8 ms·
Building a high quality audio system [video]
- rusteh1 5y agoI'd be curious to see the typical rate of hearing degradation due to age graphed against typical income growth with age that would be required to support systems of this standard. Audiophiles are synonymous with diminishing returns, but I wonder if that is even more acute with age of the listener. Super cool nonetheless.
- JohnBooty 5y agoAn excellent question. Hearing obviously (almost always) worsens with age, but it's not a linear degradation across the entire range of hearing, like adding random static noise to an entire television image. You can often still hear many/most frequencies very well even when experiencing moderate hearing loss. Moderate hearing loss is almost always more severe in the higher frequencies a.k.a. treble. For example I'm in my 40s, and my hearing's starting to become crap above 8khz. Meanwhile, the fundamental frequency of most musical content is quite a bit lower in the frequency range. The highest fundamental frequency of a standard piano with standard tuning is around 4khz, and most notes are an octave or five below that; "middle C" is usually defined as 262hz. So, still plenty to enjoy even if one's hearing is no longer pristine. typical rate of hearing degradation due to age graphed against typical income growth with age This correlation is not lost on speaker manufacturers. A lot of pricey speakers add (at least) a few extra dB of treble. None of the manufacturers will admit it, of course, but you can't convince me otherwise: I've always been certain this is an attempt to appeal to the degraded hearing capabilities of their aging+affluent customers.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's precisely right, I figure the crossover would be somewhere between 30 and 40. Babies (and dogs) would be quite happy though.
- JohnBooty 5y agoWell, I'll take that guy's system over mine for sure. However....! For those unfamiliar with the hobby I'd like to mention something, however: you can have an objectively very good system for not too much money. The research of (among others) Dr. Floyd Toole (formerly of Harman International) makes a very persuasive case that the "best" audio system is simply one that reproduces the input signal accurately, both on- and off-axis. There's no secret sauce, really. It's all in the measurements. This can be achieved rather affordably. Monitors from JBL (a Harman company) and Kali (former Harman engineers) such as the JBL 305/306/308 and competing models from Kali were built around these principles and accomplish this starting at prices of several hundred $USD. While formerly "audiophiles" were associated with snake oil and unlimited budgets, there are growing legions of those who subscribe to a more objectivist take on the hobby. https://www.audiosciencereview.com https://www.audiosciencereview.com (I have no affiliation) is one place to find such reviews and discussions. I'm not an expert but have been in the hobby for a while and would be happy to answer questions if anybody's had interest in the hobby but hasn't known where/how to get started.
- smackeyacky 5y agoThe snake oil victims really turned me off conversing with other hi fi hobbyists. Pseudo-science about cables, ethernet hubs for audio, utter nonsense about jitter. Endless arguments about blind testing and the "your ears aren't good enough to appreciate the sound that I can hear" sniffery and veiled snobbery. The insufferable Stereophile magazine and the nonsense it continues to peddle. Horrifying.
- Dave_Rosenthal 5y agoYeah, I've always loved music and good audio, but I pretty much gave up on the hobby for a decade or two because the main sources of information (i.e. industry magazines) were so absurdly pseudo-science. But, as the grandparent of this post points out, there has been a real renaissance of information and discussion on the internet that isn't bought and paid for by snake oil salesmen and it's the best time ever to get a great audio system for little money. A bunch of Chinese companies (Topping, etc.) have actually jumped on the objectivist bandwagon are cranking out (relatively) inexpensive DACs, amps, etc. that are world-leading in measured performance (at any price). Like everything internet, the 'objectivist' audiophile world can be a bit of an echo chamber, but real progress is being made towards non-trivial questions like how one should measure the performance of headphones and speakers, what the ideal actually is, and what deviations from that ideal make the most difference.
- Animats 5y agoIs he an Instagrammer? The ultimate system was probably the one in the screening room at Dolby Labs on Potero in San Francisco. The entire room was supported on anti-vibration mounts, isolated from the rest of the structure by an air gap. Outside that was a foot of acoustic insulation. The speakers are built into big chambers in the walls hidden by grille cloth screens. There's a control and projection room at the back. You didn't even see the system. Which is the point. The equipment should not distract from the show. The room also had good enough acoustics that a speaker didn't need amplification to address 90 people. I was there once for a demo of spatial audio for video games. We could hear the enemies sneaking up behind us. They had full hemisphere speaker coverage. The room wasn't particularly luxurious. It was a working facility for the industry. Dolby has since moved to a larger facility and built a new, larger screening room. I haven't seen that one.
