13 ms·
When Facebook failed to stay online, there was someone who shared a lot of internal info before deleting their Reddit account. When I worked for company B I ha
by Waterluvian 5y ago
When Facebook failed to stay online, there was someone who shared a lot of internal info before deleting their Reddit account.
When I worked for company B I had learned through friends some really really juicy intel about competitor A (which I never shared).
Through that experience and seeing all of these other examples, I’ve come to realize that there is an intoxicating effect of having info that can make you a “hero for a day” in the eyes of some audience.
Has anyone else ever felt this allure before?
- notimetorelax 5y agoI think you get accustomed to it. Just fight the urge the first few times.
- grepfru_it 5y ago>When Facebook failed to stay online, there was someone who shared a lot of internal info before deleting their Reddit account. back in the day you would be tainted if you had read any of this material. today those lines have been blurred and even my employer, who was known to viciously keep tainted people out of the kernel, is nowhere near as strict
- Zababa 5y agoWhat do you mean by "tainted" and "the kernel"?
- morcheeba 5y agoThat's a reference to clean room design - you don't want to be accused of stealing a competitor's design, so anyone with knowledge of that design is considered "tainted" and not allowed to work on your core systems ("kernel"). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoTainted = aware of non-public information that must not be incorporated into the product, so it's easiest to just not let those people work on it at all. By only allowing people who don't know anything secret to work on a product, you keep the product safe from allegations (justified or not) of illegally incorporating third party material. If you don't do it, you risk that a competitor claims "your product contains our proprietary material, pay us royalties or we'll sue your customers". Even if you're 100% in the right, until you've had that decided in court, your customers have to worry about getting sued, and you'll lose business (and also spend a lot of money on lawyers). The model is particularly known/used in reverse engineering: One team (that is not tainted with knowing any NDA'd materials, I assume) looks at the product you're trying to reverse engineer, and writes a specification. Another team (not tainted by NDA'd knowledge or knowldege of the code of the original product) then implements the spec. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design
- anamexis 5y agoWouldn't the liability only be with the company that allegedly stole the secrets? How would the customers be implicated?
- grepfru_it 5y agoMany avenues lead directly to the customer. Linksys used gpl code illegally and when they were found out they had to release updates across all of their products, causing some of their lines to be end-of-lifed earlier than expected. Customers are definitely impacted by that. How about security secrets which directly impacts the customer?
- Talanes 5y agoThe question wasn't how could the customer be impacted. None of those scenarios have to do with the customer being held legally liable for the IP violations of a vendor whose product they use.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"back in the day you would be tainted if you had read any of this material" For most jobs, if you've worked in the industry for 20 years, you have seen 'secret sause' of several companies. They often look remarcably similar. Indeed thats kind of the value of an experienced hire?
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoHow would a company reasonably enforce a rule against no tainted applicants? Ask Reddit for admin logs on the applicant's account(s)? Honor system?
- agumonkey 5y agoYes, when I was 12 I spoiled someone's secret.
- bserge 5y agoYes, it is incredibly alluring to share something only I know and either see people be amazed, surprised or not believe it, which gives the best feeling imo. Really hard to stop myself sometimes, especially when drunk.
- samsonradu 5y agoThe allure seems to be there: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/navy-nuclear-engineer-and-his-wife-charged-with-trying-to-share-submarine-secrets-with-a-foreign-country/2021/10/10/c461aff2-29d9-11ec-baf4-d7a4e075eb90_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/navy-nuclea...
- baybal2 5y ago> Toebbe allegedly asked for $100,000 in cryptocurrency, saying “I understand this is a large request. However, please remember I am risking my life for your benefit and I have taken the first step. Please help me trust you fully.” Well, that not not even funny, more of cringeworthy.
- vmception 5y ago> “Your thoughtful plans indicate you are not amateur,” the FBI wrote to Toebbe. “This relationship requires mutual comfort.” LOL, I like to play with salespeople because I know their responses are scripted. So although I like being commended on my intelligence, I change my job title and pedigree just to see if that gets the same accolades “You’re a lightbulb repairman so I know you’re smart, you can see this offer is the best for you” says the person making an offer that is not the best for me. Helps me keep a clearer head in negotiating
- geoduck14 5y ago>You’re a lightbulb repairman so I know you’re smart If you can provide for your family by JUST repairing light bulbs, you are probably REALLY good at it.
