3 ms·
Yes obviously that's what you want, but the public interest is not served by having an economy of which increasingly large parts are held by dead persons and th
by pjc50 5y ago
Yes obviously that's what you want, but the public interest is not served by having an economy of which increasingly large parts are held by dead persons and their unaccountable proxies.
- protomyth 5y agoWell, some of us who didn't have rich, white relatives in the era of the robber barons would like to leave our children our businesses and wealth intact so they can build up the family. Changing the rules when minorities are trying to build wealth is a bit problematic.
- clarkevans 5y agoThese things aren't black and white. There is an enormous difference between a 7 digit (millions) estate, and one measured in 10+ digits (billions). While income/wealth inequality does encourage work and innovation, it is entirely different when inequality becomes an entrenched oligarchy.
- kova12 5y agoThere should not be a difference here. If person who earned 10+ digits produced 10+ digits worth wealth, how can you justify taking it from him? Lets take Elon Musk - did he not earn his 10+ digits? Would you rather live in the world without electric cars and affordable space travel? And now that he already delivered something that greatly benefits everybody you want to steal what he rightfully earned. Why is it that you think you even deserve equality - I know what Musk did for humanity, what was your contribution again?
- extra88 5y agoThe estate tax does not apply to the first $11.7 million, the children will be fine. If you're wealthy enough for the estate tax to be relevant to you, you're wealthy enough to do estate planning that factors in the taxes due. The robber barons you're thinking of lived a long time ago and very few of the wealthy today inherited their wealth from them. We should be more concerned about the robber barons walking around today and how our policies benefit so few winners and fosters income inequality.
- kova12 5y agoBut when I'm dead, the wealth I generated isn't. Of course many people would benefit from cannibalizing the result of my work, but calling it "public interest" is disingenuous. If property rights are not respected, nobody wins in the end. Look at [this video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0IvTwBWUpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0IvTwBWUpE) for example of what happens when mob can take your wealth at any moment. Even the poorest people with no capital win when there is strong protection for the results of their labor. It really worries me how a bunch of people in this forum promote marxist ideas, with absolutely zero first-hand knowledge of what ends up happening, and hint: it's not in public interest whatsoever. "Democracy" doesn't mean free-for-all.
- flyingcircus3 5y agoYou're oversimplifying the problem into a binary one where either wealth goes untaxed, or communism prevails. Evidence to the contrary abounds all over the world.