4 ms·
> "Aircraft are greatly affected by the GPS jamming and it's not taken seriously by management," reads one report. "We've been told we can't ask to stop jamming
by ryandrake 5y ago
> "Aircraft are greatly affected by the GPS jamming and it's not taken seriously by management," reads one report. "We've been told we can't ask to stop jamming, and to just put everyone on headings."
This is the military practicing, but I would hope that civilian airline transport operations are also robust to GNSS unavailability or denial. Even private pilots in little Cessnas are taught to navigate using radio-navigation (NDB beacons, VORs, etc.) in the event that GPS is not available. You should absolutely be able to turn your GPS off and get to your destination.
The fact that radio-navigation aids are being phased out in favor of GNSS, turning it into a single point of failure, is pretty concerning.
- jdavis703 5y agoIn the examples given it sounds like ATC was doing things like directing aircraft in to restricted air space. Obviously the captain has final say and ATC’s role is officially just advisory. But this sounds like a bit more than a pilot who forgot how to navigate.
- mike_d 5y ago> ATC was doing things like directing aircraft in to restricted air space The last US government GPS denial test was large enough that it impacted ATC from Seattle to Los Angeles to Denver to Albuquerque. They didn't really have a way to route around it.
- repiret 5y agoRestricted airspace, and airspace where GPS is disrupted, are different things. GPS disruptions can be vast. Unless you're flying around the Mojave, restricted airspace tends to be small and with ceilings that make it no factor for transport category aircraft. ATC should not direct planes into restricted airspace.
- rnjesus 5y agocurious question: can navigational computers (on planes, though maybe this can be asked about other systems as well) not take an initial position-reading from gps or radio and then compute their location then-on based on internal gyros, compasses, accelerometers, etc.? if outside navigation aids fail, are these systems not capable of internally simulating and determining their own position, or am i underestimating how much compute power this would take?
- anyfoo 5y agoAre they still taught to do NDB approaches? I thought that's been phased out, too. In fact I was told the other day that the US officially tuned off the NDBs? Does not apply to VORs then, but as you say, the fact that they get phased out more and more is concerning.
- bdash 5y agoMost VORs are being phased out as well, with only a minimum network left in place to support routing flights on instrument flight plans to airports with non-GPS approaches (i.e., ILS) in the event of a GPS outage. [1]: https://www.aopa.org/advocacy/airports-and-airspace/navigation-and-charting/vor-minimum-operational-network https://www.aopa.org/advocacy/airports-and-airspace/navigati...
- throw0101a 5y ago> Most VORs are being phased out as well […] "Most" VORs are not being phased out. The FAA is going from around 950 to about 590: about one-third are being retired.
- RNCTX 5y agoThere are no more usable NDBs in/around most bravo cities. The last one in DFW was decommissioned about 3 years ago. Any other ones that are still functional are on borrowed time. Furthermore, no one is making the receivers anymore. If you have an NDB needle in the panel you are flying an airplane with some awfully old gauges....
- redis_mlc 5y agoMost US pilots could not fly an NDB approach using a simple ADF today, and would end up dead in mountainous terrain. The reason is that you have to practise doing relative bearings and wind corrections in your head, or else you fly in a spiral towards the station (unlike VOR, which displays absolute radials.) That means you will be off the protected approach path, and can hit obstacles. If they could fly an ADF, then AM radio stations can be used if necessary. (Airlines used to pay local radio stations to do a station identification announcement upon a phone call from ops, with the radio station typically near a coastline.) Just don't hit the radio station antenna! Note that NDB and VOR approaches are non-precision, which means they have lateral guidance but not vertical. So with low clouds, you won't get descent info to the runway like ILS. That's a big deal for airlines, since they have company operations minimums that may not even allow NDB approaches, which are more restrictive than standard Part 91 (GA) operations minimums. For example, there are situations where I can takeoff in a Cessna with 0/0, that airlines can't. Great discussion forum on navigating using radio stations: https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/commercial-am-stations-on-the-adf.44882/ https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/commercial... Source: commercially-rated airplane pilot.