- sunshineforever 5y agoYou might be surprised to learn that a lot of meth smokers are into very basic glassblowing.
- vmception 5y ago
- newacct583 5y agoExactly. Note that the same analysis can work in reverse, too. The lack of leaky corroboration for a juicy, tempting-to-believe theory is a really high quality prior that it just isn't true. (With, maybe, an exception for very tightly controlled intelligence organizations. But in general anything juicy in the civilian world isn't going to stay hidden.) For example: this is my #1 for why COVID Was Not A Lab Leak. The incentives for someone involved to blab are just way too high. If there was an incriminating email anywhere, we'd know. (Edit: and right on cue multiple people want to storm in arguing why this principle is not applicable in this particular situation. That's how you know it's "juicy", not how you know it's true!)
- vimy 5y agohttps://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/health-fitness/health-news/coronavirus-covid-19-engineered-at-wuhan-lab-who-knew-about-it-claims-chinese-whistleblower-on-the-run/articleshow/78276356.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/health-fitnes... https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/lab-leak-pandemic-origins-even-messier/620209/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/lab-leak... https://www.fr24news.com/a/2021/09/former-chinese-communist-party-insider-wei-jingsheng-speaks-out-on-wuhans-theory-of-covid-19.html https://www.fr24news.com/a/2021/09/former-chinese-communist-...
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoIt depends on a) how many people know about it b) how much they have to lose if the information gets out. The latter is a particularly powerful deterrent if it will hurt the person who shares it even if the leak isn't traced to them. For the tank manuals a) is likely hundreds of thousands of people, and b) is zero unless the leak is traced to them, and they possibly don't expect much even if it is. For the lab leak, b) is a strong deterrent - every virologist working on even moderately risky research would face trouble (in the form or stricter restrictions and possibly bans on the category of research) if the theory got confirmed, and for the people working in the Chinese lab, embarrassing the Chinese govt is probably pretty far up on the "mistakes you don't get to make twice" list. a) is less clear: They might not even be aware of a lab leak if it was one. However, one piece of sensitive info that could leak would be "we worked on something that was more similar to SARS-CoV-2 than the previously known sample", and I'd expect that to be reasonably well known at a research institute. However, that adds a third aspect: Verifiability of the leak. Even if a drunk scientist sat in a pub in Wuhan, telling his friends that it totally was a lab leak, and someone overheard that - what then? They post on Twitter "I heard some people talking that it totally was a lab leak"? Even if their friends say "hey, I know someone from the place and it totally is a lab leak", it'd at best be yet another unconfirmed and unconfirmable rumor that would be unlikely to make it far. Just because there are many leaks, doesn't mean there isn't also a lot of spicy information that never becomes public. These leaks are news because they're rare, even when hundreds of thousands of people have access to a piece of info. Reduce the circle of people in the know to 100, and the probability of a leak drops drastically.
- rootbear 5y agoI have only been in that position once or twice, but yeah, knowing some secrets can be exciting.
- tornato7 5y agoIt's amazing how some people will risk their job, their clearance, and potentially their freedom, just to impress some random dudes online for a few minutes. I tell people this whenever I'm asked about something I'm not supposed to reveal. "You want me to risk my _ just so you can satisfy your curiosity?"
- ethbr0 5y agoIt begs the inclusion of "How much time do you spend online? And how much do you value the opinions of online communities?" as security clearance questions. Are they, now? Historically, they'd be very interested in what you'd say to your friends, family, etc. But the allure of internet fame would seem to have a more pursuasive effect.
- eganist 5y ago> Are they, now? They're not included in Standard Form 86, latest revision November 2016: https://www.opm.gov/forms/pdf_fill/sf86.pdf https://www.opm.gov/forms/pdf_fill/sf86.pdf That's not to say it's excluded from polygraph questions; I can imagine a world where online associations are very relevant to an agency in need of a CI or full scope poly for compartment access.
