6 ms·
The context of HN is that of "intellectual curiosity". Serious matters require much more respect than "curiosity". The tentative approach we may use with discus
by mdp2021 5y ago
The context of HN is that of "intellectual curiosity". Serious matters require much more respect than "curiosity". The tentative approach we may use with discussing engineering and worldly trends is not appropriate with them.
Dirac was used to provide a simile to make you understand the point: you seem to be using a text outside its purpose.
Contemporary advancements in the field of logic seem more pertinent to your interest: you demonstrate a penchant for syntax, and contemporary logic was largely busy in studying complexity in a formal way. But also in philosophy: there are studies where the topic was explicitly that which seems to intrigue you - without the need to bend other texts outside their purpose.
The matter of the false dichotomy, a formal note, is completely irrelevant to the content. That «there are [no] other options» does not seem the least bit relevant to the message I wrote: was it understood? It was there for understanding. Some things are not belief systems, hence they will not be part of the consistency game in the Weltaufbau. How does mentioning that there could be more options help clarify that or correct it?
The respect which creates reticence is in that before speaking of something (some domains more than others), one must know about it, with sufficient degree. Similarly for the counterpart.
Incidentally: you wrote about «speaking with precision, accuracy, and non-ambiguity», and the broad context is about a text with starts with saying "If you can talk about it, it is not the Way". And you call it not being «easy to understand» a «shortcoming»: are you sure you understood what the text is about?!
The intention of the author was very probably religious. If you are interested in the matter, good. It will probably not take you a weekend.
- mistermann 5y agoIs this to say that you agree with me after all?
- mdp2021 5y agoNo, it is to say that you do not seem to know what you are talking about, and that you do not seem to understand what you are told. It is to say that you should intensify work on building your intellectual keys, and avoid focussing on your strict interests, which could entangle into an overgrown cage of ideas. Hopefully you still have in front of you a long and proficuous time for formation. There is "curiosity" in the fascination for potential for growth, and 'curiosity' in the sense Heidegger used - of shallowness. Tackle matters when you are ready to understand them - which will also enable tackling them seriously. For most disciplines, there is lot of literature around. Some of those writers knew something: you should use them to learn.
- mistermann 5y ago> No, it is to say that you do not seem to know what you are talking about, and that you do not seem to understand what you are told. It may indeed seem that way, but if I say the same to you (that "it does not seem what you know what you are talking about, and that you do not seem to understand what you are told"), does it then mean that it is the True state of reality that you do not actually? Or, might it be possible that I am wrong, confused, have misinterpreted your words (there are many points along the idea transmission chain where loss of fidelity can occur), or something else? And if it is possible that an error can happen on one end of a communication, might it be possible that it could also occur on the other? Are you one of those rare (or maybe not so much lately) people who never makes any mistake at all, however small? Many thanks for your advice (or: thanks to the degree that it actually contains value), I hope for your benefit that you follow it with perfection yourself.