talking about the Universe that came before it. The Universe is cyclical.
- adrianN 5y agoSince time is part of the universe, I'm not sure whether it is meaningful to talk about something that happened before it existed.
- tomrod 5y agoA poetic, yet unproven, conjecture
- achillesheels 5y agoAn unfalsifiable one at that. Unless it is possible to perceive a world independent of light?
- tomrod 5y agoClose your eyes. Touch the ground. You have now perceived a world independent of light.
- achillesheels 5y agoSir, we are experiencing light through our senses when we touch the ground. Are you familiar with how our bodies sample piezoelectrically?
- tomrod 5y agoPiezoelectricity is not photons. It may generate photons, but is not created by photons.
- achillesheels 5y agoAnd isn’t this generation the only photons that we can experience in the mind with the brain?
- simondotau 5y agoFalse. The memory of light aided your perception.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoUnproven (and unprovable)
- anders_p 5y agoIts a nice idea. There'd be no ending or beginning to worry about. Everything would be self-contained. But I don't believe that our universe is neither unique, neverending, or cyclical. I believe that our universe is just one of many, that exists on a super-dimensional plane (or substrate - not sure what word to use), where 'universes' continously appear and disappear, like bubbles in boiling water. Every one of these universes will have different sets of laws, or rather, the laws will be tweaked differently, depending on the exact conditions of how they form. Most will not be valid. They will 'pop' or implode near instantaneously. Some will not have the right values for constants like gravity and speed of light. But every once in a while, there will be a universe where the laws are just perfect for what we see in our universe. A place where stars and planets can form. Where the right elements appear, and life as we know it is possible.
- bserge 5y agoOK, now where did this superdimensional plane come from, how was it formed? Or was it always there and always will be? That's what OP was saying I believe.
- anders_p 5y agoI have no idea where that substrate, or whatever, came from, or 'who' created it. I wasn't trying to answer that. I'm aware that my comment merely added an additional layer, between us and "the creator"/creation, (however you define that). My point was more, that I don't believe our universe is unique, as in "alone". But rather that it is just one of many. That some "God", or event, didn't create a single universe, perfect for (human) life. That's way too antropocentric for me. Instead I believe that they are plentiful, and by chance one of them happened to be suitable for life as we know it. We are not here because a universe _was created for us_. We are here because a universe _could produce us_.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI like the thought experiment of exploring the entire universe with advanced space travel and finding no other life (statistically a zero chance if the universe isn’t anthropocentric). But of course it’s unfortunately impossible to know due to space time limits.
- anomosmarxist 5y agothis is NOT simply a gotg. in fact, simplification of such a brilliant work as the ETHICS is really detrimental to your simple assesment. go read a book, and try thinking. there are limits to knowledge, because its limited. what gap is really there then?
- anthk 5y agoEthics are a subset of anthropology and thus, Biology.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anthk 5y agoThis. It's ridiculous how can people support these infantile and crude beliefs in order to understand the universe. Do these people think HN stays online by prayings instead of the hard work of the sysadmins?
- bytelines 5y agoHN stays online through the work of humans. The community thrives by following guidelines, among them: * be kind * do not sneer * do not call names * respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize
- simondotau 5y agoI am 110% in support of those community principles when it comes to criticism of people. We must always assume mutual respect, practice kindness and argue in good faith. It's never not the right thing to do, whether you're motivated by persuasion or simple humanity. But can we at least recognise that there's an enormous distinction between criticism of people and criticism of ideas? In my estimation, when someone is calling for an idea to be protected from unkindness, or name-calling, or sneering, it's probably deserving of it.
- bytelines 5y agoIdeas shouldn't be beyond criticism, sure. But if you can't criticize an idea without being unkind, resorting to name calling, and misrepresenting someones view -- at best you aren't haven't a dialog, at worst you don't have any valid criticism to contribute.
- motioncuty 5y agoIm not so sure your right that its a god of the gaps argument. What faith do you have in gravity. Obviously you trust that physics is the law of our universe. Deifying those laws isnt claiming that god is in the gaps of scientific knowledge, infact its suggesting that "god" is the laws illuminated by scientific processes themselves. I certainly have faith in physics...
- glial 5y agoNo. He's reclaiming the term 'god'. Spinoza equated god with being or reality - all off it - not just gaps. He did not believe in a personal or interventionist god. "God, that is, Nature..."
- BreakfastB0b 5y agoThen why use the word “God” that already comes with so much baggage?
- glial 5y agoHe thinks that our confused conversations about god, free will, freedom, causality, etc mostly stem from poor definitions of these terms. So to have a useful conversation and valid deductions, it's critical to have 'correct' definitions of these terms - including freedom, power, etc. He starts every section of Ethics with a list of definitions. He's not only making metaphysical claims, he's also trying to set humanity up for have better conversations and understandings about god, society, and ethical behavior (hence the title of the book "Ethics"). Here's a good quote, wherein he's criticizing people's conception of God as the 'first cause' - "So they will not cease to ask for the causes of causes, until you take refuge in the will of God, that is, the asylum of ignorance." The quote makes pretty clear that he is explicitly rejecting the "God of the gaps".
- dQw4w9WgXcQ 5y agoThen again, it's really not insane to make the inference leap that given every single created thing on Earth has a human creator, the Earth (and universe itself) might also have one. Such a leap doesn't really affect the doing of science whatsoever, and might even in fact drive the enjoyment of discovering the work of said Creator.
- torstenvl 5y agoI don't think this is GotG. GotG arguments rely on gaps in scientific knowledge as evidence of the existence of the numinous. This argument isn't about gaps in scientific knowledge. It's about gaps in scientific knowability. The argument is Godelian in nature. The set of natural laws is a logical axiomatic system. It cannot be both consistent and complete. Therefore, either the scientific method is fundamentally unreliable for determining the truth, or there are true propositions about reality that cannot be proven within the axiomatic system of the natural laws. In short, unless the natural sciences are inherently bunk, it's a logical necessity that there exists something outside their scope, literally super-natural. It's an imperfect analogy but I always come back to the idea of CPU privilege rings. We run up against a hard limit of what is observable/provable - a privilege boundary, if you will. That suggests we are in Ring > 0, and therefore there is something in Ring 0. What's in Ring 0? Nobody knows. Whatever it is, we call it God.
- anomosmarxist 5y agoGodel is important, but his argument's extension to natural laws is a bit of a stretch, also that set of laws isnt really a logical axiomatic set. its more of a hodgepodge, an ever shifting discursive formation by which we are epistemological bound to in as much as we exist by it
- f6v 5y ago> The set of natural laws is a logical axiomatic system. It cannot be both consistent and complete. Can you explain why?