13 ms·
The City of London Is Hiding the World’s Stolen Money
- reynard_le_faux 5y agoAlso take note the the UK government is very interested in setting up several new Freeports.
- greyhair 5y agoThis article in the NYTimes was an excellent follow on to the Pandora Papers. The question is, will anyone actually do anything about it? I predict a temporary spasm of anger and shouting followed by the typical malaise. The only thing rich people are starting to be concerned about is average folk no longer willing to work according to the old rules, hence the current labor imbalance around the developed world.
- dr-detroit 5y agoGrow up. Crypto currency is the money laundering capital of the world.
- bongoman37 5y agoIt isn't just the city of London. It is all the squeaky clean modern financial centers like Switzerland, Singapore, etc that help cleanse black money flowing in from countries like China, India, etc. Countries like Cayman Islands, etc. come into attention, but the heavy lifting of enabling corruption is done by many countries high on the transparency index. It is just that the people affected are mostly in third world countries so no one cares.
- etothepii 5y agoBritain's overseas territories are not "partly controlled". They are self-governing.
- Bayart 5y agoTheir foreign policy, their defense and their diplomatic representation is decided by London. They're not sovereign.
- raesene9 5y agoMy feeling with those territories is that they should vote to either become proper regions of the UK along with MPs or go fully independent. AFAIK they don't contribute to the UK finances directly, but do take advantage of things like UK defence spending and are effectively protected from international regulations by being part of the UK for those purposes.
- skywal_l 5y agoWarning: The City Of London[0] is different from the city of London[1]. The former is within the latter. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London
- jstx1 5y agoAnd CGP Grey - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrObZ_HZZUc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrObZ_HZZUc
- fmajid 5y agoActually the City of London is independent of London, like a square mile-sized hole in its heart. In many ways, it is also independent from the UK government as well in practice if not in law.
- globular-toast 5y agoIndeed. "London" is actually more correctly the city of Westminster. London was a walled city while Westminster wasn't so it could grow.
- carnitine 5y agoThe City is not even remotely independent of the government. Name one way in which it is so? It is also part of London proper, just separate from the GLA, e.g. it is part of London Councils.
- dijit 5y agoMy understanding is that it's the only territory in the UK not under the Crown. The government is an extension of her majesty, and since the Queen can't even enter without prior permission.... though I believe there's some form of power exerted on the City by parliament. They are governed by the "City of London Corporation" which is much different from the "Mayor of London". They have their own police force, power stations, elections. Etc; Unless you have information I don't have.
- andlarry 5y agoThe City of London has an interesting governance structure. There are two types of voters, resident and business [0]. [0] https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/about-us/voting-elections https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/about-us/voting-elections
- null_object 5y agoI'm not sure the comments so far are really about what's germane in the discussion of this article - namely, it's talking about the government document[0] which is an obvious nod-and-wink to the City[1], that they are free to go ahead and exploit loopholes in international and national law, and continue enabling the criminal system of tax evasion and political and social corruption, without the interference of regulators. Anyone reading the headline statements in the document can see the implied meaning. For instance, the Chancellor of the Exchequer: "I want to ensure that the government - working with our world-class regulators - takes an agile and dynamic approach, one which enables those in the financial services sector to evolve and thrive as they embrace the new opportunities of the future." [0] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/998102/CCS0521556086-001_Mansion_House_Strategy_Document_FINAL.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... [1] The 'City of London' in this context should be understood as the rough equivalent of 'Wall St' in US terms
- tcldr 5y agoIf the penny hasn’t dropped yet for anyone who was still wondering, this is what Brexit was always really about. Shameful.
- patrickk 5y agoThere was also some dodgy goings on with Farage and some hedge funds, where they placed large bets on the pound dropping in value: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-09-06/brexit-pollster-faces-scrutiny-over-secret-political-operations https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-09-06/brexit-po... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-25/brexit-big-short-how-pollsters-helped-hedge-funds-beat-the-crash https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-25/brexit-bi... So some insiders were able to profit off the outcome of the referendum in shady circumstances.
