5 ms·
Ask HN: Recuiters on LinkedIn
Does anyone know if there is a setting to only be contacted by in-house recruiters that than 3rd parties?
My experience from a hiring side is that 3rd party recruiters are not actually looking for someone who is a good fit, but just trying to get anyone into the position. I don't trust the recruiters on LinkedIn since they seem like 3rd parties. I would put a lot more stock in a recruiter reaching out from the actual company.
- sbacic 5y agoI'm genuinely curious - is interacting with recruiters now considered a bad move career-wise? As in, because of the scummy tactics some of them use, will it make it harder to land a job in the future due to the shady things they do with your CV/personal info?
- duxup 5y agoI don't think the issue is good or bad move, but volume of time wasted by third party recruiters who collect candidates and shop them around but have no job for you in mind / can waste your time endlessly.
- Chyzwar 5y agoIn most cases they still perform better than in-house HR/Recruiter departments. Their's job is to adverse job opening to as many candidates as possible and do initial filtering on location, salary and tech stack. For a jobseeker they are good because they often work with multiple companies to match you with a company or pass your resume to another requiter that have jobs with better fit. They can get you pass initial screen where clueless HR would reject yours resume because of spelling error. They often can provide information on hiring process based on experience with previous candidates. For a small company that cannot afford having a dedicated recruiter, they are an easy way to outsource responsibility of finding people. For a large non-tech company they are better than in house HR because they have basic understanding of the market.
- JSeymourATL 5y agoHave you looked up the profiles of the individuals who messaged you on LinkedIn? It’s pretty easy to distinguish a serious player versus a Bozo. The “retained” headhunters are usually interesting. These are true hired guns. Essentially, you’ll want to deal with the individuals who have done their 10,000+ hours in this space. Have the recruiter prove back their interest in you. Ask them to send a detailed position summary, including the compensation package. The quality of their written response should tell you everything.
- jl2718 5y agoI have a theory that their strategy is to submit as many resumes as possible and then check back for anybody that has actually taken the job, no thanks to them, and then sending the company a bill for the referral. This happened to me once after getting hired by internal referral. The company ended up rescinding my offer to avoid dealing with the recruiter whose email I had responded to long ago. That was the one time I really needed a job - life took some very strange turns after that.
- giantg2 5y agoWe've had recruiters send us people who didn't have any experience with the technologies. They coached people on what to say to get hired and gave them answers to some of the questions. We've had to let people go after finding out how incompetent they were because of this.
- jessevr 5y agoI would just recommend you to go to the company’s LinkedIn profile and search for the right recruiter (the one looking for your skills). I get the same feeling about LinkedIn recruiters being 3rd parties, so I would just avoid responding back. Make a list of different companies you might be interested in, and look for the right recruiters.
- giantg2 5y agoThanks! This sounds like a good topic, albeit a bit more work intensive. I wonder if LinkedIn would be interested in creating a feature for their search that would filter out 3rd party job postings. I think some other searches do that.
- Raed667 5y agoDespite everything I read, I gave 3 recruitment companies a chance. It was an absolute waste of time an energy. They never delivered on the salary ranges or type of roles that were mentioned during the initial call. They wasted my time with a round of "feedback" after each actual interview with the different companies. They generally left a very bad impression, and now I think of them as leeches and avoid them like the plague.
- duxup 5y agoI think the spectrum of recruiters is really wide ... and there's a lot of bad ones out there. There are so many it's hard to find a "good" one. Folks with a good one will rightfully sing their praises, but otherwise it's a profession that has turned into spam / it's own weird industry of creating a hiring industrial complex that does nobody any good.
- duxup 5y agoMan I wish there was. LinkedIn is just recruiter spam for me now. The noise level of people just collecting names arbitrarily (either by design or due to ignorance) is off the charts. I too would like to talk to a recruiter with specific job(s) in mind and who knows/ works at that company.