4 ms·
Your comments are the only ones here which aren’t divorced from reality. It’s weird. Who are these supposed guys paying six figures for this sort of thing? It’s
by renewiltord 5y ago
Your comments are the only ones here which aren’t divorced from reality. It’s weird. Who are these supposed guys paying six figures for this sort of thing? It’s just not a valuable thing.
- tptacek 5y agoI don't know that it's not valuable! It's a good bug, from what I understand of it. The issue here is subtle. It's not that bugs of all stripes don't have plausible value. It's that there isn't a market for most of them. Bugs are small parts of the enterprises that exploit them. To purchase a bug for significant amounts of money, it has to slot into some kind of business process that will profitably† take advantage of it. What people are subtextually observing with these $250k vulnerabilities is that there are a bunch of well-scripted playbooks for profiting from RCE vulnerabilities on widely distributed, unevenly patched devices. There may be no meaningful cap to how much a phone RCE is worth, since the IC's alternative to RCEs is human intelligence work that will dwarf any RCE cost just in health and benefits overhead for personnel. But there just aren't a lot of business processes that profitably exploit stolen contact lists from malicious application installs. You can come up with lots of stories about those processes, but the key thing is that for a bug to be worth a bunch of money, that process already has to exist and be working; the cost of building all the business process stuff around the bug will rival the cost of the bug itself. Bugs have finite lifespans, and "snarf contacts from malicious app" bugs are idiosyncratic, and tend not to be pin compatible with a steady stream of similar bugs that would justify keeping that exploitative process up and running. This is for what it's worth all my own personal weird theory of the situation, and I don't sell or buy bugs. But I have repeated the theory to many people who do either or both, and nobody has told me I'm totally wrong about it. † For some possibly non-economic definition of "profitably"
- dpkonofa 5y agoI'm with you. I think these cheap, Apple-bashing blogs want to make this into a bigger deal but there are a few things that don't add up to make this the huge issue they think it is: 1. The bug lets you download contacts. Nothing else. As you've said, no one's going to pay six figures for a bug that lets you get someone's contacts from GameCenter. If this was even slightly more abstract and didn't specifically deal with just GameCenter, I could see it being valuable for companies that do phone-to-phone transfers, for example, because you could download someone's contacts from a locked device. This isn't that, though. 2. Nowhere in the article, or even the original tweet, does Apple acknowledge or state that he was the person that initially found the bug. They just confirmed that the bug exists and asked him to keep it confidential. It's entirely possible that the reason for the delay is because someone discovered a lower-level bug that rolled up to this and it's a bit less clear-cut who is owed the credit for the fix that they released. They're not just going to go around and pay everyone who claims to have found a bug. They have to verify it and make sure that it's not something they've already discovered through another report or on their own. 3. Sometimes this stuff just takes time. When you're dealing with codebases that as large as this, changing a small thing to fix a bug can unintentionally break a bunch of other things. It's not always a simple matter of "this small piece is broken and is completely independent of everything else". We have no idea if this is or isn't one of those cases because we don't really know much about it (and for good reason).
- WesolyKubeczek 5y ago> 1. The bug lets you download contacts. Nothing else. As you've said, no one's going to pay six figures for a bug that lets you get someone's contacts from GameCenter. If this was even slightly more abstract and didn't specifically deal with just GameCenter, I could see it being valuable for companies that do phone-to-phone transfers, for example, because you could download someone's contacts from a locked device. This isn't that, though. I, the evil overlord, would very much like to know who is ratting out my secret initiatives to those nosy journalists. Maybe some of them don't keep a good information hygiene and will download my simple but quite addictive game? At least I get to know some names and addresses.
- tptacek 5y agoIt's not just that it's contact data; I agree, exposing contact databases is a big deal, and that this (as depicted) is a significant bug. It's that to accomplish that with this bug, you have to install a malicious app from the app store. That is a very high hurdle towards operationalizing the bug, especially since, as I said elsewhere, Apple does API-level surveillance of apps in the app store.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoBut isn't it the reason malicious actors buy legit apps made by small shops to insert what at best is adware/spyware into something that is useful and made a name for itself already? Or make useless copycats, as Kosta Eleftheriou proved already is a way of choice in the iOS App Store.