3 ms·
> The oldest flaw in collectivism is the assumption that people will collectively care about something they don't individually care about. While possibly valid
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> The oldest flaw in collectivism is the assumption that people will collectively care about something they don't individually care about.
While possibly valid, this seems unrelated to
> The bees are dying. Is taking action on this enough to change your vote from the party you ordinarily vote for to the alternative?
>If not, and that means your representative can benefit in taking money from the insecticide companies without losing your vote, what result?
The latter is an inevitable consequence of first past the post voting and plurality-majority representation, rather than proportional representation. Until the US moves past these systems, it will always be a game of voting for the lesser evil.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> The latter is an inevitable consequence of first past the post voting and plurality-majority representation, rather than proportional representation. Until the US moves past these systems, it will always be a game of voting for the lesser evil. PR has its own problems and the US would do better to adopt range voting to break the two party system, but any system where parties exist is still susceptible to the original problem. If Party A does something bad in favor of a special interest, Party B might gain support. But they can estimate how much support they need to control the government. Now that they have more support, Party B can do some other bad thing in favor of some other special interest and still be competitive. If you add Party C to the mix, they still have the same incentive and opportunity to abuse their power. You can have a party which always makes the decision that maximizes social utility, but you can have that in a two party system too. For that party to win votes, you need voters who are willing to elect that party instead of the one that promises you that you'll be the beneficiary of the kleptocracy. But these are the same people who do the right thing even when no one is forcing them to. If you society is full of them then you don't need the use of force to make it happen. If it's not then an elected government will represent the majority of selfish jerks.