3 ms·
The article argues, and I agree, that a university is free to not invite someone if they view them as controversial. Where the problem really is is that they in
by lolinder 5y ago
The article argues, and I agree, that a university is free to not invite someone if they view them as controversial. Where the problem really is is that they invited him and then retracted the invitation in response to a mob. The retraction is what makes this problematic.
EDIT: the other point that the article makes is that this professor's "controversial" views are held by upwards of 70% of the American public. The net result of applying this rule consistently would be that a strong majority of the American public cannot express their opinions on this subject because of a tiny vocal minority.
- cratermoon 5y ago> this professor's "controversial" views are held by upwards of 70% of the American public. First of all, who says? Second of all, just because a majority believes something doesn't make it right. There was a time when the majority of Americans believed slavery was OK. Times change.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoe.g. https://news.gallup.com/opinion/polling-matters/317006/affirmative-action-public-opinion.aspx https://news.gallup.com/opinion/polling-matters/317006/affir...
- f-jin 5y agoMajority rule is kind of the underpinnings of democracy though, and free speech is a major factor in effective democratic systems.
- lupire 5y agoNo! Democracy is rule by the people, not 50.1% of the people. "Tyranny of the majority" is the major anti-democratic risk of majority rule systems. That's why free speech is in the Constitution, to defend free speech against majority rule.
- dfdz 5y agoI think that every retraction of an invitation to speak in response to a mob is bad, so we are in agreement. My only point is that this particular "John Carlson Lecture" is itself a public relations event whose purpose is to promote MIT to the local public and enhance its image, they allude to this in the official statement [1]. In my opinion, a PR lecture cancellation is different from telling a student group or department that they are not allow to invite a specific speaker: it is bad, but much less dangerous to academic discourse than previous cancellations (even if in past examples the speakers mentioned in the article had extreme or bizarre views). [1] https://orgchart.mit.edu/node/6/letters_to_community/important-update-re-eaps https://orgchart.mit.edu/node/6/letters_to_community/importa...