5 ms·
Taming the BPF Superpowers
- belter 5y agoPresentation (at correct time): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xj0PBFjLm1U&t=5730s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xj0PBFjLm1U&t=5730s Slides: https://linuxplumbersconf.org/event/11/contributions/947/attachments/831/1574/Watching%20the%20Super%20Powers.pdf https://linuxplumbersconf.org/event/11/contributions/947/att...
- GordonS 5y agoArticle mentions fs-verify, which I'd never heard of and sounds interesting! I always found it a bit odd that Linux doesn't have a standard binary signing mechanism, like Windows does through Authenticode (well, and Catalog signatures, and now a different scheme for UWL apps too). I guess it's not quite as necessary, since on Linux you typically get apps from trusted package repositories, but personally it's still something I'd like to see, so file integrity could be verified later (even offline if wanted).
- azalemeth 5y agoI guess the argument would be that your package manager checks the gpg trust chain provided by your repo -- but I totally understand that doesn't prevent a binary being modified once it's there on disk. Some level of protection about that is that typically apps aren't user writeable on *nix -- app signatures deal with a subtly different threat model (and arguably one in which sometimes the user is part of the threat...)
- solarengineer 5y agoPrelinking can change binaries as well. A combination of a Mandatory Access Control system (SELinux, AppArmour) and a Host Based Intrusion Detection system (like AIDE) could respectively help prevent and detect changes to binaries. I'm not entirely sure if techniques such as ASLR are fool-proof enough to prevent changes to binaries in memory - I haven't studied enough about ASLR yet.
- marbu 5y agoBtw rpm package manager keeps track of checksums of metadata and content for all installed packages, so that one can verify integrity of all (rpm -Va) or a particular package (rpm -V foo) later.
- agumonkey 5y agoso IIUC it's an os level tripwire ?
- marbu 5y agoYes. But I guess that tripwire has more features.
- GordonS 5y agoAh, cool, I didn't know that. Do you know if it uses public key signatures, or if it's simply a list of known hashes for each file of each version?
- dfghdfgj 5y agoThis applies to almost all modern linux package managers. PGP is typically used to sign a collection of hashes (and other metadata). PGP is generally only used at package install/build time, and the subsequently installed/generated manifest is used when you ask the package manager to verify the package.
- marbu 5y agoIt just compares expected checksum from rpm database with actual state in the system. That said, rpm supports package signing, so that it can catch a package which was tampered with and prevent it's installation.
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y agoMinor nitpick: it's fs-verity. As a non-native English speaker I walked into that one many a time.
- mjg59 5y agoIt kind of does - you can use IMA to enforce signature validation, even including an x509 chain. But it using extended attributes for this results in a bunch of difficulties, and there's no good distro support for it at present.
- rendall 5y agoNowhere does the article define BPF. Kids, always define all acronyms when first using them in technical writing, as in: Work toward the signing of Big Pill Foundation (BPF) programs has been finding its way into recent mainline kernel releases...
- treebog 5y agoNormally I’d agree, but in this case the meaning of the acronym tells you nothing (it stands for Berkeley Packet Filter. Make sense?) and BPF is easily googleable. Also, it’s safe to assume that regular readers of LWN will know a little about BPF. Though obviously in this case it rose to the top of HN where it’s likely to be seen by a wider audience.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoIf you're reading LWN over the last decade then BPF is implicitly understood at this point. Expanding the acronym is actually incredibly useless in this case.
- themulticaster 5y agoAdditionally, the technology behind BPF changed significantly in the last years to the point where the original meaning (Berkeley Packet Filter) doesn't really have anything to do with BPF anymore. BPF is not limited to network sockets anymore (or something else associated with Berkeley), it is not limited to packets anymore and filtering is not the only use case anymore. The reason that the BPF acronym stuck all those years is that the new BPF features were introduced gradually, there was no particular kernel release introducing a BPF version 2 with all the new features (a release which could have been used for changing the name). In theory, the kernel people could come up with a new acronym (something like Kernel Bytecode Language might be appropriate), but at this point it's probably too late.
- OskarS 5y agoAt some point, you have to accept that on a technical site like this, there is going to be jargon used (including abbreviations) with furtjer explication of meaning. Would you complain about using DNS? Or HTTP?
- mhh__ 5y agoIf I could combine something like Pin and BPF I'd be golden. eBPF is great for tracing but there's only so much you can do without really injecting yourself into the target binary.
- davemarchevsky 5y agoWhat would you do with such a combination?
- mhh__ 5y agoA specific example: At [NDA-ed work project] we compile a lot of templates in our D code. I was using a uProbe to hijack the semantic analysis in the D compiler to count how many and where the templates where from. All good so far, but the moment I wanted to do a little bit of non-trivial work (collect some metadata which is not a memory access away) I would've had to switch to some other much more complicated system. I don't think Pin is that complicated but it's not really intended for "infra" programming like eBPF.
- canadaduane 5y agoI have no idea what BPF is, and couldn't deduce it from the first three paragraphs.
- kzrdude 5y agoit refers to eBPF: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkeley_Packet_Filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkeley_Packet_Filter
- kzrdude 5y agoSome of the most interesting BPF applications seem to be these tools here: https://github.com/iovisor/bcc https://github.com/iovisor/bcc