6 ms·
I wonder why people don't demand more non-profit news or why articles written by for-profit organizations are as trusted as they are. Why should people trust ar
by Jensson 5y ago
I wonder why people don't demand more non-profit news or why articles written by for-profit organizations are as trusted as they are. Why should people trust articles written by NyT over articles written by Google?
- osigurdson 5y agoI'm not sure we should demand non-profit or government funded media, but I do like the idea of media outlets being legally required to disclose any conflicts of interest or funding sources which may bias content one way or the other.
- roenxi 5y agoMost Americans don't seem to trust the press. Faith in "Mass Media" has plummeted to levels appropriate to their reliability on important issues [0]. And the media is a strange place. Something like Joe Rogan's podcast is realistically more mainstream and probably more trusted than most news programs. There will be many examples like that. [0] https://news.gallup.com/poll/195542/americans-trust-mass-media-sinks-new-low.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/195542/americans-trust-mass-med...
- gruez 5y ago>Something like Joe Rogan's podcast is realistically more mainstream and probably more trusted than most news programs How can you "trust" a podcast that just interviews everyone and takes them at face value? Do people seriously go "yeah I heard it on joe rogan so I think it's probably true"?
- ravenstine 5y agoYeah as much as I like Joe Rogan's show (or at least I did before it moved to Spotify), I never thought of it as something I "trusted", or even something that would be comparable to a news program. Maybe I trusted that it was less fake and not as staged as most news, but it's comparing apples to oranges. Also, I dispute the idea that JRE is mainstream. It might be the most mainstream podcast, but almost everyone I know either hates the show or believes that Joe Rogan is a bad person, so I'm skeptical.
- math-dev 5y agoUnfortunately yes
- fellodip 5y agoI like to think of there being different domains of trust. Trust to present accurate information to their best knowledge, trust to thoroughly vet information, trust to not construe facts to construct a false reality (ie a narrative), trust to tell it like it is, trust to not present a biased self interested story that omits important things purposefully, trust to be an expert on the subject matter, and so on. Obviously any thinking individual will know Joe Rogan is worse at some of these aspects than mainstream media but they also recognize that mainstream media will willfully consistently violate other domains where Joe Rogan won't. I trust Joe Rogan will tell me some stupid stuff about conspiracies and extra dimensionality trips, but I also trust that he won't tell me this stuff just to sell me on sponsors or his party's agenda, unlike the mainstream news.
- dillondoyle 5y agoYes a bunch of people do unfortunately. Same with things like tucker carlson, alex jones, and a whole bunch of crazies creating an alternate reality that has lead to Trump, Jan 6 and more. There is some of this on the left but IMHO the 'reality' in that sphere is more having a worldview or political positions based mostly on facts.
- roenxi 5y agoHow can you trust a news source that interviews everyone and selectively pushes back to construct a narrative, often in an artificially limited format that obscures nuance? The media companies don't have any special domain experience, they've got no clear idea if what they are reporting on is true or not.
- chmod600 5y agoWhat does non-profit news look like? A few rich people starting non-profit and making news might not be very trustworthy. I guess you mean a wide group of donors. But non-profits have a lot of trouble raising money without controversy. Imagine trying to solicit donations when every other story alienates half the donors. And it doesn't really answer a lot of the hard questions. Who is going to actually write the articles, what's their political angle, and what are their career objectives? And how do you handle delicate topics with evolving information in a neutral way?
- ethbr0 5y agoA better evolution would probably be similar to Spotify royalties. Create one "donations to non-profit news" bucket, that people could freely contribute to (with tax advantages, like the election fund). Then apportion that money out to all non-profit news organizations, according to some (readership) + (journalistic awards by their peers) weighting. It removes the direct connection between donor and output, which is what we seem to want in news.
- xattt 5y agoAn example of non-profit news in the US is PBS Newshour and in Canada, The Agenda with Steve Paikin on TVO. Both have broadcast pieces as well as accompanying online articles.
- chmod600 5y agoPBS is funded by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, which is tax money. So it's more like NPR or the BBC. Also, PBS has a variety of content and I don't think I know anyone who watches their news. Scarcely any of their content, but they have a few good things. I don't think they are taken very seriously as a news organization -- much less than NPR, for instance.
- xattt 5y agoSome of it may be tax money, but some of it is donations made by individuals and organizations. The credits of PBS Newshour front-load the show with names of the contributors.
- MattGaiser 5y agoAt least theoretically, if customers actually valued accuracy, they would punish news organizations that were not accurate. A for profit newspaper would need to respond to the changing market. A not for profit newspaper could easily have a backer with other motivations, where they might be willing to sacrifice accuracy to push a particular agenda. I am not sure that the problem is the news. I do not think people really care if they get accurate news.
- chmod600 5y agoDo people not care about accuracy? Or have they just given up?
- MattGaiser 5y agoThey would rather have news that aligns with their values.
- gruez 5y ago>Do people not care about accuracy? Evidently not. When was the last time a mainstream news organization got heat from its own viewer base because of inaccurate reporting? I mean, it's fun to dunk on fox news because you think they're obviously spewing lies or whatever, but that doesn't really matter unless their viewership actually cares. Meanwhile outrage drives clicks, so journalists are strongly incentivized to stretch the truth.