- dehrmann 5y agoAll the room effort is a good point. This guy's listening room appears to be an acoustically odd shape with a lot of hard, echoy surfaces. The room acoustics likely dominate any benefits he hears after the first $5,000. That said, I suspect he has more fun building the room than anything.
- JohnBooty 5y agoThe guy's room seems pretty good acoustically. The main thing is avoiding resonances / room modes. These will cause peaks and nulls in the frequency response that cannot be fixed with EQ. The primary way to do this is to avoid right angles; it looks like he has largely done this. In a more typical room where right angles are a fact of life, furnishings and bass traps can help with this. The (lack of) sound absorption is kind of a tricky issue to discuss in a brief manner. On an objective level w.r.t to room interactions, this guy's seating area is closer to the speakers than the side walls. That makes this a nearfield arrangement, meaning that the direct sound from the speakers will be greater in magnitude than reflected sound from the walls. This alone will minimize the effect of reflections. On a subjective level w.r.t. room interactions, somewhat counterintuitively the goal for enjoyable listening is not to create a purely anechoic room totally free from room effects: this sounds unnatural and essentially just recreates a headphones listening experience. One can save a lot of money by strapping on a pair of headphones if that's what's desired. The human brain is, frankly, rather amazing at doing its own "room correction" and hearing through room issues anyway, as long as they're not massive peaks and nulls.
- jacquesm 5y agoThere is an absolute fortune worth of clocks in that room.
- defterGoose 5y ago...and mostly in the DACs I'd wager.
- pg_bot 5y agoThis guy needs to write a book about audio engineering.
- m0zg 5y agoHe probably doesn't know much about it. Otherwise he'd buy a much simpler system akin to the ones studios use to record and mix the records. Given that he doesn't need the mixing console (which can be quite expensive), he could get a SOTA set up for well under $100K, and it'd likely sound much better. That includes acoustic treatments, but not "silver speaker wire". Copper works just fine.
- JohnBooty 5y agoIf you want to read "the" book on sound reproduction, this is rather indisputably it: https://www.amazon.com/Sound-Reproduction-Psychoacoustics-Loudspeakers-Engineering-dp-113892136X/dp/113892136X/ref=dp_ob_title_bk https://www.amazon.com/Sound-Reproduction-Psychoacoustics-Lo... The book is backed by quite a few decades of research and controlled listening experiments with trained and untrained listeners. It really is authoritative. Dr. Toole is also very generous with his time on various audio forums and YouTube channels. So by all indications, you are also supporting a pretty decent human being.
- buescher 5y agoIt's a truly great book. Also a great sales pitch for Harman products.
- systemvoltage 5y agoMove 2 feet on either side and there goes the entire premise of all these high fidelity amplifiers and drivers. I see absolutely zero sound proofing. At this point this guy should be building an anachoic chamber, I only kid slighly. The more I learn about hi-fi, the more bullshit I hear. There is no nice way to put this.
- JohnBooty 5y agoStories like this aren't representative of reality. Obviously, when you coverage such as this, it tends to focus on outlandish examples such as this guy who has poured an absolute fortune into his stereo system. It's the same way with any hobby. If somebody has two cats, it's not news. If they have fifty cats, it's news. Those kinds of cat owners obviously exist but they are on the fringe. Replace "cats" with "cars" or "guitars" or any other thing you like. There is a growing trend of objectivism in the audio hobby. Performance can be measured in objective ways and it turns out that generally speaking, it's all just signal reproduction and the more accurately you do this, the better it sounds. An objectively well-performing system can be put together for just a few hundred USD at retail prices.
