6 ms·
Coinbase Digital Asset Policy Proposal
- tfang17 5y agoSmart move on trying to create a self-regulating body like FINRA for crypto.
- technotony 5y agoThis is optimistic, it would require traditional financial service regulators like the SEC to ceed power to a new agency. That's very unlikely to happen. Most of the regulatory institutions in America work to increase their power not hand it off to a new agency. We see this in coinbases own fight with the SEC and other agencies about who regulates yield earning stablecoins.
- secondo 5y agoProbably, but for Coinbase to even manage to steer the conversation in this direction it’s a victory. They are the best positioned in the industry to even attempt it and if they’re rejected they are first in line to provide the infrastructure.
- jakelazaroff 5y agoThis is a good argument for rejecting out any input from Coinbase out of hand.
- striking 5y agoHave they steered the conversation at all, though? From Bloomberg: > “There’s trading venues and lending venues where they coalesce around these, and they have not just dozens but hundreds and sometimes thousands of tokens on them,” Gensler said Monday at the Code Conference in Beverly Hills, California. “This is not going to end well if it stays outside the regulatory space.” [1] Coinbase already got a Wells notice, and whined about the SEC being "sketchy" as a result. [2] I really don't think this conversation is moving in their favor in the actual regulatory circles. 1: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-28/unregulated-crypto-markets-will-not-end-well-sec-chair-says https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-28/unregulat... 2: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-08/coinbase-accuses-sec-of-sketchy-behavior-after-threat-to-sue https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-08/coinbase-...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Animats 5y agoCoinbase could solve that problem by becoming a bank. Or a broker. Or a commodity exchange. But they want "none of the above".
- dboreham 5y agoRegulatory Capture sausage being made.
- Animats 5y agoIt's all about replacing SEC, CFTC, and banking regulator oversight with a "self regulatory organization." A dedicated self-regulatory organization (SRO) should be established to strengthen the oversight regime and provide more granular oversight of MDAs. All registered MDAs should be required to be members of the SRO. The SRO should establish the self-certification process that an MDA would use to make a digital asset available for trading on its platform. The framework would preempt state-by-state registration and related regulatory requirements. It's the scammer's dream. In a world where 79% of ICOs turned out to be scams[1], self-regulation cannot work. The percentage of crooks is too high. The SEC's Howey Test[2] for "is it an investment" applies to "digital assets", just like it does to non-digital assets. The crypto community hates this, because it interferes with Make Money Fast schemes. [1] https://research.bloomberg.com/pub/res/d28giW28tf6G7T_Wr77aU0gDgFQ https://research.bloomberg.com/pub/res/d28giW28tf6G7T_Wr77aU... [2] https://www.sec.gov/corpfin/framework-investment-contract-analysis-digital-assets https://www.sec.gov/corpfin/framework-investment-contract-an...
- rvnx 5y ago"Regulators hate him" - Charles Ponzi
- hackingforfun 5y agoI would like to be able to invest in whatever I want. As an American, I cannot, because US exchanges can't list all the cryptocurrencies that Asian exchanges can, due to fears that the coins / tokens could be flagged as securities. How is this protecting me?
- airstrike 5y ago> How is this protecting me? Go read up on the history of securities trading prior to the various acts from the 1930s.
- jollybean 5y agoIt's hard to fathom why people wouldn't know why regulations exist. Without regulatory bodies, markets would not exist. This is because regular consumers don't have the energy or ability to evaluate the quality of products or services, so in certain areas (health, safety, finance), where it 'really matters' - we regulate. Without a drug regulatory body, there would be no way to know what drugs work, and the market would be almost entirely scammers. Have a look at 'moisterizers' - it's a ridiculous game of false and misleading information by so called 'reputable' companies using technology totally out of context i.e. 'collagen' in order to be able to put it on the label. There's nary a way to understand what is effective and what is not. It's a completely distorted market. Now, it's just moisturizer, so it doesn't matter. But we don't want the same thing for diabetes drugs, now do we? The financial system is highly, highly regulated because it used to be full of outright scams and the system couldn't grow without it. Integrity is key to all long term growth, it's why we have rules. Now it should be possible to invest in highly speculative, risky things - sure - that should be up to you - but the reason we don't want to allow that in some instances is because the mechanism itself is fraudulent and misrepresentation i.e. a Ponzi Scheme is a Ponzi Scheme and it's bad to have them going around, even if you want to invest in them. The entire field of Crypto thus far has been a giant distraction and waste of time, while there is definitely the possibility of some good coming out of this, it hasn't happened yet, we should be in the experimental stage, not the 'using up more electricity than Argentina stage'.
