3 ms·
These sorts of things always get circumvented, but I wish the CoD players fun during the 1-2 week gap where the cheaters are still figuring it out. I've actual
by bee_rider 5y ago
These sorts of things always get circumvented, but I wish the CoD players fun during the 1-2 week gap where the cheaters are still figuring it out.
I've actually figured out the permanent solution to cheaters. Oddly enough, I worked it out in Pokemon Unite, which doesn't have a cheating problem as far as I know, but does have items that you can buy to boost your character stats. The solution is easy: play a game with a good ranking system, and don't get too sweaty about the whole thing. People who use non-skill based tools like cheating or paid boosts will shoot right up the rankings and leave you behind to play in peace. If somebody has a cheating tool that is so subtle that they play all the way down at my level, it is arguably not a real help anyway.
- IanSanders 5y agoI have a different solution. Shadowban. Let them play against each other and bots. Decrease network performance. In rng based situations, roll low most of the time.
- InitialLastName 5y agoHaving cheaters go up the rankings will invalidate peoples' internet points though. If developers undermine the perceived value of the Skinner Box rewards, players might disconnect the vacuum hose from their wallets.
- dTal 5y agoI agree that going to extraordinary lengths to prevent software augmentation of gameplay is attacking the wrong thing. What does it matter, if people are still having fun? But software augmentation doesn't just improve apparent skill, it can also distort gameplay. What if you're really skilled and you get matched with what amounts to a bot? Even if you're good enough to overcome the bot and win the game, it won't be the game you signed up to play. The real problem here is "annoying play styles", something that humans are capable of indulging in without any software help. This is usually policed - ineffectively - by social pressure ("no camping!"). The real solution is an extension of the ranking system - a reputation system, which tracks sportsmanship. All of these problems ultimately stem from the practice of connecting vast numbers of anonymous strangers with each other - cheatbots simply aren't an issue when you play with your friends. This is a social problem.
- bee_rider 5y agoI wonder if they could outsource this to the crowd. With things like Twitch, there are already lots of eyeballs on some of the higher-skill games. I mean you couldn't trust the twitch chat to actually do banning, but maybe they could flag things for in-house human review. Independent of that and completely niche -- a game where they specifically themed it as some sort of 'gladiatorial combat,' and ranked the players based on crowd response could be cool. I definitely wouldn't want that in every game, but it could be a neat spin-off.
- Shish2k 5y ago> The solution is easy: play a game with a good ranking system A lot of games do this, and the cheater’s response is to deliberately lose a bunch of games so that they drop down to the lower leagues, where they can more effectively harass the noobs
- bee_rider 5y agoThis ought to be detectable server-side (freeze a player's rank if you see a sudden dip over more than a couple games, or maybe have a ranking system that is always increasing). It is also a problem independent of cheaters.