- Applejinx 5y agoAlso, the top-end of live performance has moved up. Whether it's the amazing line array designs for huge gigs, or Funktion One intensely loud horn-loaded designs, we get very impressive results these days. This is one reason audio quality is experiencing a renaissance. If you have a club system that will CLEANLY hit 120 dB on transient peaks and you've got it cranked up and there's space in the mix, it's easy to hear where 16 bit audio leaves off (and mp3 is completely not to be thought of, a real bozo move). Mind you, you've got to mix and master stuff correctly to use that to full effect, but some do :)
- JohnBooty 5y agoIf you have a club system that will CLEANLY hit 120 dB on transient peaks A very underrated aspect of audio reproduction. I've got a big ol' pair of 3-way "monkey coffin" speakers in my garage as a secondary system. Horn tweeters, 15" woofers. Frequency response is smooth through the vocal range but overall, kind of a mess. Manfacturer cleams 95dB/watt efficiency which is probably somewhat of a lie, but they do get punishingly loud with very little power and will happily take a few hundred watts' worth of juice. Generally I am an objectivist and in many ways this system objectively sucks. And yet, it's a blast to listen to. While not hitting 120dB, it can actually sort of begin to approximate the dynamic range of live instruments like drums. Something that simply can't be achieved without serious firepower. Mind you, you've got to mix and master stuff correctly to use that to full effect, but some do :) Amen. This is actually where I basically... hit my personal end of the road when it came to buying audio equipment. My setups aren't extravagant or expensive, and there is some room for audible improvement, but basically I was hitting the limits of: my listening room, my ears, and like you said -- the recorded material itself. Very little recorded material outside of the classical realm is recorded and mastered in a way that would IMO reward further investment in my systems.
- js2 5y agoIf you don't have an hour to watch, here's a summary: https://www.wtvr.com/i-have-a-story/worlds-greatest-stereo-system-virginia https://www.wtvr.com/i-have-a-story/worlds-greatest-stereo-s...
- vinkelhake 5y agoOff topic, but man the out of focus shots bugged me. I don't know what they were shooting with, but obviously some care went into it. The shots of him sitting in the chair were framed alright, lighting was good, low aperture for a nice depth of field and... focus was on the chair in the center of the frame, making his face a blurry mess :(
- bittercynic 5y agoThis guy's system and the room are true works of art. Part of me wants to criticize the extravagance of it, but he's clearly having a good time, and it really looks like fun!
- zw123456 5y agoWell, one man's snake oil is another man's hobby, or whatever. I am not there with him, but I kind of understand a little. I inherited a collection of rare jazz and classical 78's from my favorite uncle when I was 15 (1973), he was a DJ at a radio station at a liberal arts college. He was my favorite uncle because when everyone else at a family reunion was arguing about fords vs. chevy or whatever, he and I would be off talking about Jazz, Blues, Rock, and all kinds of things. I have treasured them, he also willed me his vintage Victrola. I have not played most of them to preserve them. I have been experimenting and working on how to record them without harming them for years and I think I am almost there. Optics is no good, I have tried that, but this is real vinyl and there is a reactivity and response of the material that optics does not capture. I have developed what I call a software defined turntable that uses an FPGA to dynamically select equalization and control the speed, which varies during recordings. Sorry, I am rambling. My point is, some of us are kooks, I guess. But, here is the thing, music can do that to a person. And other emotions. Never judge someone why they are obsessed, just enjoy the wonder of it. I love that guy, good for him, enjoy my fellow traveler, enjoy.
- fileoffset 5y agoHmm, I thought 78s were made from pretty strong stuff, and that the needle was the wearing part when playing those old discs? Why would you worry about harming them when playing? Modern vinyl, I understand is softer and will wear with repeated plays but the old 78s should hold up much much better?
- jarnold 5y agoThis isn’t a documentary about hi-if equipment. It’s a story about this man’s obsession. The sacrifices and guilt now realized. Nearing the end of his life with a terminal illness — it’s the reflection at the end that causes pause. How are your obsessions impacting you? Are they tearing you away from your family or friends? Are you happy with those choices made?
- dukeofdoom 5y agoFuneral home vibes in this man's house. But nice system. World's Second Best Speakers! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EEh01PX-q9I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EEh01PX-q9I DIY option.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- svilen_dobrev 5y agowhen the house is the loud?speaker: http://www.scrounge.org/speak/burwen/index.html http://www.scrounge.org/speak/burwen/index.html