- thepasswordis 5y agoMaybe it's my money and I should be able to do whatever I want with it? I don't want the SEC "protecting" me from things like ethereum. I don't even want the SEC "protecting" me from things like cardano, or "SHIBE" or "safemoon". Maybe provide recommendations, but it's my money. Or is it not my money? It is incredibly frustrating watching The US turn its back on what is quite obviously a major technological/financial paradigm shift. I understand the detractors 10 years ago, but...guys it's been 10 years now and blockchain technology has only increased in penetration into industries. It's not going away. The idea that the US is going to regulate itself away from being the epicenter of this is pathetic. Here's how far along it is: coinbase was a YC company that has already gone through the entire cycle of conception, startup, raising money, and going public with a $50B market cap. People like this stuff. It's not going to go away like a fad.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoWhat's written on your dollar bill?
- ur-whale 5y ago> your dollar bill? Therein lies the problem: using dollars to conduct business with other economic entities. If you can figure out way to escape that particular snare (and cryptos are such a hatch), the paradigm isn't the same anymore.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Maybe it's my money and I should be able to do whatever I want with it? I feel your pain, but you are deeply deluded: it never was your money in the first place. There are letting you play with it if you agree to play by their rules. If you don't, the government can take it back anytime it wants to, using any manufactured pretext it wants.
- mistrial9 5y agodon't be so quick to give up what rights you have ! it is a system of systems, and you are in it
- loraxclient 5y agoIs this a summary or the entire text? I think I saw messaging from Coinbase in anticipation of this proposal earlier this week. [1] Not a lawyer but the definitions and language seem a little shallow to me considering how lofty the proposal of a new regulatory agency is. Wouldn’t one expect a higher level of detail, supporting evidence, citations or legal precedent from consultations with “30+ crypto firms, 25+ members of congress and/or staff, 4 major law firms, and 3 trade groups”? [1] https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/1443712282953859103?s=21 https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/14437122829538591...
- airstrike 5y agoI'll just leave this here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Act_of_1933#Purpose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Act_of_1933#Purpose > The primary purpose of the '33 Act is to ensure that buyers of securities receive complete and accurate information before they invest in securities. Unlike state blue sky laws, which impose merit reviews, the '33 Act embraces a disclosure philosophy, meaning that in theory, it is not illegal to sell a bad investment, as long as all the facts are accurately disclosed. A company that is required to register under the '33 act must create a registration statement, which includes a prospectus, with copious information about the security, the company, the business, including audited financial statements. The company, the underwriter and other individuals signing the registration statement are strictly liable for any inaccurate statements in the document. This extremely high level of liability exposure drives an enormous effort, known as "due diligence", to ensure that the document is complete and accurate. The law bolsters and helps to maintain investor confidence which in turn supports the stock market.
- hackingforfun 5y agoStocks were never open source code. Anyone can research a crypto, online. We don't need a walled garden for them.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoCrypto falls under regulation when regulators believe it falls within the scope of their regulatory obligations. Whether the code is open source is immaterial. This is the result of the "code is law" gang running into the "law is law" gang.
- hackingforfun 5y agoSecurities laws were about disclosures, right? Since many cryptos are open source, how is that immaterial?
- jollybean 5y ago
- ARandumGuy 5y agoTwo things popped out to me, under the disclosure requirements section: > c. Digital tokens that are earlier in the life cycle, and not yet decentralized, should have a minimum set of disclosures. This seems odd to me, because aren't tokens "earlier in the life cycle" full of scams and dishonesty? Shouldn't the disclosure requirements be higher? > d. Asset-backed tokens, like stablecoins [...] require a different type of disclosure. The disclosures should be appropriate to how they are being used, which is inherently different from money market funds. Disclosures "appropriate to how they are being used" seems like it could easily be interpreted as "whatever the stablecoin provider thinks is appropriate." In any case, since stablecoin providers promise a specific amount of value in assets for every coin, they should require full transparency to ensure that value actually exists. Overall, this piece seems like a clear attempt at bypassing regulation, instead of actually trying to obey the existing regulations. The question I have is "what problems do you have with the existing regulations", and I suspect the answer is "because we would be caught doing shady shit."
- fleddr 5y agoPersonally, I find the "shitcoin" part of crypto the least interesting target for potential regulation. Some are outright scams (say 1 in 10), many just poor investments (about 8 in 10), but for the most part the crypto community willingly engages with these coins, knowing the risk. What I find much more important in terms of consumer protection is exchange regulation. Mainstream use of crypto will overwhelmingly be via exchanges and wallet apps, and quite obviously, your money shouldn't just disappear because of incompetence, a hack, a bug or bad intent. Adding protection or regulation here may make crypto far less scary. I extend this concern to DeFi, which largely means staking. Right now, it basically means giving up custody of your coin to others, whom in some cases may "lose" it. I would consider both use cases, just parking a coin and staking it, absolutely critical for mainstream usage and as the amount of money exponentially increases, it becomes ever important that at least basic protection is in place. At the same time, you don't want to add so much regulation that it crumbles the entire space.