6 ms·
Instagram has largely replaced TikTok in India
- simorley 5y agoAs others have pointed out in this thread, why doesn't india create their own tiktok or instagram instead? Just clone them if they can't come up with something new. Neither instagram nor tiktok is rocket science. The value of instagram and tiktok isn't their "technology" or algorithm, it's their users. Why is india ceding their entire market to an american ( or chinese ) company to begin with? Love them or hate them, at least the chinese leadership are competent. What are india's leaders doing? At least when the chinese ban foreign companies, they build up their own homegrown champions. I thought when india banned tiktok, they were going to do the same. Instead, they just handed over the market to facebook.
- devnull3 5y agoThere is an Indian version Moj [1]. India is too big a market to have vaccumm in this space. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moj_(app) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moj_(app)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jamiequint 5y agoIf the "canteen" has better food, and 50% of your company hangs out there 2hrs/day and is under full-time surveillance/propaganda broadcasting by your primary competitor, maybe focusing on the food is missing the point.
- aks_tldr 5y agoso let's just starve them
- jamiequint 5y agoI think you misunderstood the metaphor in the article.
- ldiracdelta 5y agoAs Scott Adam says, ["Analogies are fighting words."](https://www.scottadamssays.com/post/102881499176/analogies-are-fighting-words-update https://www.scottadamssays.com/post/102881499176/analogies-a...)
- erehweb 5y agoBroken link
- born2web 5y agothis could be the link... Analogies are Fighting Words - update - Scott Adams Says https://www.scottadamssays.com/analogies-are-fighting-words-update/ https://www.scottadamssays.com/analogies-are-fighting-words-... though it looks like the content has been updated(removed)
- KennyBlanken 5y agoAnd I say Scott Adams is a fascist, a bigot, and a peddler of misinformation.
- rafale 5y agoI think they benefited from being early on the platform. A great advantage if they can monetize, grow and keep up with the competitive pressure. Unfortunately that's not always an option. People move on and these kids have to feed themselves.
- krisrm 5y agoMaybe I'm just getting old and crotchety, but "influencer" seems like such a ridiculous thing to do for work. I guess the laws of Capitalism dictate that it must be a job, or people wouldn't pay for it. But I think it says something about the world we've created, and I don't think it's necessarily good.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago60% of people in UK think their job is bullshit and doesn't need to exist, so my wild guess is these 'influencers' fill more fulfilled than an average office worker.
- npteljes 5y agoI watched some videos about influencers' daily grind, and I think it's just a different kind of entrepreneurship. They are basically internet-enabled, self-managed celebrities. The social role is not that different that of a "traditional" actor or entertainer, but the effort is grass-roots more often than not. Job security is shit though. Among other trappings, like a cancel mob.
- ethbr0 5y agoI look at it as a fashion athlete, extending the term beyond clothing. Your actual job is silly, but entertaining to a large number of people. Consequently, there's a lot of money available. Consequently, the industry selects for peak performance. It's easy to look in from the outside and say "Wow! They're getting paid that much because they're that good." But in reality it's that (total available money in the endeavor) determines (relative competition vs other industries) determines (absolute effort of top performers, to be top performers). ... that said, "erased working class creators" is objectively a ridiculous turn of phrase.
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoInfluencers for teens are what clowns are for kids and what talkshow presenters are for adults. Entertaiment. Only teens badly want anything easy to give them purpose.
- 5y ago
- Despegar 5y agoIt would have been a disaster for competition if Trump had managed to ban TikTok.
- paxys 5y agoThe solution, IMO, is not to debate between a Chinese-owned vs an American-owned app but rather promote something homegrown.
- fabianhjr 5y agoPromote counter-anti-desintermediation: http://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Counter-Anti-Disintermediation http://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Counter-Anti-Disintermediation http://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Disintermediation http://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Disintermediation
- Barrin92 5y agothat's just going to further degrade the quality. International competition is good because it's the fiercest market there is and TikTok is a genuinely good platform for content creators. the same is going to happen when Huawei is excluded from 5G contracts, watch and see how cost reduction is going to stagnate. The exact same thing happened to the American auto industry after its anti-Japanese protectionist moment in the late 80s/90s. It's gonna be a feast for the national oligarchy and an absolute disaster for consumers. And also one thing to add regarding foreign social media. If you think that your citizens are so fundamentally gullible and illiterate that they're going to be brainwashed by a platform like tiktok and that domestic politicians need to spoonfeed them news you've already abandoned any faith in the basis for democracy to begin with.