- Waterluvian 5y agoWait. Some people still get put through a complete nonsense pseudoscience polygraph test for clearance?
- EamonnMR 5y agoI've spent an inordinate amount of my life chasing that high, not by leaking information but by trying to be the guy who finally remade the game everyone liked.
- shepardrtc 5y agoGaben?
- bmsleight_ 5y agoI liked the game http://flythrough.space/ http://flythrough.space/
- monkeybutton 5y agoI've definitely been in that position before (though the stakes were much lower) and spilled the beans to my personal audience. It was so very exciting! Then I regretted it. Not because I was caught or suffered any consequences, but because I felt childish and attention seeking. The allure is gone for me now. I wonder if others come to the same conclusion?
- 101008 5y agoSame here. Posting an exclusive online is not satisfaying anymore. Maybe because I grew up on times where other websites used to link to your website as Source? Now "influencers" will copy your exclusive on Twitter and Instagram without giving any credit.
- 1270018080 5y agoIsn't preying on that allure the mark of successful journalism? Getting info from unofficial channels etc.
- wolverine876 5y agoI can imagine many other motives and methods. Many people are torn between risking their careers, freedom, and/or safaety, and doing the right thing by blowing the whistle.
- dejawu 5y agoI believe that's exactly how intelligence agencies will compel people to spy for them and betray their own nations: they make them feel smart and special for sharing information.
- mhh__ 5y agoSIS (MI6) literally have a page on their website for sharing dirt with them "securely" https://www.sis.gov.uk/contact-us-form.html?lan=en https://www.sis.gov.uk/contact-us-form.html?lan=en
- fnord77 5y agoimagine sharing classified information via an https webform. Yikes!
- Consultant32452 5y agoJust take a picture with your phone and text it to me.
- ren_engineer 5y agoit's in human nature and in every industry. It's just a variation of gossip, which is what the majority of the news industry is based on. Almost all the news is "sources" giving a peek behind the curtain for everybody else, or at least the illusion of a real glimpse humans are curious by nature
- ogurechny 5y agoQuite the opposite. People naturally feel more “important” and “knowing” when they have access to internal or “secret” information, while in fact they perform the work of a cog in the system. In 100 years — often much less than that — none of that secret stuff would matter, and it will become clear that someone's life was wasted on transitory things for the benefit of some bureaucracy or corporation.
- jollybean 5y agoEvery cog is required in order for the system to run. Even when parts of the system are not materially utilized, i.e. tanks that never see action, they have important strategic value in terms of deterrence and optionality. It's probably understandable that people want to 'feel important' for a moment, but if they had the 'big picture' they'd realize that 'doing their job' is the most important thing they could do. It's easy for regular people to lose sight of that, just as it's easy for some people in power to take their roles a bit too seriously.
- armchairhacker 5y agoThere's an intoxicating effect of just contributing to a conversation, saying something interesting to other people. But there's also shyness and paranoia: what if whatever I say makes me look bad? What if it comes back to screw me over later? The Internet dilutes the latter a bit because you're anonymous. But you can still get caught e.g. if someone goes through your post history and recognizes you. Some people are very paranoid and don't like to share anything because they're afraid somehow it will affect them later. I guess on the other hand, there are people willing to share confidential information for attention without protecting themselves adequately (or at all!).
- swayvil 5y agoI know (from a forum) a guy who is VERY paranoid. His ideas are strange. His conversational style is combative. He published a book. He used his forum nick as the author name. He won't let anybody even know his age. Forget occupation or nation. Par. A. Noid.
- ta988 5y agoI wonder how much you could find by correlating subjects and way of writing. Not so many people hide their writing style as well.
- swayvil 5y agoOh no doubt. The technology definitely already exists. A wonderful algorithm that all the security agencies use.
- cassonmars 5y agoThere’s some folks who will run their sentences through google translate and back between languages with poor translation coverage to strip identifying writing styles.
- geoduck14 5y ago>There’s some folks who will run their sentences through google translate and back between languages with poor translation coverage to strip identifying writing styles. Hi Google! It's Robert Hackerman, here with the County Search Engine Inspector Office. Google: Hi Bob! How can I help you? Robert: I have a bunch of phrases passed through your Google Translate, can you help me find the IP that submitted them? Thanks.
