3 ms·
I can't help but think this and other attempts at biodegradability going to lead to even more planned obsolescence. Things which used to last basically forever
by userbinator 5y ago
I can't help but think this and other attempts at biodegradability going to lead to even more planned obsolescence. Things which used to last basically forever will self-destruct with no way to stop it; of course it'll be heralded as the next generation of environmental friendliness, but it's actually a way to keep the consumers consuming and the producers producing (nevermind how much resources get used in the production of these things...)
- Sebb767 5y agoTo be fair, reducing the lifespan from a few centuries to a few decades will not impact most consumers. Especially if we're talking about stuff that'll see very few uses, such as plastic bags.
- bordercases 5y agoThe current situation is that planned obsolescence exists without biodegradable materials. So you get two externalities: products that aren't made to last due to poor make causing artificial demand, which also won't degrade when disposed. So now we can potentially legislate the use of biodegradable materials where planned obsolescence exists, while simultaneously demanding less planned obsolescence as a separate problem. You might argue that there would be less reason to respond to incentives if disposables were more environmentally efficient to maintain, but on the other hand I'm unsure if producers are responding now in the first place. This is an area where I'd be happy to be proven wrong.
- johnebgd 5y agoThings wear out. Thats a natural part of life. Ensuring that the things wearing out can be biodegradable is a big net positive for society. Making things more repairable / upgradeable is a good way to make things last longer.
- asxd 5y agoI think that's exactly the point. In this context, planned obsolescence of plastics is the goal, because currently they last much longer than needed. I'm having trouble seeing how this might lead to planned obsolescence of non-plastic goods that you would want to keep around for a long while.
- WalterBright 5y agoI have some older plastic items that have become very fragile and brittle. They're not lasting forever. I also left one of those clear plastic tubs where the sun shines through a window on it. After a couple years, the plastic became very brittle, lost its strength, and the tub pretty much disintegrated.
- shadilay 5y agoMercedes tried biodegradable wiring and it totaled cars due to electrical problems. http://www.badmercedes.com/ http://www.badmercedes.com/