6 ms·
> once again the US has decided this is the hill it will die on. Wat? If it's too much of a pain to prosecute somebody then they should give up? > nearly ever
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
> once again the US has decided this is the hill it will die on.
Wat? If it's too much of a pain to prosecute somebody then they should give up?
> nearly every major news outlet and journalist all see Assange as a journalist, not a hacker. .
So is he a journalist or a hacker? It would sure be nice to know. If he is a journalist then I support him, if he is a hacker then I do not. I'd love an answer to this.
I'd like to see what comes out in court that is not public right now.
I'm tired of everybody presupposing that a trial must be unfair therefore people like Snowden or Assange have a license to do whatever they want.
- Jensson 5y ago> So is he a journalist or a hacker? It would sure be nice to know. He clearly isn't a hacker, so of those two he got to be a journalist. He publishes information that might have been acquired by hackers, but nobody claims he hacked anything himself, all he did was make a website for publishing stuff (WikiLeaks). If you are one of those who call programmers "hackers" then you could call him a hacker, but he isn't a hacker in the popular definition of "someone who illegally breaks into others computers". He was the illegal form of hacker a long time ago and was properly charged for it, but that was decades before wikileaks. Edit: To be clear, not even USA claims he hacked anything in order to get it published on Wikileaks. People calling him a hacker refers to what he did in the 80's and is completely irrelevant to this case.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe US is charging him with conspiracy to commit computer intrusion, for "hacking" into government computers. They are very heavily trying to convince the public he's an evil hacker not a journalist.
- naasking 5y ago> It would sure be nice to know. If he is a journalist then I support him, if he is a hacker then I do not. I'd love an answer to this. You mean you decide whether to support someone based on someone else's arbitrary classification, and not on the merits of their actions, like, I don't know, exposing the US' atrocious war crimes?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoA court decision is hardly "someone else's arbitrary classification."
- naasking 5y agoA court decision is literally someone else's arbitrary classification, namely the judge's. Have you agreed with every court decision ever made? I suggest you think for yourself as to what's right and what's wrong and vote according to your own conscience, rather than relying on other people thinking for you. You know, how democracy is supposed to work.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoMy own conscience? I don't have the facts. I don't know what Assange or US prosecutors know. I think, without evidence, that he was working with a US adversary and his entire public image will collapse under scrutiny in court. Should I follow that or wait for more information? I'm done talking about this on this forum for awhile. Every discussion is the same.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>I think, without evidence, that he was working with a US adversary and his entire public image will collapse under scrutiny in court. Should I follow that or wait for more information? None of the charges have anything to do with him working with a US adversary, it's silly to think revelations about that will come out in a trial for a completely unrelated incident. Remember, the hackers that supposedly stole the DNC documents have already been indicted, and the US Justice System was so convinced that Wikileaks and Assange were not involved in criminal activity that they called them something like "organization A." If he was knowingly working with them, they would have charged him in those indictments. Even from a PR standpoint, why would the US spend years getting negative press about their treatment of Assange if they had a slam dunk like that.
- naasking 5y ago
- boomboomsubban 5y agoI went over this with you a few weeks ago. Only one of his eighteen charges has anything to do with hacking, and what actions he took is already very clear from the Manning trial. The "hacking" he did was saying he'd try to crack a generic Windows password that provided zero additional documents. There's little chance anything else could come out in court as if they had proof he did something else they would have charged him with it. Even further, he'd still be a journalist if found guilty on this charge, as every other charge is for actions that are unquestionably journalism. And I don't care if you're sick of hearing he can't get a fair trial, it's still true that he can't get a fair trial. Things like his attorney client privilege have already been compromised, and witnesses the US offered deals to for testifying have already recanted their testimony. This isn't a presupposition, it happened.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago> There's little chance anything else could come out in court Famous last words. You can't have an unfair trial unless you have a trial. He needs to stand trial and if the US govt pulls some unfair BS then I'll be right there to condemn them and I'll be sure to let my representatives know.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>Famous last words. Not really, a court case only deals with the charges the accused would be on trial for. While it's possible that they'd try to pull out another witness like Thordarson to try and claim he has a history of hacking, anything they had actual evidence of him doing would be a new charge. >You can't have an unfair trial unless you have a trial. You absolutely can. Prosecutorial misconduct in the pretrial stages can cause there to be an unfair trial before the trial ever begins. Things like the instances of misconduct mentioned in my previous post, which you should condemn and contact your representatives about already. This is a standard of US law. As an easy example, an improperly acquired warrant can cause an unfair trial causing a case to be thrown out.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 8note 5y agoI think he's won a direct trip to Guantanamo for torture if the US gets their hands on him. You aren't going to see a trial, those aren't needed for non Americans
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoNope. The US has said that if convicted he can serve in Australia, where he is from.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agothe US also said they weren't torturing people in Guantanamo until it leaked that they were.