- gambiting 5y agoSure. I work in game dev, we work with highly NDAd stuff that a lot of people would love to know about(things like console devkits way before anything about the hardware is made public, or just details on unannounced games). The temptation to "be the hero" as you said is always there but it would literally cost you your job and most likely your entire career as I can't imagine you'd ever find employment after doing such a thing. It's really hard to resist when you read comments and someone says "oh I bet Sony would never do X in their next console" and you actually know the truth but can't say.
- vvanders 5y agoYeah, I think in game dev there was also a culture of understanding that leaking that stuff just hurt whoever was working directly on it. Back when I was in industry we all knew what everyone else was working on including big IPs and next gen console stuff. That might have also been a factor of how small and tight nit of an industry it was.
- devwastaken 5y agoRest assured, if it gets leaked the vocal internet gamers that spend more time on Twitter and reddit will rarely be happy, and instead will use the leak to make it look bad. It's too bad we live in the digital age where you can't just tell someone "sora is the next character in smash, nobody is going to believe you." And then walk away. Everything's recorded and saved somewhere.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoAs you surmise it is not uncommon. It is talked about in some of the security briefings I've been required to watch and FSO's (facility security officers) have a bunch of stories of this effect facilitating a security leak. When I was at Google a TechStop employee couldn't "help themselves" and shared a picture of an unreleased Android phone. Apparently it wasn't hard to figure out who it was and they were subsequently fired and everyone got a lecture at the Friday meeting. I have not seen much literature on whether or not there are ways to mitigate that "feeling." (sure there are the 'you'll be fired if you tell anyone') but this comes up in all sorts of scenarios like seeing a VP from your company out on what looks like a romantic date with someone who isn't their spouse.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krisoft 5y agoThe traditional model of psychological factors behind leaks is called MICE. Each letter describes a potential reason why one would leak secret information. M stands for money, I stands for ideology, C stands for coercion, and E stands for ego or excitement. I believe this last one, the E covers what you are talking about. People who know something special can share it and thus appear in the specific circumstanc as special themselves. This strokes their ego which motivates them to share more.
- noodlesUK 5y agoIt sounds like you are knowledgeable about this topic. Where might I be able to read more?
- disposableuname 5y agoIn every intro book on espionage. MICE is the short-hand for why people become traitors / how to turn people into assets.
- crdrost 5y agoVery surprised that they never added one that started with R so that the acronym could be CRIME.
- bigiain 5y ago"Coercion, Reddit-karma, Ideology, Money, Ego"
- killingtime74 5y agoreligion? revenge?
- jdub 5y agoThat's just ideology.
- TomVDB 5y agoI once attended a press briefing, as a supporting demo engineer, that started with a very stern “Under NDA” warning, followed by some pretty mundane technical disclosures. Not 10 minutes later, one of the attending journalists was blabbing about it on Reddit under a user name that was linked to his publication. Another 10 minutes later, said journalist was walked out of the room, well before the really interesting stuff was talked about. I wonder how he explained that to his editor. What an idiot…
- Andrex 5y agoYup. Video game "leakers" are some of the thirstiest clout chasers I've ever seen.
- Pxtl 5y agoYup. I work in health research, but as a software developer. I know I'm not a scientist or a doctor so I shouldn't shoot my mouth off about medical issues and pretend I'm an authority on the matter, but it gets hard.
- iratewizard 5y agoWhen I snitched on Google for doing messed up things in the name of "equity" I felt much better about taking on the project in the first place.
- Bertio 5y agoYes. Quite a few times I’ve had some exciting inside info from my industry and I would love to spill it in my pseudo anonymous online hangouts! But then when I compose something that doesn’t give anything away I realize I’ve said nothing and don’t submit.
- tinus_hn 5y agoThe adult version of ‘my dad work at Nintendo’
- nomel 5y agoI suppose I'm the opposite. I feel excited by the trust and camaraderie that goes with having secrets. I'm protecting something with real value, that we all worked hard for, rather than destroying it.