3 ms·
AWS? More than 24hrs downtime in the last year. You must have incredible luck. Sure, AWS has a lot of outages; but most of them only affect a small proportion
by cperciva 15y ago
AWS? More than 24hrs downtime in the last year.
You must have incredible luck. Sure, AWS has a lot of outages; but most of them only affect a small proportion of their users.
- saturn 15y agoHuh? North Virginia was down for something like 30 hours in April. I had some instances in there. Hardly "incredible luck". And it was not just me: http://www.google.com.au/search?q=AWS+Virginia+outage http://www.google.com.au/search?q=AWS+Virginia+outage
- cperciva 15y agoOne zone in US-East had a significant outage in April; and only instances using EBS were affected.
- saturn 15y agoThe cheapest zone, yes, so presumably the most popular. And who doesn't use EBS? You sound like you think I'm being unfair. Why? Plenty of sites were badly affected by that outage; it precipitated a lot of self-examination at some companies I know of. I don't think I am overstating the issues here.
- cperciva 15y agoThe four zones in US-East have exactly the same prices. And I don't use EBS.
- saturn 15y agoYou mean availability zone. Well I guess me, Reddit, Foursquare, and plenty of other sites just got lucky in the bad availability zone. Ah yes, here's the classic AWS apologist pattern in full effect. You don't use EBS! Of course you don't, you would have to be some kind of friggin' idiot to use EBS. So what do you use for, say, MongoDB data files, that is different from morons like me who stupidly assumed they could/should use EBS?
- wes-exp 15y agoOnly fools would want a persistent filesystem for their OS! </sarcasm>
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Locke1689 15y agoHow is S3 not persistent...
- wes-exp 15y agoNotice I said for the OS. From Wikipedia: "An EC2 instance may be launched with a choice of two types of storage for its boot disk or "root device". The first option is a local "instance-store" disk as a root device (originally the only choice). The second option is to use an EBS volume as a root device. Instance-store volumes are temporary storage, which survive rebooting an EC2 instance, but when the instance is terminated (e.g., by an API call, or due to a failure), this store is lost." (Emphasis mine) Most choose the EBS type of instance now, because having the OS on a persistent storage device is more convenient for typical server scenarios (as you might imagine). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_Elastic_Compute_Cloud#Persistent_Storage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_Elastic_Compute_Cloud#Pe...
- Locke1689 15y agoThe only scenario I can see that would require hitting an EBS store often enough to matter would be if you put your database on it. Obviously your OS kernel is going to be in resident memory, so your argument is somewhat of a strawman.
- lmz 15y agoIt's the root device that's on EBS. On most AMIs with EBS root that's the entire OS i.e., /etc, /dev, /bin, /usr, etc. and not just the OS kernel.
- saurik 15y agoI distinctly remember the Amazon status page (which unfortunately seems to have very little history) claiming that two availability zones were affected during that outage: one was fixed within two hours, and the other remained offline for over a day (and if you were as unlucky as me, was not fully recovered for multiple days, not just 30 hours). Regardless, you have missed the point of this thread: I have a bunch of servers on standard non-cloud providers (like 1&1), and I have seriously had /one/ outage in the last EIGHT YEARS. In that case, a hard drive (just mine in one server, not half of the known Internet's) failed, was replaced, and my server was back up in a few hours.
- wes-exp 15y agoActually some of the issues extended to the entire East region. In particular, for quite some time I couldn't create a new instance in any East zone. At all.
- cperciva 15y agoTrue, but "can't instantaneously spin up a new instance" just means that for a few hours the US-East EC2 region was providing the same amount of flexibility as dedicated servers.