7 ms·
It's the usual story: capture of the USPS by its unions, such that 500k employees are getting raises simultaneously with their reports of "We're dying!!!" Amer
by patio11 15y ago
It's the usual story: capture of the USPS by its unions, such that 500k employees are getting raises simultaneously with their reports of "We're dying!!!"
America in 2011 simply doesn't need to set aside half a million lifetime sinecures to deliver two pieces of mail a week which actually matter. The nation receives no value from a civil servant whose full-time job is literally to convince BoA not to go paperless.
It's a cool institution. Let's remember it in a small museum somewhere.
- bodyfour 15y agoThe full story is more complicated. The USPS is in an unattractive position of being supposedly independent of the taxpayer's money, yet any major operating issues are at the whim of Congress. Predictably, it goes like this: USPS: "Volume is down, we need to raise prices." Congress: "Nope, sorry" USPS: "Uhm, ok. We'll have to cut Saturday delivery then..." Congress: "No can do, sorry" USPS: "Well I guess we have to close a bunch of post offices at least" Every member of Congress in unison: "Sounds great, but not in my district" etc... I'm a big fan of the USPS -- I've found them to be more reliable than UPS and FedEx by far and they're amazingly inexpensive to boot. They know what they need to do to fix themselves, but sadly it seems to take a crisis before Congress will get out of the way and just let them do it.
- PLejeck 15y agoNot even a crisis will convince Congress to let them do it. I mean, look at what happened with the budget.
- tomjen3 15y agoThey are insane if they raise prices when volume is going down. The only thing that will happen is that the volume will go even further down.
- sliverstorm 15y agoOh really? What if they raise the price of postage on First Class mail by one cent. Would you look at the stamps, scream bloody murder, and stamp (hah!) out of the Post Office? Sure, increase prices, and demand will fall, but it's not perfectly linear, and even a one cent increase boosts revenues considerably.
- ctdonath 15y agoIf you increase prices and demand falls enough, you don't get a revenue boost. Upon one USPS increase, they lost my business altogether (save for maybe 5 stamps per year, instead of 120); a one cent increase cost them a lot more.
- georgefox 15y agoReally? I hope you're not talking about first-class postage: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_Postage_History.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_Postage_History.svg
- rdtsc 15y ago> Would you look at the stamps, scream bloody murder, and stamp (hah!) out of the Post Office? Maybe not me and not by one cent but eventually, if they keep raising the prices, I would look at the price and think, "hmm this is getting kinda pricey. I wonder what UPS would charge to deliver this..."
- ansy 15y agoYou can go check. USPS has a long way to go before it comes close to the prices UPS and FedEx charge. It's like comparing coach to business class airline tickets for the vast majority of mail. The postal service is truly an amazing service for small parcels within the United States.
- rdtsc 15y agoThat is why I said "eventually" ... it will be more than one cent and it will happen slowly. As price keeps cropping up some people will choose to use other services.
- mikeash 15y agoI personally doubt that the drop in volume is all that much related to prices. If they cut the price of a first-class stamp in half, mail volume would not go up much, because what we mail vs what we call/e-mail/fax/whatever is almost always based on capabilities, not cost. Likewise, if the price of a first-class stamp went up by 50%, I really don't see the extra 22 cents (or whatever it would be now) influencing all that many people to stop sending mail. A letter is already vastly more expensive than an e-mail. It seems to me that those items which are being mailed are those items which more or less have to be mailed.
- ubernostrum 15y agoIt's the usual story: capture of the USPS by its unions Except, you know, not really. You might want to read this: http://www.buffalonews.com/editorial-page/viewpoints/article476402.ece http://www.buffalonews.com/editorial-page/viewpoints/article... Especially this bit: What about those news reports of multibillion losses? Well, the $20 billion in losses over the last four years has nothing to do with what you’ve been told about a failing business model or obsolete mail. Here’s the real skinny: In 2006, Congress mandated that the Postal Service prefund future retiree health benefits for the next 75 years, and do so within a decade—something no other public agency or private firm does. The resulting annual payments run $5.5 billion a year, costing the Postal Service $21 billion since 2007. That’s the difference between a positive and a negative balance sheet, as it would be for virtually any entity facing a similar burden — if any did. Remove that unreasonable obligation and the Postal Service would have been profitable.
- nhebb 15y agoBut the unions do have influence. The Business Week article is from May. A few days ago, the USPS proposed a plan that would break existing labor contracts in order to keep it solvent. The plan includes cutting the workforce by 120,000 and running their own health care plan. Naturally, the service unions opposed it, making congressional highly approval doubtful. Here's the related article from the Washington Post: http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/usps-proposes-cutting-120000-jobs-pulling-out-of-health-care-plan/2011/08/11/gIQAZxIM9I_print.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/usps-proposes-cutting...
- ubernostrum 15y agoThere's a difference between "influence" and "bad influence", and between "influence" and "running it into the ground". The union quite reasonably objects to cutting 120,000, because there's no need to. The postal service could be quite solvent if Congress -- which is not the union and not, so far as I know, acting at the union's behest -- would take away the idiotic mandate to fund 75 years worth of benefits. In other words, this is something the union should oppose.
- three14 15y ago
- aaronbrethorst 15y agoI look forward to when you move back to Kansas and expect mail delivery six days a week, or the ability to ship a package anywhere for less than fifteen dollars. Like ubernostrum and bodyfour point out, the real story is much more complicated than this. This isn't to say that the USPS hasn't made many terrible missteps along the way, or that they don't need to dramatically revise their business model: they have and they do. But, the fact remains that they are critical to many aspects of American life, even for stalwart market-driven replacements [1] [1] http://fedex.com/us/smart-post/outbound.html http://fedex.com/us/smart-post/outbound.html and http://www.ups-mi.net/packageID/ http://www.ups-mi.net/packageID/, for example
- scrod 15y ago>It's the usual story: capture of the USPS by its unions... Oh, if only it weren't for all those undeserving, greedy workers! Clearly the problem is that they banded together to protect each others' wages, access to medical care, and dignity in the workplace! Thank goodness we have Businessweek to confirm our reactionary free market biases for us. You guys must be loving these budget crises — they provide such a convenient pretext for attacking worker's rights and consolidating the power of the owning class while sidestepping the inherent contradictions of the system which caused those crises at the outset.
- alttag 15y agoYes, it's irresponsible to _only_ excoriate the line workers. But wholly absolving them does no good either. Surely, there's enough blame to go around. (With an added helping for Congress, perhaps?)
- dcposch 15y agoI agree completely. I'm surprised that nobody has asked the question in this thread yet--why is the government still in the mail business? Pure libertarians would say the government should only exist to protect citizens from each other and external threats. I see a somewhat wider role: government is where we pool our money to accomplish projects that are beyond the scope of any private institution, like building an interstate highway system. But mail? The USPS is fairly unique among government entities in that it competes directly with industry: FedEx, UPS, etc. It might have been legitimate a hundred years ago, when delivering mail nationwide was an epic undertaking that no private organization could do, but today, the USPS is obsolete.