4 ms·
Firefox 9 will be out this December, lol, https://wiki.mozilla.org/RapidRelease/Calendar https://wiki.mozilla.org/RapidRelease/Calendar Who on earth though thi
by ck2 15y ago
Firefox 9 will be out this December, lol, https://wiki.mozilla.org/RapidRelease/Calendar https://wiki.mozilla.org/RapidRelease/Calendar
Who on earth though this was a good idea?
So, every six weeks a new release - that means Version 15 this time next year. Seriously?
- ch0wn 15y agoI don't see the problem. Version numbers no longer matter as long as browsers are concerned. IE is an exception, as always.
- nirvdrum 15y agoThrough my line of work I end up seeing a lot of nuanced differences between browser version numbers. It's kind of a myth that browser versions (usually read as releases -- not actual version numbers) don't matter any more. I see things break quite regularly that people don't expect. And while browsers on the whole are getting better, the slow introduction of CSS 3 and HTML 5 features make a huge difference.
- st3fan 15y agoWhat is the problem exactly? You don't like updates that improve things a lot? Really, it is just a version number.
- ck2 15y agoThey are MAJOR version numbers. Are all these going to major changes in GUI, API, backend? Are you okay with Version 20 by next December? Version 35 the December after that? Or should version 6 really be version 5.2 ?
- ordinary 15y agoThis really, really does not matter.
- jellicle 15y agoThe problem is that, like the boy that cried wolf, they have no way to get attention if they actually want it. Say that version 32 introduces a "do what I mean" feature where the browser simply goes to whatever site you want, no user interaction required. How are they going to publicize that version 32 is more important than 31 or 33 or 27, all of which were tiny incremental upgrades?
- ordinary 15y agoThey could name it Firefox XP, I guess. All silliness aside, I see your point. But is the browser really still at a point where such earth-shifting changes are likely to occur? The biggest single change of the last few years that I can think of is the addition of tabs to browers, and even that is a feature that's been around for 20 years in other programs. Any change that's much bigger than that almost warrants a whole new product, regardless of your numbering scheme.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- zobzu 15y agoSo? Is it suddenly bad if its version 20 or 409? It could also be 0.409 or 20112012 Or 0293.3948.2933.12.409 Or FE39D9A of all these, 409 is the most readable anyway.
- tom9729 15y agoIf the version number is meaningless (hint: it doesn't have to be) then why bother mentioning it at all?
- tom9729 15y agoVersion numbers aren't meaningless if you have a good system, e.g. major/minor/patch. You just can't use them to compare between two different products. I know Moz wants to be a bit more like Chrome with frequent releases but it seems like this could be done a bit more sensibly wrt the version number.
- wmf 15y agoWhen you release every six weeks, there will never be a major release. Thus you end up with version numbers like 2.6.39.
- tom9729 15y ago1) The patch number is for things like bug and security fixes, and gets reset every time the major/minor version gets bumped. 2) Every 6 week release you bump the minor version _unless_ some big feature(s) are ready to be rolled in, in which case you bump the major version instead.
- kylec 15y agoI agree, the new version numbers are stupid. If they wanted to copy Chrome's rapid-release schedule, they should have just ditched the version numbers altogether (like Chrome) and just continuously and transparently kept their install base up to date. There's also a real practical problem to fast-growing version numbers. Historically, a major release would have major new features and might break existing extensions. Minor releases were typically safe to install and were designed to be as compatible as possible with the version they were supplanting. With new major versions of Firefox coming out every 6 weeks you're constantly checking to make sure they haven't changed something critical.
- markokocic 15y agoWhy is this a problem for FF, and not a problem for Chrome, since they are doing practically the same thing now?
- nxn 15y agoChrome has version numbers. And similarly, firefox doesn't make a big deal about new version releases since 4.0 was out. The ones that do make a big deal out of them are blogs and tech sites, but those will get bored of doing so soon enough.
- tghw 15y agoChrome hides the version number, because 98% of the time, it doesn't matter. There's no mention of it on there download page (http://www.google.com/chrome/ http://www.google.com/chrome/). They make it available only if you need to get specific. Firefox, OTOH, still advertises their version number right on the download button (http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/new/ http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/new/).
- nxn 15y agoNot sure if I'd call that "advertising" -- it's a small green number on a green background. Before the rapid release schedule you'd have a 72pt version number hitting you in the face when you went to their main page within a week of a major release. Never the less, I see what you mean about it being still "visible" to the user.