3 ms·
I would suggest an experiment. All intellectuals complaining about the dumbing down of the generation that follows their own should instead compare pairs of pas
by fauigerzigerk 15y ago
I would suggest an experiment. All intellectuals complaining about the dumbing down of the generation that follows their own should instead compare pairs of past generations and see if they still think that the later generation always has less substance, fewer great thinkers, etc. Because if you read what people write when comparing their own generation (or the one before) to the next you'd have to think the world has been in an intellectual death spiral basically from the start.
It may just take time for great ideas to turn out as such or be interpreted as such. It would be interesting to do an empirical study to see whether the age of ideas at a time when they were first called "great ideas" has changed over time. It would be difficult to do because the concept of "greatness" may itself have gone through fashion cycles.
But maybe he is right and our society suffers from a little bit of "big" idea fatigue after the ideological desasters of the past two centuries that cost many millions of lives.
His complaints about social media seems totally misplaced. Does he really think that the Facebook or twitter event stream is somehow competing with deeper thought in people who would otherwise be thinking more? I don't believe that at all.
Just because a lot of chatter is now public doesn't mean fewer ideas of substance are published or perceived nowadays. Publishing just isn't filtered and curated as hierarchically as it used to be. That may influence the perception of greatness quite a lot.