3 ms·
I'm not deeply familiar with webauthn -- what happens when a user loses their device/private key? Can they still do an account recovery? If it's a standard "l
by jedberg 5y ago
I'm not deeply familiar with webauthn -- what happens when a user loses their device/private key? Can they still do an account recovery?
If it's a standard "lost password" flow, in which case it still suffers from the same weaknesses of the lost password flow?
- aseipp 5y agoToday, with WebAuthn, recovery works the exact same way. Which is normally by emailing the user a magical link to a (trusted) address that does some recovery flow. There's nothing different about this, and how much of a weak link it is depends on your risk assessment, I guess. WebAuthn makes other classes of "first-party" attacks like phishing and credential stuffing impossible to perform, however, which is a huge benefit. So on the whole I see it as an improvement, but there could still be a lot improved. Honestly saying that part out loud, one of the annoying parts of it all now is that the credential store for WebAuthn is now effectively per-application, not per-user. So you need "number-of-browsers * number-of-devices" different registrations, which is basically annoying enough to mean I still use 1Password. In some fancy world, the actual credential store could be some kind of persistent, per-user system service provided to any application, and they would all share these credentials. Sort of like Apple Keychain on steroids, basically, but it needs to work everywhere, on all platforms, and be adopted consistently by applications.
- MarkSweep 5y agoApple has a technical preview in iOS 15 and macOS Monterey that stores the WebAuthn credentials in iCloud. This lets you have passwordless WebAuthn login, without registering each device separately. https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2021/10106 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2021/10106 It's only works in the Apple ecosystem currently and is only a technical preview, but it's a cool idea to reduce the number of registrations you have to do and reduce the chance of getting locked out of websites by losing your WebAuthn key.
- dwaite 5y ago> It's only works in the Apple ecosystem currently and is only a technical preview, but it's a cool idea to reduce the number of registrations you have to do and reduce the chance of getting locked out of websites by losing your WebAuthn key. There is work being done to try to create a realistically usable cross-device (e.g. mobile phone as authenticator to my desktop) support leveraging Bluetooth LE. One could hope for a future where say an iPhone with these WebAuthn "PassKeys" (as Apple branded them) could be used to authenticate with a Windows laptop. There are also draft features which would allow a site to detect you are going cross-platform, and offer to add an additional local Windows Hello mechanism to streamline the process in the future.
- tialaramex 5y agoThis is a matter for the relying party (typically a web site). WebAuthn doesn't define what should happen if you can't do WebAuthn. Yes, if they've got a "lost device" flow that bad guys can easily defeat then, bad guys can easily defeat it.
- gabrielsroka 5y agoYou're encouraged to purchase multiple keys and register them. Keep one in a safe.
- iggldiggl 5y agoHow am I supposed to register multiple keys if some of them are kept in a (possibly off-site) safe? Maybe for some high-value accounts doing that kind of "registering of the keys" ceremony might be worth the hassle, but for everyday usage frictionless this certainly ain't...
- dolni 5y agoThis doesn't solve the issue of somebody traveling and getting mugged. Then what? You're just locked out of everything? That seems very, very inconvenient. There's a reason passwords haven't been usurped yet. It's because these fancy new ideas come with an entire new set of their own problems. These problems are worse than what we deal with for passwords.
- dwaite 5y agoTypically it falls to an account recovery flow, which would be expected to be as strong or stronger than the account creation flow. Obviously sites implement account recovery wrong all the time though. Some systems like Google Advanced Protection Program specifically don't really have alternate means of authentication or a recovery flow. If you register multiple authenticators, you can do a break-the-glass/open-the-safe recovery, but this assumes you remembered to register all authenticators to all sites. There is a proposal to support backup keys via what might be referred to a cryptographic introduction. My primary key can include additional cryptographic data, and if I lose my primary key my backup key can prove that it was the key that was previously mentioned. There is a tech preview by Apple for PassKeys, which is a WebAuthn authenticator which isn't represented by a single piece of hardware but across all the hardware on your Apple account. This reduces the need (or I suppose, increases the trauma) needed to get to an account recovery event.