8 ms·
You don't find that conclusion informative and interesting? I did, much like I find Godel's incompleteness theorems or the Halting theorem very informative and
by gwern 15y ago
You don't find that conclusion informative and interesting? I did, much like I find Godel's incompleteness theorems or the Halting theorem very informative and interesting.
- gus_massa 15y agoGödel theorem / Halting problem: "We are sure that something is impossible." -> Interesting Virus Origin: "We still don't know. We will keep researching." -> Not very interesting
- asdkl234890 15y agoThis is NO Godel's incompleteness theorem! This is shallow nothingness, do not compare it to some of the deepest math ever.
- chc 15y agoNot every instance of "I dunno" is equal in impact or insight to Gödel's theorems. In fact, almost none of them are. This is because the interesting part of Gödel's work was not the "dunno" aspect, but the positive knowledge of what is and is not possible in mathematics. The halting problem, likewise, exposes exposes a fundamental limitation in computing. It is not simply "I dunno," but "This cannot be known." If the article proved the origin of viruses to be unknowable, that would be quite interesting and surprising. But asking a difficult question and then answering it with "I dunno" is a much simpler and less interesting accomplishment. I could do this with any number of things.