7 ms·
Kape Now Owns ExpressVPN, CyberGhost, PIA, Zenmate, and VPN “Review” Sites
- chuckee 5y agoShouldn't some kind of anti-trust agency forbid such mergers, or break them up after the fact? At least in an alternate world where anti-trust law was still enforced.
- SahAssar 5y agoAnti-trust is meant to protect competition against monopolies, not everything against anything evil. At least that's how I've understood it. It'd be hard to argue that Kape is even close to becoming a monopoly.
- missedthecue 5y agoRight. There are dozens of different VPN providers and switching costs are pretty low.
- nitrogen 5y agoAIUI antitrust also covers cartels, e.g. this one from the early 20th century controlling lightbulbs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel
- SahAssar 5y agoIsn't a cartel a type of threat to competition via monopoly? The wikipedia first-line definition of a cartel is "A cartel is a group of independent market participants who collude with each other in order to improve their profits and dominate the market". The monopoly in that case is by the group.
- nitrogen 5y agoIt seems like a cartel can form without having a collective monopoly. It's the collusion that's problematic, not the combined percentage.
- roywiggins 5y agoThere's no Kape cartel if they just own lots of brands, Kape can't collude with itself...
- tablespoon 5y ago> Shouldn't some kind of anti-trust agency forbid such mergers, or break them up after the fact? At least in an alternate world where anti-trust law was still enforced. Even without anti-trust, it should be illegal to own or buy a "review site" for something you sell. That kind of thing is very counter to consumer interests and a blatant conflict of interest.
- ortusdux 5y agoI frequently encounter 1-off review sites that are owned by the #1 product on the list. Many are transparent about it, and some even do a good job listing their competitors and describing them in a fair light. I think they are mostly a response to Google's algorithms prioritizing reciently published blog style top-10 lists. Here is the first result when I google "best free youtube downloader" https://www.gihosoft.com/hot-topics/best-free-youtube-downloader.html https://www.gihosoft.com/hot-topics/best-free-youtube-downlo...
- xboxnolifes 5y agoI feel like this should fall under advertising laws. Maybe it does and I'm not familiar with the area. Does the review site need to disclose the fact of ownership?
- tablespoon 5y ago> I feel like this should fall under advertising laws. Maybe it does and I'm not familiar with the area. Does the review site need to disclose the fact of ownership? Even if they do, they can probably satisfy the requirement with disclosure where no one would actually notice it. The only kind of disclosure I'd be happy with is if at the top of the page and next to any self-endorsement they would have to show a garish warning banner with a legally mandated design that called out their conflict of interest in blunt terms. It would be easier and better to just ban the practice.
- SahAssar 5y agoThat sort of rule would quickly become very hard to untangle. For example news papers are often the only good source of reliable, in-depth book reviews and for historical reasons the companies that sell books and sell news papers are often owned by the same parent company. In the Kape case I think it is clearly dishonest, and the same can be said for the online order mattress space among others. Most online direct to consumer spaces (for example gaming and anti-virus) probably has some actor that is dishonestly setting up or buying review sites. But it is not exactly clear how you would in a legal sense draw the line.
- killingtime74 5y agoI studied competition law and I think the regulators would probably struggle to even understand what a VPN is
- GekkePrutser 5y agoThey don't even have to though. All they have to know is that it's a market.
- killingtime74 5y agoThey won’t look to investigate if they don’t even understand the product
- dehrmann 5y agoI suppose, but they have better things to do with their time than prevent consolidation in the snake oil market.
- mleonhard 5y agoI'm not sure who I trust less, a shady Israeli proxy (VPN) company that claims not to track you, or Verizon/AT&T/T-Mobile/Comcast who successfully lobbied the US Government for permission to record and sell your network behavior, or Webpass (Google).
- dehrmann 5y agoHow much of your traffic is HTTPS and do you use DoH? I guess reverse DNS mappings can still get you something.
- egberts1 5y agoThe entire vertical industry segment? Or is that horizontal?? Or is it the entire path of an industry segment? Yeah, just a path, a control path, to market control.
- ucha 5y agoYet Sven Taylor recommended ExpressVPN for years despite the fact that its ownership was quite suspect (secret). We've never fully known who was behind it and from where it was truly operated. The ranking of best VPNs on the site is mostly a ranking of VPNs that offer the largest referral fees [1]. One of the largest, most honest and transparent VPN, Mullvad, does not have an affiliate program. And guess what, it's not even reviewed on Restore Privacy! [1] https://onemorecupof-coffee.com/best-vpn-affiliate-programs/ https://onemorecupof-coffee.com/best-vpn-affiliate-programs/
- ouEight12 5y ago> The ranking of best VPNs on the site is mostly a ranking of VPNs that offer the largest referral fees [1]. Can't we replace "VPNs" with pretty much any service at this point though? I haven't trusted 'review/ranking' sites in ages, because after see the same top 5 "best hosting providers ever!" lists one 3 sites, you kind of get a hint.