- ethbr0 5y agoThe issue is that modern news (and the economic model that backs it) is a mix of entertainment, education, and investigation. Even assuming all leads were pursued equally, and all stories were published, entertainment is still highly partisan. Which, presumably, is why we saw partisanship jump when the entertainment component increased in revenue importance (90s talk radio, then 2000s competitive 24/7 news). Fox News was objectively brilliant in that they saw this coming, which is why they went ahead and devoted a huge chunk of their airtime to entertainment-weighted programming.
- 5y ago
- simonh 5y agoGoogle writes news articles? The issue is freedom of expression. If individuals are allowed to speak, write and disseminate information and opinion freely and own businesses, why can't they charge for it? Well, that's a news organisation. It's not that you necessarily trust any one individual publisher, it's that a range of views are freely represented in the press generally. The Chinese constitution used to guarantee free speech, but the massive disconnect between what the constitution said and what was actually allowed was so gargantuan it became a bit of an embarrassment in the post-Tiananmen era. Since then the constitution has been revised extensively to be less blatantly contrary to reality. Totally incidental aside, but one of the inciting incidents for constitutional revision was a court case brought by a person fired from their job for being short, where the actual job had no real requirement for them being any particular height. They won the case based on the constitution's barring discrimination, but the fact that a court had granted a right to someone based on the constitution was so novel and unheard of that it caused massive conniptions in the CCP.
- tremon 5y agoWell, that's a news organisation No, that's a publisher. "News" describes the product, not the method of operation. Has the war on words been so successful that Americans univerally consider e.g. Cosmo "news" now?
- simonh 5y agoThat seems unnecessarily pedantic and argumentative, to be honest. News is information, right? Anyway I'm a Brit.
- Jensson 5y ago> Google writes news articles? Google writes PR pieces. I don't see why you should trust news articles more than PR pieces, except as links to other sources that you can check yourself like scientific articles or government agencies with data. > The issue is freedom of expression. If individuals are allowed to speak, write and disseminate information and opinion freely and own businesses, why can't they charge for it? You can make legally protected news organizations, and that anyone who doesn't follow those rules isn't allowed to call themselves a news site with journalists. Instead they'd be forced to call themselves opinion writers or bloggers. That way you still have the freedom of expression but lets the public clearly see who follows the basic rules of independent reporting.
- jorblumesea 5y agoMany "non-profit" agencies are actually funded by the wealthy or special interest groups. "Non-profit" is a tax status thing, not necessarily "in the public interest" label.
- ravenstine 5y agoHaving worked for non-profit news, I can tell you that they are in effect not that different from for-profit news. The majority of their revenue comes from wealthy donors, often in the form of "major gifts". Granted, this is usually done because it becomes a tax break but that doesn't mean that certain folks with enough money don't have unsaid influence. The frequent pledge drives are somewhat of a charade in that they create the perception that they will run out of money if they don't get donations from average joes right now. Depending on the outlet, this may or may not be the case. In big cities, non-profit media would be unlikely to go away even if most of their audience stopped donating. In terms of journalistic ethics, non-profit is somewhat better but by design isn't necessarily free of the same crockery that occurs in for-profit news. Non-profits are more likely to get people who take journalistic ethic seriously, but non-profit orgs are also seen as career leap-pads to the big name for-profit outlets, thus you end up with a lot of the same people and similar practices that end up at places like WaPo. I don't know what the answer is to news, but I'm pessimistic that present models of non-profit news are the solution some believe them to be. > I wonder why [...] articles written by for-profit organizations are as trusted as they are. That's like asking "why do people believe propaganda?" The entire business model is built on creating the perception that they are authoritative when they may be nothing but lackeys playing dress-up. Sadly, the average person receives a generally poor education and is never taught about human psychology and how programmable the human brain is, and many of the messages they've received about the world came from parents whose views were shaped by a world that didn't have the internet in its current form. You could place the truth in front of them and it's a mixed bag as to whether they take that information and form an original opinion. But if you dress that information in a suit and tie, perhaps with the right letter and color next to their name, they become conditioned to accept that information from a place of subordinance. EDIT: I want to clarify that I don't actually like shitting on public media. There was a lot that I learned during my time in it, there are some fantastic journalists in that arena, and overall I want to be believe in the concept. I've been highly critical of just about every single organization I've ever been affiliated with, so my intent isn't to single them out.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI agree, but Google is more in the news aggregation business, right? I pay monthly donations to Democracy Now, PBS, and Matt Taibbi. For my tastes, I very much prefer these sources rather than MSNBC or Fox News, which I dislike (one reason is that they never seem to walk back major stories that we eventually find out that they initially got wrong - that seems either unprofessional or corrupt, or maybe both).
- Ransid 5y ago[dead]
- david38 5y agoBecause when people hear non-profit, they think NPR, which is wildly biased. A true facts only news outlet is likely best, but provides little entertainment value.
- redisman 5y agoWikipedia has a major recent events section which is the closest thing to this I’ve seen
- systemvoltage 5y agohttps://www.allsides.com/news-source/pbs-newshour https://www.allsides.com/news-source/pbs-newshour Seems centrist according to AllSides, but in my experience is has been Center-Left to Left.
- laurent92 5y agoShouldn’t we rather forbid the centralization of news? I wouldn’t know how to do it, but AFP belongs 60% to the French government and is as bad an example as CNN or BBC. Shouldn’t news be parcelled like AT&T and centralization systematically unweeded, for it is far more dangerous than centralization in energy or internet providers. Then, when there are thousands of small information providers, we can see bottom-up what actually interests people, rather than beating up an idea from the top-down until people think it’s interesting.
- Gordayn 5y ago[flagged]