4 ms·
>Why are people out to crucify Apple for a story that's still being resolved? >The company hasn't denied the bounty, they're just incompetent / slow on this pr
by smoldesu 5y ago
>Why are people out to crucify Apple for a story that's still being resolved?
>The company hasn't denied the bounty, they're just incompetent / slow on this process.
People probably expect more from... checks notes The world's most valuable and successful modern corporation.
- ewagsjr 5y agoYa, if I interpreted this right, also really convenient that they seem to be dragging their feet on a $100,000 bounty.
- dpkonofa 5y agoNobody's going to pay $100,000 for a bug that lets you download someone's contact list.
- brokenmachine 5y agoHow much would a bug like that be worth? I can imagine getting anyone's contact list being valuable.
- dpkonofa 5y agoWhy? What would be valuable about that? Specifically, what would be valuable about getting someone's GameCenter contacts? These aren't business or family contacts. These are people the person games with. It's a privacy violating bug but not a show-stopping bug. Important but not valuable.
- saagarjha 5y agoYou're misunderstanding the vulnerability. The bug is in gamed, the Game Center daemon, but it allows access to the entire CoreDuet database, which does on-device intelligence stuff. Duet essentially logs everything you do on your phone, which means that if you look at the database it'll contain logs for all your interactions, not just those with Game Center contacts.
- dpkonofa 5y agoYou are correct. I did misunderstand that portion of it but that doesn't change the fact that Apple is willing to pay $100k for a bounty like that but no one else does and Apple's actions don't suggest at all that they won't pay out the bounty. If you've ever been part of a program like this, on the developer side, it's possible that they discovered a larger bug that this was a part of or that someone else had already reported this bug. Tracking down the origin of this and the tickets involved takes time and fixing the bug is always the priority. They haven't acknowledged that he's the originator of the report so his insistence that he be credited immediately is a big immature and premature. There's nothing here that suggests Zerodium, or someone similar, would pay the same amount Apple is offering and there's nothing that suggests that Apple doesn't intend to pay this or credit him. That's all completely conjecture.
- saagarjha 5y agoI have no idea if Zerodium would pay out that much for this bug (probably not) or anyone else (maybe?) but Apple in general has a poor track record of paying out bug bounties. They do sometimes, but it seems like it is far rarer than their website says they should.
- dpkonofa 5y ago>Apple in general has a poor track record of paying out bug bounties What is this based on? My understanding is that Apple pays out 99% of the reported bug bounties and that's only because they include multiple submissions in the totals but not in the payouts (they only payout the first discovery or root discovery).
- smoldesu 5y agohttps://habr.com/en/post/579714/ https://habr.com/en/post/579714/ thunderspy.io/ Those are my favorite recent examples, but specifically Apple has huge issues with turnaround time. They also don't communicate with or assist the researchers who found these exploits either, which makes things particularly frustrating for people who ultimately both want to secure Apple's systems. Their overt hostility, history of poor communication, and frankly pathetic bug bounties are all contributors to how people perceive Apple's relationship with security experts.
- efleurine 5y agoAnd iOS users should be grateful that they report those bugs to Apple to get paid. They could also sell it to some spying companies and may be those pay well and very fast
- jsjohnst 5y ago> and may be those pay well and very fast Pay very well? Often, assuming they actually pay, sometimes you can get stiffed there too. Very fast? Nope. Easy to work with? Nope. Communicate with you any better than Apple through the process? Not usually.
- smoldesu 5y agoHave you dealt with terrorist orgs in the past, or is this all conjecture?
- jsjohnst 5y ago> They could also sell it to some spying companies The above type of organization is what I was referring to. So if you consider the grey market buyers[⋁] of exploits “terrorist orgs”, then yes. If you use the normal definition of “terrorist orgs”, then hell no. [⋀] three letter government agencies, defense contractors, and those who sell to them
- tptacek 5y agoOr maybe they don't pay for these bugs at all.