3 ms·
A nation-state is not the way that populations interact on the political stage, but rather the way the elites that rule those populations do. You're correct in
by int_19h 5y ago
A nation-state is not the way that populations interact on the political stage, but rather the way the elites that rule those populations do. You're correct in that the elites are who defines what the "nation-state of China" is, but that doesn't mean that they speak for the "people of China".
(It should be noted that this also goes for the vast majority of nation-states.)
- bordercases 5y agoThis will be false to whatever extent the nation-state can directly influence the behaviour of the population, making the population an apparatus of the state. And this will be true as long as the government can simultaneously be seen as just or powerful, while additionally having the government expand their influence to punish people who don't believe in its justice or power. Both these conditions are true in China. The perception of legitimacy in the government is the only variable that can vary freely enough to contradict the claim that individuals are distinguishable from the state. However, this perception can be controlled if you can manipulate the livelihood of the individuals to stay in line, by e.g. monopolizing payment, communication, and reputation. So guess what. China's influence on its population directly has only been growing and the way it yields the influence of its citizens to grow power in the West (without resorting to kinetic violence, leaving lawfare/financial warfare/demographic warfare/tech-transfer/propaganda/cabinet stacking) has only become more apparent.