3 ms·
Scalzi's article about "Being Poor" is definitely not a description of poverty in the United States. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1713461 http://news.yc
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Scalzi's article about "Being Poor" is definitely not a description of poverty in the United States.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1713461 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1713461
- wpietri 15y agoYes, I am certainly going to believe your hazy handwaving over his direct statements: http://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/#comment-64682 http://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/#comment-64... Of course, I didn't need that to know where he went wrong: I know actual poor people in the US. Maybe you should go meet some.
- yyyyyyy5 15y agoMy family is actually at the bottom 1%. We can afford a solid standard of living at $15K-$20K salaries because of corporate behemoths like Walmart, which I assume you despise, feed, clothe, and entertain our family at $15 per day. Maybe you shouldn't generalize about poor people.
- wpietri 15y agoIf you have salaries (plural!) in the $15-20k range, then you are nowhere near the bottom 1%: http://www.data360.org/dsg.aspx?Data_Set_Group_Id=2363 http://www.data360.org/dsg.aspx?Data_Set_Group_Id=2363 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States The poverty line for one person is $10.9k. For a family of four, $22.4k. That covers circa 15% of the population. For comparison, the median income is $44k, so if you're making $30-40k per year (assuming two salaries) then that's not far from the average American household.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoDo you disagree with any of the statistics I've cited? Or are you merely dismissing them as "handwaving" because they don't fit your preconceived notions?
- wpietri 15y agoI notice you've dodged my question three times in a row. I don't agree or disagree with your statistics. They're irrelevant, because Scalzi is describing things he has seen, and that match things I have seen. In the lives of actual poor people. In the US.
- yyyyyyy5 15y agoAre you serious? You're dismissing statistics because you believe your anecdotal evidence holds more weight? You're now an expert on poor people because of the things you have "seen" and someone else has "seen"? Please quit it with the BS. You're not poor. You're not around poor people. Stop describing how poor people live.
- wpietri 15y agoI am dismissing his statistics because they do not have bearing on the question that we were discussing, which is whether or not Scalzi was describing poverty in the US. Scalzi is definitely an expert on what he has seen. I'm an expert on what I have seen. As are the hundreds of other contributors to that discussion. I am definitely not poor now. But we were poor when I was a kid, and only made it through via the help of family and government programs. I am still in regular contact with people who are not as lucky as I was. So enough with your baseless assertions, ok?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI ignored the question because the answer is irrelevant. One can gain knowledge about the world via statistics, not merely personal acquaintance, and statistics also tend to be more useful. However, to answer your question, yes. I know poor people. I've lived most of my adult life in poor neighborhoods. My experiences tend to agree with what the official statistics say - most poor people eat enough or perhaps too much (virtually none are underfed), don't work much and do not live in overcrowded homes. These are the specific points on which I disagreed with Scalzi. I cited statistics which back up my position. You are also dodging a question, so I'll ask it again: which set of statistics do you disagree with? The BLS, the Census or the USDA?