5 ms·
Almost every position I've ever seen says "BS or equivalent experience". I never look at resumes when conducting interviews unless I'm asking the candidate abo
by echelon 5y ago
Almost every position I've ever seen says "BS or equivalent experience".
I never look at resumes when conducting interviews unless I'm asking the candidate about past projects. It makes you form biases. I don't look at the school at all.
As a data point, some of my coworkers went to MIT, CMU, and Stanford. Many others didn't go to college at all or graduated with entirely orthogonal degrees. I'm at a fintech with $500k total comp packages.
Degrees are bullshit unless you're doing research, using an expensive lab, or need mentorship. You can learn data structures, algorithm analysis, and distributed computing on your own from home using free resources. That's more than enough to land a good job.
Any interview pipeline asking you dynamic programming problems has a broken process.
- HWR_14 5y agoWhy on earth wouldn't you look at a resume at all? Or do you mean that you skip the degree part of it?
- dahart 5y ago> You can learn […] on your own from home Sure, yes you can. Statistically speaking how many people actually do this for several years while being focused on other things? I know there are some, absolutely, but I’ve met lots of people with and without CS degrees. It’s pretty clear to me that on average, the ones with degrees are better prepared for programming jobs than the ones who dabbled. I would say it’s also clear that a small minority of self-taught people are even better prepared for jobs than the majority of degree holders. And the best programmers I’ve ever known do a metric ton of both academics and self-schooling, because they devour it in all possible ways. > Any interview pipeline asking you dynamic programming problems has a broken process. So the question is: what is the right process? Are you saying the interview should not ask any algorithm questions?
- WalterBright 5y ago> Degrees are bullshit The trouble with being self-taught is few manage to teach themselves calculus let alone advanced calculus, and one can have yawning gaps in knowledge and be completely unaware of their existence.
- hashmap 5y agoI can count on zero fingers the number of times I've needed to know any sort of calculus working in tech.
- WalterBright 5y agoI've known many engineers who could have simplified their work if they'd used calculus, but they were afraid of calculus and went to considerable lengths to avoid it. For example, I know one who was trying to reduce the noise in an electronic circuit. He randomly tried adding resistors and capacitors of various values. Until eventually a coworker looked at it, calculated the right values in a few minutes, and eliminated the noise. I've seen this sort of thing again and again, in diverse fields.
- GeorgeTirebiter 5y agoThere is a fellow I know who gives embedded design seminars, and he -- intentionally -- puts up one slide that has an error in showing Maxwell's Equations. He notes that in Europe, especially Germany, almost every time he puts up that slide, someone politely points out his "typo". In the USA? He said about 1 in 50 seminars somebody does the same. If you are doing engineering, and you don't know cold both multi-variable integral and differential calculus, you have no right calling yourself an 'engineer' IMHO.
- WalterBright 5y agoSadly, I'd flunk that test. Although I was taught ME, and understood them, and still remember what they are and do, I don't recall the exact form of them anymore. But if I did need them, I know enough to know just were to look to refresh my memory :-)
- jimmyvalmer 5y agoYour example will only resonate with a small minority since most of us here are web and CRUD jockeys. Also, your claim to have "seen this sort of thing again and again, in diverse fields," is patently disingenuous. Even the most maths-intensive groups in tech deal largely with discrete methods.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Any interview pipeline asking you dynamic programming problems has a broken process. Every interview method ever presented on HackerNews has been labeled "broken".