- retube 5y agoNo one _knew_ what the outcome would be (how could they have done?). Hedge funds routinely risk capital to bet on outcomes of events like this based on their own research (it's what they do); some would have got it right, some not. There's no conspiracy here.
- carnitine 5y agoI don’t really understand the regional inequality point. Obviously the City is uniquely rich and full of investment amongst places in the UK, but that is because we are fortunate enough to have one of the world’s foremost financial centres. Most firms in the City view Paris and Zurich as their alternatives, not Manchester and Birmingham, and I don’t see how that can be changed. I think the country is much better off with the City than without it and to some extent we must be accommodating of it, not bending it to our will. Disclaimer: written from my desk within the City.
- rsync 5y ago"Most firms in the City view Paris and Zurich as their alternatives ..." Is this true ? Genuinely curious since you work in The City. I was under the impression that New York was 1, London was kind-of-sort-of 2 and Frankfurt was either 2 or 3 ... Comments ?
- lukebutton 5y agoTotally agree on this point. As an American who spent the last year working in Westminster this was always something I never understood.
- fmajid 5y agoIt's called Dutch disease. The financial center has a distortive effect on the allocation of resources in the country, including talent.
- skywal_l 5y agoI guess it's a game theory kind of thing. If, for some reason, the UK decided to clean their act, the grifters would go someplace else (delaware, singapore, etc). In the end it might make the world a slightly better place but at an important cost for the city types. However, it would mean that part of the local investment might flow back into local business/industry, making the country also slightly better off and with less inequality there might also be less corruption. Your average politician would spend less time being a mercenary for the city and more time dealing with actual problems.
- eigengrau5150 5y agoLondinium delenda est
- smoyer 5y agoWithout paywall - https://web.archive.org/web/20211011115516/https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/11/opinion/pandora-papers-britain-london.html https://web.archive.org/web/20211011115516/https://www.nytim...
- deanebarker 5y agoI live in South Dakota. Turns out we're hiding a hell of a lot of it too.
- Program_Install 5y agoThis really isn’t surprising, the rich and powerful will always be the rich and powerful. The article sheds a little more light on what we have always suspected. This is the game! Everything else are just distractions.
- bobbytit 5y agoMeanwhile, they push for 'behaviour change' taxes for the plebs.
- photochemsyn 5y agoThe root solution is rather simple but also completeley unacceptable to the architects of the modern global trade deal structures, all of which are built around unrestricted cross-border capital flows. The ability to move large sums of money from one country to the other without the government taking a fair slice is a relatively new phenomenon. Simply re-instate capital controls and the uber-wealthy would find the costs of offshoring their wealth would be greater than the costs of paying their fair share of taxes domestically, as would corpororations. Of course, corrupt governments controlled by the uber-wealthy (Saudi Arabia, United States, Britain, Australia, etc.) would never willingly go along with this approach, as it would represent a great loss of power and control by the billionaire class.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> as it would represent a great loss of power and control by the billionaire class There are zero cases, contemporaneously or historically, of permanent capital controls not having billionaire-sized holes for the rich and powerful. Instead, they typically create a wealth transfer from the lower and middle classes to a bureaucratic layer of bullshit jobs which benefit the elite.
