6 ms·
The problem is getting low to middle income people to stop voting against themselves. Good luck with that, they all seem to think they are going to be billionai
by ck2 15y ago
The problem is getting low to middle income people to stop voting against themselves. Good luck with that, they all seem to think they are going to be billionaires someday so better keep those billionaire taxes low.
Either that or by bribing the wealthy with low taxes they might only ship out half the jobs overseas instead of all of them.
It's just dumbfounding. Election after election, over and over.
- breck 15y ago"The great bulk of the legal voters of the South were men who owned no slaves; their homes were generally in the hills and poor country; their facilities for educating their children, even up to the point of reading and writing, were very limited; their interest in the contest was very meagre—what there was, if they had been capable of seeing it, was with the North; they too needed emancipation. -Ulysses S. Grant People fighting or voting against their own self interest has gone on for a long time, sadly.
- ck2 15y agoI've come to the conclusion that the logic becomes "well if I can't have it, no-one will". People basically trying to take away assistance/help to others by trying to vote it away from everyone, since they somehow perceive themselves as better than others suffering on the lower rungs on society. This also explains why people try to vote away unions and benefits for teachers/schools, the very foundation of society, while they are okay with CEOs having multi-million annual stock bonuses while getting paid $1 to dodge taxes.
- dwolfson20 15y agoPeople can't vote away multi-million dollar CEO bonuses, though.
- ck2 15y agoThey vote against "clawback" taxes on those bonuses, it's the same thing as saying the bonuses are okay.
- learc83 15y agoThere is a huge difference between voting on compensation for public employees, and punitive taxation on private employees. Plus the vast majority wouldn't vote for teacher pay cuts. There are a few exceptions, but look at the trends for education spending. America spends more per capita on education than most developed countries.
- rdtsc 15y agoThere is a another process that takes place "I am not poor, I am just pre-wealthy". The biggest scam is that the wealthy have managed to convince even the poorest that they are just a "little hard work" away from being a successful owner of family business or the next Donald Trump. It is the American Dream. So ... they should vote accordingly and just get their future selves those nice tax cuts for when they become wealthy. There is also the good'ol "trickle down" trick. Vote for us and we'll trickle it down, we promise...
- niels_olson 15y agoSteinbeck: “Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat, but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires.”
- arethuza 15y agoI was pretty surprised when I learned about Huey Long - he was a genuinely left-wing US pre-war politician (including Governor of Louisiana and Senator). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huey_Long http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huey_Long Unfortunately he was assassinated in 1935 :-(
- dget 15y agoI think your last sentence is painfully false. I don't think most people are OK with CEOs dodging taxes. I also don't think they have the slightest clue (I sure don't..) of what to do with it. These things are decided in the details (capital gains vs income in this case) that I think can very easily fly past most people. Then it comes down to rhetoric/politics, and no one ends up winning once it's at that point. I also don't think that people are trying to vote away unions and benefits for teachers/schools, but unions/benefits for crappy teachers/schools. It's incredibly difficult for schools to get rid of bad teachers, and a decent number of people come into contact with it. This doesn't do anything for the other side of the equation — getting less bad teachers, but again, I don't think spite is the reason people vote against teachers unions.
- jonnathanson 15y ago"I've come to the conclusion that the logic becomes "well if I can't have it, no-one will"." I don't think the poor who consistently vote Republican really care about the economics of social services. That's too removed and abstract a concept for them (ironic, given that it affects them directly). Instead, they're voting emotionally: on social values, and on the politics of identity and nationalism. These abstract concepts are very "real" to a lot of Americans, because they're the things people cling to and hold fast when everything else is taken from them. Bear in mind that a lot of these people have seen social values work for them amidst their own circumstances. Those among them who work their asses off, keep out of trouble, go to church, stay clean, and don't overspend will do markedly better than their peers who slack off, abuse government assistance, and engage in reckless behavior. Meanwhile, a preponderance of military personnel are drawn from the families of the working poor -- so these folks eat, breathe, and sleep patriotism. They love America, even if the version of "America" they love is largely a myth. Republicans have become masters of speaking the language of identity politics and values. They understand what tune these guys want to dance to, and they play it flawlessly. Meanwhile, Democrats are tonedeaf. Nevermind that Democrats may actually have the interests of the little guy in mind; they don't speak the little guy's language. And that makes all the difference. Case in point: the Democrats consistently talk about "the middle class," and sometimes "the working class" or "the poor." Meanwhile, Republicans always talk about "Americans." They rarely even speak of classes or social divides. It's a brilliant rhetorical gesture, because it recognizes that the working classes don't enjoy hearing about how shitty their lives are. They don't like the labels. If you ask them, many of them won't even agree that they're "working class" or "poor." They're in denial, and it's a defiant denial. They're too proud to face reality, and when Dems constantly throw the reality of their misery in their faces, they get angry and resentful.
- webXL 15y agoThis assumes low to middle income people are single issue voters and that issue happens to be the effective tax rate of billionaires. What's dumbfounding is that there are people who believe that wealth is zero-sum, and that by taking from the rich and giving to the poor, "justice" would be done, never taking into account what produces wealth or the fact that living standards have improved despite the rich getting richer. 99.9% of us will never become billionaires, but so what? If my neighbor has a nicer car than me, should I try to get the government to raise his taxes and decrease mine? Why not? Here's a possible reason: The conditions that permit my neighbor to drive a nice car are the same conditions that produce billionaires. Just because I want Warren Buffet to be able to keep most of what he produces doesn't mean I believe I will be in his shoes one day, it just means that I don't trust people who are trying to take more of his money in order to improve my life. Warren may trust those people, but his life really doesn't need much improvement now, does it?
