5 ms·
> Ethnic studies sounds like a valuable thing to add to baseline education As far as I can tell, it’s just a thinly disguised effort to socialize brown kids in
by rayiner 5y ago
> Ethnic studies sounds like a valuable thing to add to baseline education
As far as I can tell, it’s just a thinly disguised effort to socialize brown kids into identity politics. It’s an experiment that risks derailing the economic convergence that’s we’re seeing with Latinos and could cut the legs out from under Asian upward mobility.
I was seething when I got an email from my school saying they’d be teaching my (brown) kids to develop their “identity” around “skin color” but hey what can you do. The liberals get what the liberals want.
- tptacek 5y agoPresumably that's how the liberals in Texas and Florida feel, too. This comment would be better without the last sentence.
- rayiner 5y agoConservatives don’t have the weight of the NEA and AFT behind them, not to mention the country’s teacher’s colleges and EdD-granting institutions. I’m in a purple county (+38 for Larry Hogan) and it’s an uphill battle against identity politics even here. Moreover, conservatives support the educational status quo, which is at least a known quantity. America of the few countries in the world where minority immigrants have similar upward mobility to natives of the majority ethnic group. The changes liberals are trying to impose on our education risk socializing minority children into the ethnic identity ghettos you see in nearly every other multi-ethnic society. Liberals are going to get the change they want, and we’ll just have to cross our fingers and hope it doesn’t derail the American assimilation engine.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm just saying, you had an interesting thing to say, and you spent one of your most valuable sentences asking me to weigh liberal irrationality against conservative irrationality. I immediately blanked on what it was you were trying to say and had to go read it again. It's just bad writing. I'm not asking you to like liberals. I'm one of them, and I find them frustrating too.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Conservatives don’t have the weight of the NEA and AFT behind them, not to mention the country’s teacher’s colleges and EdD-granting institutions. Yes, practices based in tradition and not evidence have that problem. > Moreover, conservatives support the educational status quo, which is at least a know quantity. Yes, a known to be quite bad quantity, especially by cost effectiveness, in the US. > America of the few countries in the world where minority immigrants have similar upward mobility to natives of the majority ethnic group. America of the few countries in the world where minority immigrants have similar upward mobility to natives of the majority ethnic group. Minorities (especially blacks and American Indians) are ghettoized by the status quo system, in which they do not have equal upward mobility. [0] You play a nice trick talking about immigrants (a small minority of racial and ethnic minorities) and the pretending that covers the bulk of the minority experience, but it does not. [0] https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/3/21/17139300/economic-mobility-study-race-black-white-women-men-incarceration-income-chetty-hendren-jones-porter https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/3/21/17139300/e...
- rayiner 5y ago> Yes, practices based in tradition and not evidence have that problem. Let’s not pretend that education is a practice based in “evidence.” America has among the most professionalized schools systems in the developed world, and also among the worst. My cousin in Sacramento was complaining the other day about how far behind her kid’s school is in math compared to what she learned in Bangladesh in the 1990s. You think we have EdDs? No, just tradition (i.e. practices with a track record of working). > Minorities (especially blacks and American Indians) are ghettoized by the status quo system, in which they do not have equal upward mobility. And ethnic identity politics is part of the status quo system for those groups. At least in the last 30 years, that seems to have hurt more than it’s helped. > You play a nice trick talking about immigrants (a small minority of racial and ethnic minorities) and the pretending that covers the bulk of the minority experience, but it does not. Hispanics and Asians, the vast majority of whom have immigrant backgrounds within the last few generations, comprise 25% of the country, while Black and native Americans comprise 15%. By 2060, the Black and native population share will be about the same, while Asians and Hispanics will be nearly 40% of the population. The liberal approach of projecting the Black and indigenous experience onto all “people of color” is innumerate. Hispanics and Asians are economically converging with whites over time: https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353 https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353. Possibly derailing that convergence (which is pretty much unprecedented in the world) is something everyone should be scared of. The TV show White Lotus had a tremendous illustration of the problem. One of the characters, Paula, is a minority who is college friends with a white girl and comes to Hawaii with the girl’s family. Paula falsely convinces herself that her white friends don’t really care about her. She persuades a (reluctant) native Hawaiian worker at the hotel to steal from her friend’s family, giving some speech she learned at school about stolen land, but he gets caught and arrested. Liberal identity education hurts the affluent “brown” girl by driving an artificial racial wedge between her and her friend who genuinely cares about her, and destroys the life of the working class “brown” boy, by corrupting his traditional morality. I’m not sure it was supposed to be a conservative polemic but it succinctly illustrated exactly what I’m afraid of happening to my own kids as they’re taught to develop an “identity” around their “skin color” in elementary school (according to the email I received recently).