5 ms·

Eh, if you want an airgapped phone, use it in airplane mode. Obviously, the phone needs some network infra for things like updates or timekeeping. You can route

Eh, if you want an airgapped phone, use it in airplane mode. Obviously, the phone needs some network infra for things like updates or timekeeping. You can route it over vpn if you want and you can build everything yourself and host all the servers yourself too if you so prefer. This type of pedantry is more harmful than useful to casual users who would be far better served with grapheneos than some non-existent ideal phone.

hilbert42 5y ago
"...if you want an airgapped phone, use it in airplane mode." Right, that's what I do. In fact this post comes from a smartphone sans SIM with airplane mode on, with a firewall against apps phoning home, no Google or Gmail account, all Google Gapps nuked including playstore - in fact all Gapps have been completely removed - not to mention that most replacement apps come via F-Droid. Yes, technically it's not fully airgapped but it is against Google and that's my main aim. Of course there's a penalty: I also carry around both a pocket router with WiFi and SIM to which the smartphone connects as well as the dumbest of dumb phones just for phone calls. Yes, it's a little inconvenient in that the combined paraphernalia is about equivalent to two normal smartphones (both the router and dumb phone being somewhat smaller). Next step is to upgrade to a Fairphone or equivalent. (I've often wondered where I'd fit on a percentage scale of users who'd go to such lengths - somewhere between 0.1 and 0.001% I suspect.) You may well ask why I've gone to such lenghts. It's more principle than privacy really. It's because governments around the world completely abrogated their responsibility when they deregulated the once-private telephone networks in the 1980s, when they did they let the Wild West take over. This 'vacuum' then led to a depreciation in the value of privacy on telephone networks. The ultimate insult came when the vacuum was filled by the likes of Google and others who usurped the last vestiges of our telephone privacy for good - and these damn governments just stood by and let it happen without so much as whimper. Remember, we telephone users were never first consulted about our privacy - governments just let Google and Apple et al take over the whole damn caboodle without question. (In the future after all the world has finally woken up to the disaster then we'll have dozens of historians trying to figure out what the hell happened and why. When realization finally dawns everyone will be flabbergasted.) Now, long after the horses have bolted and without so much as an apology, governments are trying to reign in the likes of Google and Facebook. Right, our governance is a fucking farce - it has to be when governments simply allow Big Tech to not only effectively overrule longstanding law but also to go on and do whatever they damned well feel like with impunity.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
  Is the pocket router battery powered. Really we need an suitable open source, easily compiled OS to run on a suitable "smartphone" that can be re-purposed into a "pocket router". This to function as the gateway through which our "phones" reach the internet.
  - hilbert42 5y ago
    The router/modern is battery powered or it will run continuously off a USB charger. The one I'm using currently is a Vodafone (Huawei) R216. Here are the specs: https://wirelessgear.com.au/vodafone-pocket-wifi-4g-r216-modem/ https://wirelessgear.com.au/vodafone-pocket-wifi-4g-r216-mod.... That link is the first one I found, if it doesn't work for you just search the modem's model number. The R216 lasts for at least 6 hours on battery, often much longer (and the battery is removable, so you can have spares to extended its operational life). Whilst this modem is principally an ISP one (Vodafone) it comes unlocked. I note that that link says it's locked but it's likely not - as most assume ISP-supplied stuff is but to be sure you'd better check that's so where you are. Also, if you aren't using a Vodafone SIM then first just check that it works even if it's guaranteed unlocked (some other SIMs may need setting up). If the R216 isn't available or its locked in your country - or you have that common aversion to using Huawei equipment - then there are several other brands that are essentially equivalent. If you want the details I'll provide them. Note this is a real router/modem and it'll run up to five smartphones/PCs at a time (which can be very handy). Some others that are a little more expensive can connect 10 devices to each other by their WiFi LAN and or to the SIM's mobile network. Also the R216 will take a micro SD card (one's mobile NAS so to speak :-)). Given its small size size and usefulness I'd never be without one (I've three of this model and several earlier types).
    - Iolaum 5y ago
      Regarding a portable router - I wonder what you think about that one? https://www.gl-inet.com/products/gl-e750/#specs https://www.gl-inet.com/products/gl-e750/#specs It's about double the price, based on openWRT (but not fully open source).