- photochemsyn 5y agoWell, by far the major issue would be the disruptive influence on offshoring manufacturing. Consider Ford or GM manufacturing cars in Mexico. These cars are 'products of Mexico' and if sold in Mexico (to the exporter division of Ford and GM) then that cash could not be transported back to Wall Street without the Mexican government taking a significant cut, say 20%, which would make the whole offshoring of manufacturing uneconomical to the Wall Street architects of US free trade deals. This would force manufacturing back to the country of ownership, which would be good for domestic manufacturing and middle class prosperity, and very bad for the current global tax evasion and money laundering system.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Consider Ford or GM manufacturing cars in Mexico. These cars are 'products of Mexico' and if sold in Mexico (to the exporter division of Ford and GM) then that cash could not be transported back to Wall Street without the Mexican government taking a significant cut We don't need to use hypotheticals: China is heavily capital controlled on the outbound side of the equation. On the other side of the coin, the U.S. corporate tax regime, until recently, penalised bringing capital home. That acted as a limited inbound capital control. So when considering a U.S. company investing in China, one would have symmetric capital controls. The result? Not less offshoring. Just more money sitting uselessly in various accounts being tended to by teams of lawyers and accountants.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoContrarian point: tax havens protect wealth from wasteful public sector interests. Case in point: California, where income tax rates are over 50% for some income brackets, because the state sector has taken over the political system, via control over the dominant narrative/ideology. To give just one example, emergency workers can retire at 55 with 90% of their pension, that averages $108,000 per year. California now has $1 trillion in pension obligations for its unionized public sector workers. The one thing that the leak revealed, that should not be tolerated, is wealth hiding by public officials. Public officials should be under intense scrutiny. In fact all the financial surveillance laws which are misleadingly labeled anti-money laundering laws, should be repealed, and in their, place we should have financial surveillance laws for public officials.
- ganzuul 5y agoWhen do you think emergency workers should retire?
- refurb 5y agoI have no idea what CA pensions are like but NY it was generous to a fault. Someone did an analysis of the NYFD and noticed that overtime peaked during the last 3 years of service (no shit, that’s what the pension is based on). They also noticed that a huge proportion were retiring with disability (like 70%) which provides a pension “kicker” and boosters it further. What you ended up with was firefighters working 30+ hrs of OT per week and qualifying for disability and retiring with 120% of their normal salary versus the typical 60%. Dude we’re retiring with pensions of $120,000 per year until they die. I don’t blame them for gaming the system but Jesus Christ.
- pjc50 5y agoSomeone commented that the most effective way to dig out abusive and violent police officers was simply to audit their overtime properly; fraud is rampant, and there's a correlation between ignoring one set of laws and ignoring another.
- moksly 5y agoInequality works pretty well, until it doesn’t. The system is build to fail. Part of the reason we get along so famously here in Scandinavia, and why we share the burden of the less fortunate is because of how we build our cities and systems of society so that everyone met everyone. In an average school class in the 90’ies you’d find children from the top and the bottom of society, and that helps generate and build compassion, understanding and empathy in ways that I think are very underrated in today’s Danish society where we all send our children to private institutions and schools if we can afford it, and aren’t ideologically inclined not to do so. This has created ghettos of wealthy and poor, where we don’t really mix anymore. The result has been fairly obvious over the past two decades, and as inequality steadily increases the classes grow further and further apart. This will of course only have one conclusion unless the legal system gets a grip and starts seizing and redistributing the wealth. Maybe people are willing to live in their cars and work warehouse jobs in America, but here in the cradle of social democracy, people are sharpening their axes.
- TacticalCoder 5y agoYou're basically saying that somehow the socialist idealism of Denmark is failing (despite its very high tax rates) and that now that it is failing people need to go further left, to communism? ("seizing and redistributing the wealth"). What changed in Denmark between the 90s and now? Why do people, even in Denmark, send their kid to private schools if they can afford it? Tax rates have always been very high in Denmark, you're advocating for them to be even higher? > ... but here in the cradle of social democracy, people are sharpening their axes. Blood to make sure to make more of what didn't work?
- aerosmile 5y agoI don't know why you're being downvoted. Let's put our political inclinations aside, and just marvel in the long list of contradictions and unintentional negative commentary that someone managed to produce by trying to voice the opposite. With a large enough microphone, this fellow HN member would bring to fall any political affiliation they decide to join and support.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- KingOfCoders 5y agoAnd South Dakota.
