6 ms·
>They take on the entrepreneurial risk and if they're successful Amazon will know exactly how many goods they sell to which customers and from who they get thos
by gruez 5y ago
>They take on the entrepreneurial risk and if they're successful Amazon will know exactly how many goods they sell to which customers and from who they get those goods.
What "entrepreneurial risk" are they taking there? Sending the initial batch of products over and creating a product listing? Are they involved with the design/creation of the product itself? If they're just taking already designed/made products and reselling on amazon, and amazon's cutting them out, I can't say I feel sorry for them losing their middle-man position.
- sumedh 5y ago> What "entrepreneurial risk" are they taking there? Maybe identifying which product is good for the market, who is the best supplier, using social media to market the product and create a demand?
- hef19898 5y agoNot to forget the financial risk of inventory.
- staunch 5y agoThey're taking on financial risk but I wouldn't call it entrepreneurial risk. They can list any number of products at time, risking nothing but money. There's nothing innovative or novel being added to the world. The closest thing to entrepreneurial risk is the "creating demand" claim but that seems unlikely to be very true in most cases. In most cases, they're likely capturing demand on Amazon itself by being among the first to list a product. It seems pretty clear that they're arbitraging and Amazon is taking advantage of its position to out-arbitrage them. In many cases, it seems reasonable to assume Amazon would've tried selling the product themselves regardless. These arbitragers probably just have to accept that the reward for finding new products to arbitrage is very time-limited, because if Amazon doesn't start competing with them, someone else will. This is a great example of a ruthlessness, but highly functional, capitalist market. It seems to work out great for consumers, all things considered.
- short12 5y agoWhat else are they going to lose? Money is kind of a big deal and unless a failed business owner gets a finger taken it is the biggest thing to lose That's a major risk
- staunch 5y agoBesides money, entrepreneurs invest a lot of time and energy. Buying on one market and selling on another is not much more than gambling/speculation/trading. Seems like a real stretch to call it entrepreneurship.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoAnd, importantly, it's also their money. Perhaps personal, perhaps a loan. But they don't get to just pull in VC funding under the assumption that they can burn through it, close shop, and carry on like nothing happened. This is the real entrepreneurial risk.
- flavius29663 5y ago> What "entrepreneurial risk" are they taking there If there was no entrepreneurial risk, why wouldn't Amazon just use it's AI to predetermine all the successful combinations of product+supplier+customers ? There would be zero reason for Amazon to allow third party sellers, except for very niche areas. This is a very predatory practice and I'm amazed they're allowed to do it.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhy does the entrepreneur not just setup their own website, and sell everything themselves?
- gowld 5y agoBecause Amazon offers logistics in exchange for (allegedly) a reasonable fee, not for "steal my trade secrets and undermine my business"
- hospadar 5y agoAlso presumably because lots of shopping activity starts and ends on amazon, and if you aren't listed there, you'll lose sales.
- ZetaZero 5y ago> and if you aren't listed there [on Amazon], you'll lose sales. Those sales were never yours to lose, right?
- kongolongo 5y agoThat's true, but I think there's a solid case for why this type of practice is anti-competitive and unfair. Let's say I own a restaurant and instead of improving my food or service I go to my competitor's food suppliers and offer them extra money to not sell to any of my competitors. In isolation, there shouldn't be anything wrong with me making an agreement with another private corporation, but the effect of this is that it creates an unfair playing field for my competition. Amazon's position as both the marketplace and a competitor in that marketplace, creates very similar "unfair" circumstances that benefit them uniquely on that marketplace (for example placing their offerings higher up in search results, or creating special "recommendations" specifically for their offerings, etc) not to mention, the unique access to information that they have into how well their competitors do (which is not inherently unfair, but when combined with all of the other aspects does make a decent case for fitting the "unreasonably constraining competition" section of anti-trust law)
- alasano 5y agoThey pay Amazon for that middle-man position already. And then Amazon gets to determine that it's more profitable for them to also compete with you in addition to taking the cut from your sales.
- MR4D 5y agoI find it interesting the FedEx hasn’t entered this market by purchase someone like Square and competing with Amazon. At this pace, left unchecked, Amazon is going to destroy their business as well.
- Bombthecat 5y agoI properly should buy some amazon stock then..
- hef19898 5y agoI don't know about the US, in Europe FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) is getting competition from affiliates from Hermes (the logistics arm of Otto Group, one Amazon's biggest competition in Germany) and others. Multi marketplace capability and cost being among the main reasons.