3 ms·
> It’s not popular to say but we need to stabilize population growth Is it not? Where, and why? > provide them with prophylactics Kinda problematic for orgs
by triceratops 5y ago
> It’s not popular to say but we need to stabilize population growth
Is it not? Where, and why?
> provide them with prophylactics
Kinda problematic for orgs that rely on US foreign aid.[1]
"The policy originally enacted from 1984 to 1993 spoke to abortion only, not family planning in general. However, in 2001, the policy was re-implemented and expanded to cover all voluntary family planning activities, and critics began to refer to it as the "global gag rule." These critics argue that the policy not only reduces the overall funding provided to particular NGOs, it closes off their access to USAID-supplied condoms and other forms of contraception. This, they argue, negatively impacts the ability of these NGOs to distribute birth control, leading to a downturn in contraceptive use and from there to an increase in the rates of unintended pregnancies and abortion. A study of nations in sub-Saharan Africa suggests that unintended pregnancies increased and abortions approximately doubled while the policy was in effect. Critics also argue that the ban promotes restrictions on free speech as well as restrictions on accurate medical information. The European Parliamentary Forum on Population and Development presented a petition to the United States Congress signed by 233 members condemning the policy. The forum has stated that the policy "undermines internationally agreed consensus and goals"."
The global gag rule is enforced by Republican administrations and rescinded by Democratic ones. Infer from that what you will.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexico_City_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexico_City_policy
- bordercases 5y agoThe Green Revolution was predicated on the idea that we should increase calorie yields now to prevent famine shocks in key third world populations. The most efficient way to perform well on this single metric is with monoculture and cash crops, due to economy of scale. This is humane, but it doesn't slowed down population growth, which requires either a bottleneck or a set of loose constraints aside if we want to maintain a constant food yield, ceteris paribus the way we grow food now.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoAll well and good, but thecountries of Africa are 't the problem. They're not the ones consuming resources disproportionately to their populations. Is population an issue? Yes, probably. But it's (Western) (over) consumption that got us here, and continues to escalate the crisis. The less distractions for that, the better.
- triceratops 5y agoI'm not disputing anything you're saying. My response, a rebuttal to "we need to focus on population reduction", was about 2 things: 1. Countries with high population growth numbers do, in fact, focus on bringing those numbers down. China and India have had widespread family planning programs for decades and those have borne fruit. 2. The country with the highest per-capita consumption in the world conditions a lot of its foreign aid on recipients not promoting family planning. Meanwhile, Internet commenters from that country grumble about poor countries' population numbers.