- dreww 15y agoliving standards have improved despite the rich getting richer. Citation needed. Please explain how the living standard in the US can have improved if real wages have fallen. Oh wait, the answer is an incredible increase in consumer debt. That seems to be working out. Keep calm and carry on.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoPlease explain how the living standard in the US can have improved if real wages have fallen. If by "real wages", you mean "wages adjusted for chained CPI" (this is what most people mean), the answer is because the basket of goods used to compute CPI has become larger. I.e., consider the following scenario. In year 0, there is one good - food. A basket of food costs $100. In year 1, medicine is invented, and the cost of food goes up to $101. Inflation is 1%. The basket of goods is modified to reflect the invention of medicine, and is now comprised of 50% food, 50% medicine. In year 2, the cost of medicine increases 10%, and food decreases by 2%. Chained CPI now reports an inflation rate of 3.45%. Is life worse in year 2 than in year 0? (This is a combined 2-year inflation rate of 4.5%.) Of course not. In year 2, you are paying $99 for a basket of food. In year 0, you are paying $100 for food and Medicine doesn't exist. I have yet to see anyone construct an inflation measurement based on a fixed basket of goods (which is held constant over the years) that shows real wages have gone down.
- chrismealy 15y agoThey don't. Google 'rich state poor state red state blue state'
- tsotha 15y agoAmen to that. Why is it so hard for leftists to understand people voting for small government are voting in their own interest?
- muhfuhkuh 15y agoI didn't know the PATRIOT Act, all those porn scanners, Homeland Security, and decade-long wars were small government. Refresh for me again under what leadership all those started?
- tsotha 15y agoMy memory is a little cloudy as well. Maybe you can tell me who continued all those things, and even extended them. But I thought we were talking about economics.
- Andrew_Quentin 15y agoThat's not really a counter argument. You stated republicans stand for small government, not democrats. You were given concrete examples which disprove what you stated. Arguing that the democrats are just the same is simply stating that republicans do not stand for small government.
- tsotha 15y agoNo, I didn't say Republicans stand for small government. Some of them do. Not enough. But certainly people interested in a small, limited government aren't going to vote for redistributive policies.
- niels_olson 15y agoThe top result being a study by Gelman? I skimmed it, I don't see how it supports your point. Care to elaborate?
- forkandwait 15y agoI keep trying to formulate my take on this, and failing, but here goes anyway: The democratic party and American leftists no longer understand non-college working people and, for the most part, no longer reach out to them. Working people think that the left today advocates either for weirdos or for the completely screwed up, and wants everybody to pay for its programs to help said weirdos and fuckups. There is some valid reason for this impression, with the Great Society programs and affirmative action in the sixties and seventies being partly funded by taxes on the middle classes, along with fiascos like school bussing and over-compensated hiring practices screwing over people who didn't feel like they deserved it. (And poor management of government agencies making them ineffective at cost effective delivery of services.) However, working people don't see themselves as fuckups (because they're not), and they don't have a lot of patience with weirdos. So they aren't going to feel comfortable with the gay marriage/ social worker part of the left (the old union guys were socially very conservative for the most part). Also, most of the left today seems to me to be made up of people who really have no connection to actual poor working class people, so there is automatically a divide that is mobilized by the Karl Roves of the world. Furthermore, if you have ever been lower middle class or "working poor", you learn early that very traditional personal character values can make the difference between you and your family living in a truly shitty situation or rising out of the muck around you to actually have a decent marriage/ nice friends/ safe home. So when college educated lefties come around and tell them to have pity on fuckups and weirdos because its society's fault, or that personal character and traditional values don't matter, any working class person is likely to tell them to go to hell. So today's Republicans mobilize personal character rhetoric, traditionalism rhetoric, and the cultural non-understanding between leftist leadership and working people, and -- voila, working people voting against their own interests. Until the left figures out the working classes again -- which means taking the time to show up in the middle of the country, go to church, eat ribs, etc, etc -- Capital will continue to screw everyone. So quit whining about how stupid working class people are -- nobody represents their interests today, neither left nor right, but at least the Republicans pretend.
- GHFigs 15y agoI think you would get a big kick out of the work of Eric Hoffer.
- Egregore 15y agoDo you think in the interest of those people is rich people going to another country and paying there their taxes?
- pfedor 15y agoI don't think I'm going to be a billionaire someday, and if I did I couldn't care less about tax rates. I do think however that maybe I'll be able to retire some day before I die. But the likelihood of this is very much affected by LTCG rate, wouldn't you agree? Now how is it even fair that long term capital gains taxes even exist? I make some money, I pay taxes on it. I buy whatever instrument I hope will be the best at preserving the value of it (since I know if I just stuff the money under the mattress, I won't be able to buy much with it in say 40 years). After 40 years, the nominal price of the thing I bought will have gone up, chiefly due to inflation. When I sell it, I pay taxes again. How is it not double taxation?