2 ms·
> You don't have to be a citizen to have a driver's license, either, but they're accepted. This is the exact reason that issuing indistinguishable driver's lic
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> You don't have to be a citizen to have a driver's license, either, but they're accepted.
This is the exact reason that issuing indistinguishable driver's licenses to non-citizens was controversial.
> Doesn't matter if you're a resident of the state.
The point is that maybe it should. It's reasonable to say that people should vote in the place where they're a permanent resident and not somewhere they're likely not going to reside by the end of the term of office for the election in question.
It's not as if they can't vote, they can vote where they're actually from. Or demonstrate the intent to move to the state where they want to vote by getting a state ID there.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> This is the exact reason that issuing indistinguishable driver's licenses to non-citizens was controversial. I don't think it's ever been controversial to permit permanent residents to have drivers' licenses.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This is the exact reason that issuing indistinguishable driver's licenses to non-citizens was controversial. No, it wasn't. Because nondistinguishable licenses for immigrants had been issued for generations when the controversy, which was about licenses issued to people without valid immigration status, erupted.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoDon't be pedantic, you can see what I'm getting at here. A lot more US citizens have a driver's license than a passport. It's the most common form of identification and if it doesn't specify citizenship then there will be millions of people who don't have any picture ID that can prove their citizenship status. That problem could easily be solved by specifying whether you're a citizen on your driver's license. It's a poor excuse to extend the problem to other forms of ID that don't prove citizenship status.
- Talanes 5y agoIt was literally not clear until THIS comment that you were just discussing how you think things should have been designed, and not talking about how things actually work.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Don't be pedantic, you can see what I'm getting at here No, I don't. Because there is no reasonable on topic argument you could be getting at. > A lot more US citizens have a driver's license than a passport. It's the most common form of identification and if it doesn't specify citizenship then there will be millions of people who don't have any picture ID that can prove their citizenship status. Which is fine in the context of voter ID, because presenting ID to vote is notionally to confirm that the person presenting to vote is the person registered (authentication), not that the person registered is allowed to vote (authorization). Authorization of registered voters and removal/disqualification of unauthorized voters is, even in Voter ID systems and proposals, handled separately from voter ID, typically by the same kind of processes used without voter ID.
- tzs 5y ago> The point is that maybe it should. It's reasonable to say that people should vote in the place where they're a permanent resident and not somewhere they're likely not going to reside by the end of the term of office for the election in question. That doesn't really have anything to do with voter ID at the polls, because the point of voter ID at the polls is not to prove that you are eligible to vote. Proof of eligibility should be taken care of when you register to vote. The point of ID at the polls is to show that you are the person who you claim to be, so that the poll workers can check to see if you are on the registered voter list.