4 ms·
Please let this not be the beginning of the end of the Home Depot website experience, which currently meets my needs quite well. Every other store that has play
by mindslight 5y ago
Please let this not be the beginning of the end of the Home Depot website experience, which currently meets my needs quite well. Every other store that has played around with this same day delivery gigwork scheme has eventually made their shipping option worse to push customers towards subscription services.
In general "same day delivery" seems like a solution in search of a problem - if you need something ASAP, it's much more straightforward to just run to the store than to be waiting around for it to be delivered on someone else's schedule. And if you're not near a store, then it's not like a gigworker can magically conjure it either.
Also never mind that half the stuff at Home Depot won't easily fit in the average car. I had a Walmart order for some shelving units that got converted to local delivery. The online status just said "delivered" with a blank picture. I found out later the driver had seen the large boxes, decided it wasn't worth it, and refused the pickup. I finally had to go to the store during their asinine online pickup hours to sort it out.
- mertd 5y agoSame day delivery is not for the stuff you need ASAP in my opinion. It's for the stuff you'll need on the *next day*. Like buying a specific tool on Saturday for a Sunday home repair project, which could be a big business for Home Depot.
- mindslight 5y agoI have two queues, soon (store pickup) and eventually (shipping). I generally have enough errands queued up that if I need something the next day, I'll do an in store pickup in the evening/night, and get a few other things done with the same trip. I don't begrudge people who can benefit from gigwork delivery having that option. My problem is with the stores who seem to be running an unsustainable operation (either they're getting supremely awesome freight and packaging rates, or more likely taking a loss on many items that they ship), and choosing to change to a different and less convenient unsustainable operation rather than actually sorting out their inefficiencies (like figuring out how to avoid sending so many boxes with a single item in each).
- ethbr0 5y agoThat's an evem better point. Why doesn't Home Depot do tool rental delivery & pickup via gig work?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoI’m not sure about the “via gig work” portion of it, but they do in fact do tool rental delivery and pickup. I rented a Dingo last month (a small digging and leveling machine that you ride behind on a platform) and this was provided as an option. It was not really clear when I looked whether HD employees took it or whether they subcontracted the service out using something like gig work. IIRC the fee was $100 USD each way. That was prohibitively expensive for me and was nearly the price of the 24h rental itself which was around $280 if I remember correctly. I fortunately own a truck with a hitch (the Dingo came with its own flatbed trailer) but I could theoretically see it as an option for those who didn’t own one. Though at that price you might as well pay the $300 to $400 or so to have a hitch installed on your car instead provided you own one that could tow the Dingo (which most cars could, it’s pretty light).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alwillis 5y agoAt least with Amazon Prime, if you’re up late past midnight, “today” often means you can order something at 1am and have it that afternoon, especially if you’re fairly close to Amazon fulfillment centers. My Walmart will deliver groceries and basic electronics (USB cables, SD cards, etc.) together within two hours.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI think Home Depot has the best website right now. I love how I can see inventory at all the stores around me in one screen.
- mc32 5y agoA nice mundane touch is how they’ll sow you inventory for stores within 100 miles. Though it’s disappointing when there is nothing within that radius.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThat's about the only thing I like about HD these days. It's too bad, I used to love shopping there. Now--their prices are not the lowest either. They used to be the lowest, until they closed most hardware stores with their buying power. I refused to pay $9 for a tiny box of glazing compound. I went to an employee owned store I have been passing by for years, and found the same product for 1/2 the price. I can't figure out if the employees hate the place more than the customers. At one time, people used to like going to HD. Now it's a chore. HD used to hire seasoned professionals for each sector of the store. You used to go to the Electrical section, and a guy was there who knew exactly what you needed. Now--it's just anyone who wants a terrible job, and shows up. Oh yea, I don't like being photographed 15-20 times in order to buy a M8 bolt. I'll be glad when they go under, and someone new comes along. It seems like someone could just copy the original business plan of the two guys whom started HD?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoLowe’s has a similar UI that is pretty competitive IMO. What I love even more about both is that the sites are nearly always correct in both count and location. If a store says 15 in stock on Aisle 27 Bin 9 I can walk into that Lowe’s or Home Depot with an extremely high level of confidence that I am going to find that item at the listed location with the correct amount listed on the site or only one or two count off. It’s very nearly magical how good they have gotten at inventory. Compare to say, Tractor Supply Co. which is a chain of pet supply stores in the States. TSC purports to show stock but it’s a complete dice roll on whether the numbers are actually correct or not for any given location. In their case I would prefer them to not show any inventory online at all because of how wrong it is all the time.
- runako 5y ago> In general "same day delivery" seems like a solution in search of a problem - if you need something ASAP, it's much more straightforward to just run to the store than to be waiting around for it to be delivered on someone else's schedule. I would preface that with "For your particular situation,". There are a lot of situations where it can be very valuable to have something come "today," where you don't necessarily care when today. Notably, a QoS of "today" is a guarantee that you can start using it tomorrow morning. If you actually need it tomorrow, you can save the hour or whatever entailed in a round-trip to the store. Depending on your situation, that hour can be worth a meaningful amount of money. If you're doing a larger project, the time (money) savings could add up fast.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoI think same day delivery is stupid, but unfortunately Amazon has set the bar there, no matter how many people get harmed in the process. Companies like Home Depot need to find a way to compete for the service level consumers expect if they want to remain in business... not that Walmart is the ideal partner to avoid human suffering.
- mindslight 5y agoUnless you're paying for Amazon's sunk cost fallacy, their standard is to hold your order several days before shipping. Brick and mortar stores plus Fedex often deliver faster than Amazon does! And if you are paying for Amazon's sunk cost fallacy, that doesn't mean you want to automatically sign up for additional sunk cost fallacies at more stores. Which is eventually what these gigwork delivery options always turn into (eg Target "shipt"), because paying people to perform ad-hoc shopping and delivery isn't cheap either.
- throwaway81523 5y agoHome Depot's web site is pretty awful besides the other issues in that post. Its search function is near worthless. You have to look in 5 different places to find the weight of an item and sometimes it's not there at all (but you can usually find it on amazon). Tons of crap waiting to load, the usual. My HD curbside (parking lot) pickup experience has so far been pretty good, but I didn't go during the worst of things.
- mindslight 5y agoI find it average. My gold standard is Digikey, everything else has its own flaws. FWIW I have more problems with Amazon hiding straightforward matches than Home Depot or many other places for that matter. Amazon seems to always want to distract me with gensym brands. FWIW Home Depot loads in half the time with NoScript only allowing what's essential. Otherwise they seem to be backhauling every single mouse movement, at least the last time I checked.
- throwaway81523 5y agoI hate Digikey's too (tons of script dependence even in the checkout page, including a recaptcha iirc). Really by now, I'd rather bypass the web site altogether and just use an ordering API instead. Digikey actually has that, but they only offer it to large customers. Seems lame.
- mindslight 5y agoWhile I agree with you completely, I find that ship has sailed. Most web stores pop up recaptchas, and have extremely heavy javascript. I find it utterly unprofessional, but somehow it's acceptable in this new age. I'd love for APIs, especially common APIs, where consumer-agent software could create one cart that would optimize between vendors on price/shipping minimum/etc. But that's not in webstores' interest for the obvious reason of decommodification.
- kube-system 5y ago> I find it average. My gold standard is Digikey, everything else has its own flaws. Have you tried McMaster-Carr?
- kube-system 5y ago> In general "same day delivery" seems like a solution in search of a problem There's a very good use case for this: If I want the item after work. A trip to-and-from the store during rush hour is a decent chunk of time, when I could have the item waiting for me instead.