- barnabee 5y agoMy response to this: privacy is a right. Trying to build a fair and equitable world using a tax system that relies on knowledge of everyone's finances is not only doomed to fail but also abhorrent because it denies privacy except to the rich and powerful. The obvious place to start with an alternative is land value tax. The Georgists have the right idea.
- Zigurd 5y agoPrivacy has always, and in every modern democracy, been subject to court orders to produce documents. There is nothing horrifying about transparency in finance. Property taxes have a role to play, for example in reducing the use of otherwise unused property to launder money. But, without other regulation, property taxes would just be a kind of sham, leaving every other avenue for money laundering wide open.
- barnabee 5y agoThere is a difference between court orders to violate privacy in narrow cases and the kind of 24/7, always-on surveillance needed to make this work fairly.
- echopurity 5y agoFinances are not private. They're created and protected by the state.
- barnabee 5y agoDownvotes: why do you disagree? Do you think it is possible to achieve the aims of a fair and equitable world through taxation? Do you think we can have sufficient financial transparency for the super rich to make them pay tax fairly compared to the rest of society? If so, why and how? Or do you just think that people have no right to privacy even when there’s no evidence they’ve done anything wrong?
- zz865 5y agoLondon is and always was the main financial hub for the world. Of course some dodgy money will find its way in.
- blitzar 5y agoBehind Every Great Fortune There Is a Crime
- helloworld11 5y agoEven easier if what constitutes a "crime" can be arbitrarily defined into existence by a whole torrent of financial regulations and laws that often come into being for the sake of defending the government's ravenous need for control and funds.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoWe are a major laundry chain, ofcourse sometimes a billion dollars will slip here or there!
- kspacewalk2 5y agoThis is a truly terribly written and argued op-ed, regardless of your stance on offshore banking. If the author spent any time at all actually explaining the mechanisms by which this system works, perhaps also offering an insight or two for those who are familiar with the basics, it would have been an actually useful read. Instead, no effort was spared inserting the word "shady" everywhere it can possibly fit. So it goes.
- cletus 5y agoIMHO there are six key problems here: 1. A predicted consequence of Brexit was that the UK would become more of a tax haven once freed from the shackles of EU banking and financial regulation. This would be (and is) sold under the banner of jingoism and because of jobs as some business moves to the EU; 2. The US demands financial transaction information as the price for access to the US banking system. The flipside of this is that the US doesn't share that information with anyone else so ironically (or perhaps by design) the US has its own role in hiding assets. Note that South Dakota featured prominently in the Pandora Papers; and 3. We need to tax real estate more when the beneficial owner isn't known or isn't a tax resident of wherever the real estate is located. Treating real estate purely as an asset class is having real consequences for the ability of people to live. New York City, London and other cities are where people work and live and shouldn't simply be a place for oligarchs to secretly park money. Yes, we have property taxes in NYC as one example but they're not high enough. For example, a $100m apartment only pays about 10-15x the taxes on a $1m apartment and that $1m apartment pays 2-3x the taxes on a $1m single-family home. Interestingly, US citizens and residents have to declare foreign assets every year (twice; once to the IRS and the exact same information also to the Treasury on a separate form) but... foreign real estate is an excluded asset. You don't even have to report it. Why? It's a nonsensical exclusion for the wealthy; 4. We need to do something about using debt to avoid taxes. This is another zero-interest problem. Why repatriate or realize gains and pay 35% when you can borrow at <1% basically forever. Worst case you end up realizing gains to pay those loans back. For individuals, you get out of that by dying (ie your beneficiaries inherit things on a stepped up basis). For companies, borrowing money should count as repatriating foreign profits and be taxed accordingly; 5. We need to tax more things at source; and 6. We need to do more about using IP shenanigans to shift profits overseas. Additionally, countries need to start apportioning profits based on revenue. If Apple earns 25% of their revenue in the US then the US should tax 25% of their profits. People being unwilling to pay for the world that allows their wealth to exist is not a new problem but like all such efforts before them, the ultimate form of wealth redistribution is war and revolution. And nobody wants that.
