2 ms·
Those critical of BART's action will say that stifling communication for any reason is unacceptable and that even if most of the riders would have agreed, they
by tedunangst 15y ago
Those critical of BART's action will say that stifling communication for any reason is unacceptable and that even if most of the riders would have agreed, they weren't consulted. Some may also say that you can't let the sheeple vote on such matters because they'll vote wrong.
- hollerith 15y ago>stifling communication for any reason is unacceptable Do you really mean that? Do you for example condemn the U.S. army convoys in Iraq for travelling with cell-phone jamming equipment after they learned that insurgents were using cell phones to detonate roadside bombs?
- tedunangst 15y agoIt's not a position I personally hold, but it's more or less quoted from other comments in a different thread.
- wil421 15y agoI think if BART owns the repeaters or cell towers etc. then they have every right to turn them off whenever they want. With or without permission from the carriers or occupants.
- OpieCunningham 15y agoFirstly, I'd say it's debate able whether a corporation can disconnect public use communication services they've installed without notifying the public prior to disconnection. However, that debate is moot. BART is a government organization. Disconnection of communication services by a government organization for the express intent of preventing public demonstrations is a rather blatant violation of the 1st Amendment.