3 ms·
This post stil feels disingenuous. Part of the experiment? Odio came along and scraped all the carbohydrates out of the Petrie dish, to give to ants outside th
by Terretta 15y ago
This post stil feels disingenuous. Part of the experiment? Odio came along and scraped all the carbohydrates out of the Petrie dish, to give to ants outside the lab.
As pointed out by HN readers, absolutely everyone here knew the experiment could be broken, so nothing was proven or gained by doing what any of us could have.
I was given an EcoSphere (a glass ball containing a supposedly self-sustaining ecosystem) as a boy. For a kid, it's a fascinating experiment to see if it works over time.
"One possible outcome" is to drop the glass ball on the floor. Not a particularly inventive or interesting outcome, and if you do that in front of a class of kids, you'll get the same reactions.
A lot of people were enjoying being kids again, watching the glass ball's energy supply surge and fall, till Odio broke open the EcoSphere protesting that's valid science too. In a large enough classroom, there's always at least one.
- Terretta 15y agoAddendum – Came back at the end of the day to add this clarification: Nothing in Sam's comments about this lead me to believe he's a bad guy, just that he's missing something about this particular scenario. On the contrary, spotting rules begging for breaking is a very helpful trait for an entrepreneur – as most here know, the YC questionnaire asks for examples of "hacking the system for your own gain". (Though the PG "no jerks" rule[1] implies hacking that's not at someone else's expense.) ”There's always one“ who's constantly challenging conventions, and when that one zeros in on the line between audacious and antisocial, 20 years later he often winds up running things. For more human background, this Washington Business Journal profiles the Odio brothers.[2] 1. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1632477 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1632477 2. http://www.bizjournals.com/washington/stories/2010/10/11/focus1.html http://www.bizjournals.com/washington/stories/2010/10/11/foc...