- aembleton 5y agoWhy didn't the UK use its veto to prevent the "shackles of EU banking and financial regulation" from ever being implemented?
- echopurity 5y agoStolen money, eh? Wait until they find out about colonialism.
- 1cvmask 5y agoAnd DC? First they bomb and destroy countries. And then steal their assets. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/nov/13/donald-trump-syria-oil-us-troops-isis-turkey https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/nov/13/donald-trump... https://www.businessinsider.com/new-emails-reveal-that-hunter-biden-wanted-2-million-for-libya-deal-2021-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/new-emails-reveal-that-hunte...
- rwmj 5y agoTechnical question! Shady dictator moves $100 million to the British Virgin Islands. Where does the money actually go? In a "traditional" country the bank can invest the money in the stock market or land or government bonds. But as I understand it BVI doesn't really have any of those things, at least not in sufficiently large amounts to support the trillions banked there. So I wonder where/how does the money exist in these tiny countries?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> So I wonder where/how does the money exist in these tiny countries? Banks, in any country, aren’t limited to domestic investments. It goes into exactly the same things as it would if in a US Bank.
- rwmj 5y agoUnderstood, but if say the BVI bank buys US treasuries, won't that make this supposedly underground money visible? (Assuming there is a register of US treasuries - I've no idea which is why I'm asking)
- koonsolo 5y agoWho the clients of the bank are and where that money comes from is not visible when that bank buys treasuries.
- jonpo 5y agoI'm not sure what we think the city does to hide all this money but compared to its size I think its probably cleaner than: swiss secrecy, Irish tax dodging, Dutch sandwich companies, and the US tech companies with billions parked in carribean banking centers delaware companies and south dakota trusts etc. Opinion article seems to sling a lot of muck but nothing substantial/concrete. "competitive" is not evidence for a crime IMHO.
- untilHellbanned 5y agocrypto's fault
- znpy 5y agoIs this news? IIRC it was in the book "Treasure Islands: Tax Havens and the Men who Stole the World" by Nicholas Shaxson that I first learned about the existance of the City of London. I don't even get indignated anymore... The thing is, as a society, we're fine with tax evasion ad high levels. Had we not been so fine with it, something would have been done about it.
- bsd44 5y agoI strongly recommend a documentary on Youtube called "The Spider's Web - Britain's Second Empire" that talks about this very problem of dirty capital being funnelled through City of London and its offshore islands.
- helloworld11 5y agoCouple points: 1. Have any of you brilliant financial analysts who work in different tech sector jobs and megacorps put consideration into how much of your high salaries and benefits might just be subsidized by those same corps that hire you being able to enormously reduce their tax burdens through all sorts of clever tax avoidance schemes? The same havens and instruments that are often used by blatant tax avoiding criminal money launderers such as drug traffickers and corrupt politicians also correlate with the paths that legal entities legally use to avoid taxes. 2. In all discussions about tax havens and financial privacy instruments, the criticism is always against those who practice these things and those who facilitate them. Rarely do people who should know better seem to ask if maybe, just maybe, government already wastes far too much money on all sorts of idiocies and inefficiencies. Many of these could first be corrected for better funding of its better, more socially beneficial programs instead of reallocating funds or trying to squeeze even more tax revenue and paranoid surveillance from people of all kinds. The obvious example in this case: The U.S governments military budget alone is in the several hundreds of billions per year (not including god knows how much black budget spending or military-related waste), but tax avoidance losses get screamed about by bureaucrats and social justice types at every turn. How about wasteful-spending avoidance first, and a modicum of self restraint from the behemoth public agencies that bloat nearly every western governments apparatus today?
- kinjba11 5y agoI'm reminded of the Guardian article: "How Britain can help you get away with stealing millions: a five-step guide" all about how ludicrously loose the UK's company registrar is. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/05/how-britain-can-help-you-get-away-with-stealing-millions-a-five-step-guide https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/05/how-britain-ca...