hilbert42 5y ago

"...if you want an airgapped phone, use it in airplane mode." Right, that's what I do. In fact this post comes from a smartphone sans SIM with airplane mode on, with a firewall against apps phoning home, no Google or Gmail account, all Google Gapps nuked including playstore - in fact all Gapps have been completely removed - not to mention that most replacement apps come via F-Droid. Yes, technically it's not fully airgapped but it is against Google and that's my main aim. Of course there's a penalty: I also carry around both a pocket router with WiFi and SIM to which the smartphone connects as well as the dumbest of dumb phones just for phone calls. Yes, it's a little inconvenient in that the combined paraphernalia is about equivalent to two normal smartphones (both the router and dumb phone being somewhat smaller). Next step is to upgrade to a Fairphone or equivalent. (I've often wondered where I'd fit on a percentage scale of users who'd go to such lengths - somewhere between 0.1 and 0.001% I suspect.) You may well ask why I've gone to such lenghts. It's more principle than privacy really. It's because governments around the world completely abrogated their responsibility when they deregulated the once-private telephone networks in the 1980s, when they did they let the Wild West take over. This 'vacuum' then led to a depreciation in the value of privacy on telephone networks. The ultimate insult came when the vacuum was filled by the likes of Google and others who usurped the last vestiges of our telephone privacy for good - and these damn governments just stood by and let it happen without so much as whimper. Remember, we telephone users were never first consulted about our privacy - governments just let Google and Apple et al take over the whole damn caboodle without question. (In the future after all the world has finally woken up to the disaster then we'll have dozens of historians trying to figure out what the hell happened and why. When realization finally dawns everyone will be flabbergasted.) Now, long after the horses have bolted and without so much as an apology, governments are trying to reign in the likes of Google and Facebook. Right, our governance is a fucking farce - it has to be when governments simply allow Big Tech to not only effectively overrule longstanding law but also to go on and do whatever they damned well feel like with impunity.

1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
Is the pocket router battery powered. Really we need an suitable open source, easily compiled OS to run on a suitable "smartphone" that can be re-purposed into a "pocket router". This to function as the gateway through which our "phones" reach the internet.
- hilbert42 5y ago
  The router/modern is battery powered or it will run continuously off a USB charger. The one I'm using currently is a Vodafone (Huawei) R216. Here are the specs: https://wirelessgear.com.au/vodafone-pocket-wifi-4g-r216-modem/ https://wirelessgear.com.au/vodafone-pocket-wifi-4g-r216-mod.... That link is the first one I found, if it doesn't work for you just search the modem's model number. The R216 lasts for at least 6 hours on battery, often much longer (and the battery is removable, so you can have spares to extended its operational life). Whilst this modem is principally an ISP one (Vodafone) it comes unlocked. I note that that link says it's locked but it's likely not - as most assume ISP-supplied stuff is but to be sure you'd better check that's so where you are. Also, if you aren't using a Vodafone SIM then first just check that it works even if it's guaranteed unlocked (some other SIMs may need setting up). If the R216 isn't available or its locked in your country - or you have that common aversion to using Huawei equipment - then there are several other brands that are essentially equivalent. If you want the details I'll provide them. Note this is a real router/modem and it'll run up to five smartphones/PCs at a time (which can be very handy). Some others that are a little more expensive can connect 10 devices to each other by their WiFi LAN and or to the SIM's mobile network. Also the R216 will take a micro SD card (one's mobile NAS so to speak :-)). Given its small size size and usefulness I'd never be without one (I've three of this model and several earlier types).
  - Iolaum 5y ago
    Regarding a portable router - I wonder what you think about that one? https://www.gl-inet.com/products/gl-e750/#specs https://www.gl-inet.com/products/gl-e750/#specs It's about double the price, based on openWRT (but not fully open source).