- ohashi 5y agoAs someone who has been working on an honest web hosting review site for a decade now. You're totally right. I see the same pattern in this article talking about fake review sites. The biggest offender in hosting was Endurance International Group who owned so many major brands and gobbled them up. You'd often find any ranking full of the brands they owned (BlueHost, HostGator, iPage, JustHost, Site5, Arvixe, etc, etc, etc). Since you're really skeptical, I'd love to hear your take on what I've done (and been doing) in terms of trying to create an honest system. The gist is, I scrape Twitter data, filter out spam, affiliate links, etc, and use sentiment analysis to see which brands people actually like. My hypothesis was that reviews are fundamentally a weird human behavior. The real 'reviews' are embedded in normal conversation when you talk to people. With enough data of these signals, you can get a much better picture of what people really think. The results seem to line up basically like an NPS measurement. https://reviewsignal.com/webhosting/compare https://reviewsignal.com/webhosting/compare has all my data if you want to see how the rankings actually look. Not every company has an affiliate program. Many smaller companies aren't listed because I can't get enough data.
- consumer451 5y agoIf I was in charge of intel ops for any country with a decent budget, first thing I would do is build or buy a VPN company. You have a self-selected group of people with something to hide. What could be more ideal to gather kompromat?
- bryanrasmussen 5y agomost often though the thing they're hiding is watching movies and shows they couldn't get in their country otherwise. But the great thing about the vpn is some people leave it on and forget about it. So then you invest in a free porn service.
- consumer451 5y ago> most often though the thing they're hiding is watching movies and shows they couldn't get in their country otherwise. Sure, but the .0001% of users who use grindr while trying to hide their preferences, and hold a position of influence in government or a corporation make the whole effort worthwhile. As a bonus, the op is actually profitable because the 99.9999% of people you don't care about, and don't have to spend man-hours on, are actually paying for all the man-hours that you spend on the people of interest! The intel flywheel is up and spinning! edit: this is all conjecture.
- Ansil849 5y agoThere are hundreds, if not thousands, of VPN services. Why would someone you care about targeting use your specific one? Or is the point that you're just conducting a massive dragnet operation to see what you find? In that case, it's probably way cheaper to just send agents out to search people's trash every night /s.
- srg0 5y agoThere are hundreds of vpn services, but as the topic article tells us more and more of them are owned by the same entity. And this same entity tries to obscure this fact. And this same entity under a different name was allegedly "involved in browser hijacking, malicious software bundlers, adware, and other monetization methods" (Crossrider past). This same entity is registered in a country with influential and capable intelligence services, and not particularly known for its privacy laws. And if you google names behind this entity, you'll find mentions of bribery, jail time, gambling industry, and Israeli intelligence. I don't see why you put /s on your post.
- mig39 5y agoI just signed up for 3 months of Mullvad a few weeks ago. So far so good. Didn't even need my name or anything. I paid anonymously. It's super fast with wireguard. No affiliate links, no special discounts, no special sales prices. No coupon codes. Just privacy.
- throwawaysea 5y agoHow do you pay anonymously?
- nabaraz 5y agoGiftcards or crypto. You could even mail cash to pay for it.
- dtn 5y agoYou can snailmail them cash along with a random token you get from their website/account management page, and that gets credited to your account. https://mullvad.net/en/pricing/ https://mullvad.net/en/pricing/
- KennyBlanken 5y agoEvery single piece of postal mail is scanned front/back. If you've signed up for the USPS's delivery notification stuff for your mailbox, that's where the scanned "previews" come from. And it's notable how often those previews show a pretty good representation of what's inside, even without messing with the preview image in an image editor to play with the levels/contrast/etc. So yeah, if you'd like to hand the feds evidence you're using a VPN, go right ahead, mail Mullvad cash?
- Tsiklon 5y agoI would assume the person mailing them cash is not sending it from their mailbox on their property, but instead a public access mailbox in a town or city. If you’re worried about being actively followed by the feds and they’re tracking you drop that letter, you have much, much more to worry about than your VPN usage.
- rodgerd 5y agoIsn't this the outfit associated with the "Emperor of Korea" who took over Freenode?
- SkyMarshal 5y agoNot really, the Emperor sold PIA to Kape, but that's the only known association, and the association seemed to end there.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Isn't this the outfit associated with the "Emperor of Korea" who took over Freenode? “Crown Prince”; the would-be Emporer who named him is still alive.
- superflit2 5y agoIs there a reason why people are not using distributed/blockchain VPNs as https://mysterium.network https://mysterium.network? I cant understand why put your data on these shady VPNs.
- Saris 5y agoI don't trust that the exit nodes are safe.
- null0pointer 5y agoBecause nobody wants to host an exit node.
- superflit2 5y agoNo you dont. If you use your free credits you can buy more. No need to host an exit node.
- NicoJuicy 5y agohttps://privacyguides.org/providers/vpn/ https://privacyguides.org/providers/vpn/ A community led guide for the best VPN's.