2 ms·
> It would sure be nice to know. If he is a journalist then I support him, if he is a hacker then I do not. I'd love an answer to this. You mean you decide whe
by naasking 5y ago
> It would sure be nice to know. If he is a journalist then I support him, if he is a hacker then I do not. I'd love an answer to this.
You mean you decide whether to support someone based on someone else's arbitrary classification, and not on the merits of their actions, like, I don't know, exposing the US' atrocious war crimes?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoA court decision is hardly "someone else's arbitrary classification."
- naasking 5y agoA court decision is literally someone else's arbitrary classification, namely the judge's. Have you agreed with every court decision ever made? I suggest you think for yourself as to what's right and what's wrong and vote according to your own conscience, rather than relying on other people thinking for you. You know, how democracy is supposed to work.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoMy own conscience? I don't have the facts. I don't know what Assange or US prosecutors know. I think, without evidence, that he was working with a US adversary and his entire public image will collapse under scrutiny in court. Should I follow that or wait for more information? I'm done talking about this on this forum for awhile. Every discussion is the same.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>I think, without evidence, that he was working with a US adversary and his entire public image will collapse under scrutiny in court. Should I follow that or wait for more information? None of the charges have anything to do with him working with a US adversary, it's silly to think revelations about that will come out in a trial for a completely unrelated incident. Remember, the hackers that supposedly stole the DNC documents have already been indicted, and the US Justice System was so convinced that Wikileaks and Assange were not involved in criminal activity that they called them something like "organization A." If he was knowingly working with them, they would have charged him in those indictments. Even from a PR standpoint, why would the US spend years getting negative press about their treatment of Assange if they had a slam dunk like that.
- naasking 5y agoYou could know. Transcripts for Assange's convos with Manning are publicly available. Furthermore, even if Assange did break a law that doesn't mean he did anything wrong. Or do you disagree with the notion of civil disobedience? Do you also think Snowden did something wrong? He very clearly violated the oath he took, but the government was itself breaking the law and the system was immune to change from the inside. I don't see why Assange's classification as either a hacker or journalist should affect your moral judgment in any fashion. The point I've been trying to make is that your original moral argument for judging Assange is simplistic, and doesn't apply on the fringes of human behaviour where powerful players are trying to influence the outcomes, because any narratives or facts are guaranteed to be distorted. Why do you think the US just wasted 20 years fighting wars in the middle east?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]