- wyre 5y ago> anti-Japanese protectionist moment Is there more to this than the chicken tax preventing imported trucks?
- Barrin92 5y agoYes, a 45% tax on motorcycles (to save Harley Davidson[1]), a flat limit on the number of cars that could be imported to the United States, and later a 100% tariff on the Japanese electronics industry[2], among a few other things. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_motorcycle_tariff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_motorcycle_tariff [2]https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1987-03-28-mn-698-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1987-03-28-mn-698-st...
- el-salvador 5y agoTikTok does a very good job mixing and matching content creators from different income levels.
- akomtu 5y agoInstagram and TikTok sound like invasive species on your lawn that compete for territory. I'm reading it like "Poisonous Ivy has largely replaced Crabgrass on your front lawn, erased all flowers and is taking on that tree".
- sbmthakur 5y agoI hope the authors can share some hard data to back up their claims. The sample size from the article is not enough to justify the title.
- whitefirered 5y agoIm genuinely curious, who watches these types of videos in the first place? Instagram and Tiktok have useless videos, with little snippets of random information, or some dancing trend. Its basically Fast Food social media. On top of that Tiktok is just Chinese spyware.
- IlliOnato 5y agoMaybe I am not getting it, but to me this long article is about something rather simple: some people got popular on a platform, then the platform was banned, and they cannot easily re-create their following on other similar platforms available. A similar problem about the platforms themselves: the article mentions that a number of local Indian TikTok-lookalike platforms have been created, but none of them was able to get even a fraction of TikTok popularity. That said, I was pleased to learn about Savitri and Sanatan Mahto, and enjoyed a few of their videos (on Youtube, ironically).
- geodel 5y agoI mean you are right. Instagram in India (maybe many more places?) has an upscale, fashionable image to it and thronged by celebrities and wannabes. TikTok was platform for subaltern voices so to speak. So all in all one does not have to be slick fuck to be on TikTok and thats reason of popularity.
- sgpl 5y agoI think the article's trying to convey that instagram has a more curated look and so by algo-design/human-design doesn't reward videos/reels that are shot on poor resolution phones and those that don't directly follow their guidelines for being promoted - these can be barriers for folks from marginalized communities and folks that have poor access to resources. Tiktok on the other hand promoted your video to other users on the platform regardless of these 'requirements' and as a result those from poor/marginalized communities had the opportunity go viral and gain followers as well - without investment in the polish necessary to gain the same visibility on instagram. This polish could be in the form of better phones(cameras), better clothing or better backgrounds/scenes.
- bobthepanda 5y agoEh, TikTok got a lot of heat for telling its moderators to downrank fat people, disabled people, and queer people, so this is not by any means one being better than the other. https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/2/20991843/tiktok-bytedance-platform-disabled-autism-lgbt-fat-user-algorithm-reach-limit https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/2/20991843/tiktok-bytedance...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoThe story tries so hard to make a point about casteism in algorithmic bias that it ignores the financial realities of the ground. There's a huge Venture Capital bubble forming in India right now thanks to, among others, Andreesen Horowitz. Those guys have seemingly bottomless pits of money to throw at startups like Clubhouse and in India have gone and created Unicorns out of thin air on paper only. The big money fight in India post the TikTok ban is what helped IG. Lots of upstarts running expensive advertisements on Television and getting brand endorsements, while the big, established networks in the Facebook family silently boosted content similar to the trash you find on TikTok through FB stories and Facebook stories on placements on top of feed/message inbox, upsells in feed etc IG is far from winning the space. The competition is simply in disarray from trying to figure out branding and the "cool" factor that TikTok had.
- naveen99 5y agoIndia should just unban tiktok and bitcoin to / from INR conversions. Also clean up the water supply (setup municipal water treatment plants) so we can have some Golguppe without getting sick. And then all will be well.