3 ms·
> I think that most of our top engineers would not be able to do what Eratosthenes did with a wooden stick and some calculations (calculating the earth circumfe
by bluGill 5y ago
> I think that most of our top engineers would not be able to do what Eratosthenes did with a wooden stick and some calculations (calculating the earth circumference and tilt).
Sure they would if you gave them time. Eratosthennes didn't just go do it, he spent some (how much we don't know) thinking about the problem. Engineers today have all the math background needed - they are a little rusty but if you give them a few days they can reconstruct the needed math.
- stephc_int13 5y agoWithout Googling it? I am not so sure. I know a lot of guys with engineering degrees who clearly could not do that even if they have had access to much more advanced math than Eratosthenes.
- bluGill 5y agoNote that I gave them dedicated time to focus. I couldn't do it before lunch (in about an hour as I write this), but give me a few days to run some false starts and I think I could figure it out.