- omegant 5y agoWe still have inertial and radio beacon navigation(VOR, ADF, ILS) , you are always able to disconnect the gps data from the computer. Obviously GPS is allowing much more precise route and approach navigation, all without ground equipment. New rules and rutes have been developed the last 15 years to take advantage of GPS precision and global availability. But current airplanes still keep all the old systems in place and we train with them. Removal of ground stations could become a problem in the future. I agree that it is important that alterantive navigationsystems are available.
- aaronfitz 5y agoThe waves of deactivations on the ground stations have already started. We're on a trajectory of GPS over-reliance. https://www.boldmethod.com/learn-to-fly/navigation/the-faa-is-shutting-down-308-vors/ https://www.boldmethod.com/learn-to-fly/navigation/the-faa-i... https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2018/may/23/vor-shutdown-update https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2018/may/23/vor...
- dwheeler 5y agoBad idea. Relying on any single technology creates a nasty single point of failure. GPS signals are weak signals from satellites & obviously can be jammed.
- ericpauley 5y agoThe VOR MON is structured to provide a usable (for safety purposes) backstop should GPS fail, so from a safety perspective this isn’t making us more reliant.
- throw0101a 5y agoFrom the first (2016) article: > 10 years from now, the network of VORs will be about 68% the size it currently is. So they're cutting about one-third of the VORs by the end of the phase out.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> a single point of failure, is pretty concerning. If is it concerning, we must have a definition of "failure". Does failure mean the inability to fly a route as planned? If so then we cannot fly any routes via GPS that we cannot fly without GPS. So GPS doesn't really add any efficiencies. But if we instead define failure as "danger to life" then we can accept that when GPS fails we will use the other systems to get aircraft to a safe landing, even if flights don't complete as planned. Under that definition we can still enjoy the efficiencies of GPS without maintaining a backup that can instantly replace all GPS functions. This is very important in a military context too. If you always need a 100% backup at the ready then you cannot ever use a novel system. Any new system won't have a backup that is 100% equal. So to leverage new tech you must accept the risk that you may loose some abilities should it fail. If you won't use the new toy until it has a 100% backup, you will end up never playing with any new toys/weapons.
- RNCTX 5y agoIt's not so much that you can't fly from VOR to VOR, everyone knows how to do so. It's more that it's a horrible waste of time and fuel. If you have GPS, you will get cleared direct after getting out of congested areas, usually (presuming you are capable of clearing all of the terrain between point A and point B). If you're having to fly from VOR to VOR you will fly a much more indirect route and spend a lot more time and fuel, particularly on private jets. Hence the offer to put private jets on vectors rather than tell them to fly the old fashioned way. People on private jets tend to be people who make political contributions, who in turn tend to call the congressmen in their pocket and complain.
- unionemployee 5y agoThere's an incredible amount of inefficiency in the airspace system that causes massive fuel and time waste, but flying VOR to VOR in cruise doesn't seem like one of them. Airline routes are still frequently planned along airways with lots of VOR to VOR along the way. Yes, you get directs, but these only save a minute or two. If you're in a Gulfstream flying above everyone else, sure, it's "direct Van Nuys" from over NYC. Airlines don't get that treatment though.
- RNCTX 5y agoDidn't say they did. Yes, airlines are run assembly-line style. The linked article mentioned a private jet straying into a restricted area, I was referencing that incident in particular.
- lutorm 5y agoWhat I don't understand is how this is supposed to work when the point of using the more precise GPS-based ADS-B positional reporting is for controllers to be able to pack airplanes closer together. If they do this, there will literally not be space in the sky to spread out existing air traffic to radar-based separation requirements.
- rlpb 5y ago> ...the point of using the more precise GPS-based ADS-B positional reporting is for controllers to be able to pack airplanes closer together It's not. Edit: at least, not in the places where there is adequate radar coverage - ie. in congested areas.
- lutorm 5y agoAdmittedly I'm not super familiar with this, but my impression is different. E.g. https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/programs/adsb/faq/ https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/programs/adsb/faq/ Why is the FAA transitioning away from radar and towards ADS-B technology? ... The improved accuracy, integrity and reliability of satellite signals over radar means controllers will be able to safely reduce the minimum separation distance between aircraft and increase capacity in the nation's skies.