4 ms·
This may be a valid argument, but it's an irrelevant argument. 10-20 years ago we should have been building hundreds of nuclear plants world-wide. But we di
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
This may be a valid argument, but it's an irrelevant argument. 10-20 years ago we should have been building hundreds of nuclear plants world-wide. But we didn't and now the economics have shifted. Nuclear has gotten more expensive due to the loss of expertise and solar/wind/batteries have gotten crazy cheap.
Why build nuclear for $200/MWh after a 20 year build delay when you can get solar+batteries for $40/MWh in 6 months? (https://www.energy-storage.news/news/developer-8minute-says-more-than-24gwh-of-batteries-included-in-its-us-sola https://www.energy-storage.news/news/developer-8minute-says-...)
- lrem 5y agoIgnoring dollar amounts, are we even able to mine raw materials fast enough to get the required battery capacity in place? Or would the plan be to burn fuel at night and sequester the carbon during the day? That sounds inefficient :/
- bryanlarsen 5y agoYes. LFP batteries use lithium, iron and phosphorous, all extremely common elements world wide.
- lrem 5y agoHmmm, that's the kind of battery that electric cars use? There are some worries about availability of the rare earth metals for them... Are they used for the engines only?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoElectric cars usually use nickel and cobalt in their cathodes, which are rarer and less geographically diverse. Cheap electric cars are switching to LFP though. Rare earths are used in permanent magnets. Most, but not all, motors use those.
- lrem 5y agoToday I learned. Thanks!
- p_l 5y agoBecause solar plus storage involves needing to build 10x as much capacity, and that's making dangerous assumption about storage that might not pan out. So instead building out solar/wind also causes build up of at least gas power plants, if not coal.
- nickpp 5y agoBecause we need a lot of energy and soon - to scrub all that CO2 gas, coal&oil threw and are still throwing into the atmosphere. Also because we need baseline power for when the wind isn’t blowing and the sun isn’t shinning.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago> Because we need a lot of energy and soon - to scrub all that CO2 gas, coal&oil threw and are still throwing into the atmosphere. I'm not sure how nuclear plants that take 20 years to build count as "soon". > Also because we need baseline power "Baseline" is a useless word regarding supply. (It still has utility when regarding demand). There are two types of supply -- cheap and peak. It used to be that the cheapest power was that generated by running a plant at 100% 24/7, so people used the word "base" to describe cheap power. Many small utilities have 0 baseline power, they run purely on dispatchable power. They use natgas or diesel generators that they can throttle up or down to match demand. IOW, baseline power is only useful if it is cheap. Otherwise, you might as well use dispatchable power. Baseline nuclear is far from cheap, and dispatchable nuclear is even more expensive. > for when the wind isn’t blowing and the sun isn’t shinning. Ways to do demand matching that are (a lot) cheaper than using dispatchable nuclear: - using a mix of renewable sources (aka wind & solar is more reliable than wind or solar) - geographic diversity, HVDC lines between grids (the wind is always blowing somewhere) - overprovisioning (IOW, size your solar plants for cloudy days rather than sunny ones. 3*$10 is still a lot less than $200. - load shifting, AKA time of use pricing - batteries - pumped hydro - hydrogen as storage - other storage - fossil plants with capture
- tlamponi 5y ago> Because we need a lot of energy and fast to scrub all that CO2 gas, coal&oil threw and are still throwing into the atmosphere. Nuclear power plants have lead times of about 10 years or more, so if we need more now (as in this or next year) nuclear power plants are not the answer. There are wind turbines with 10 to 15 MW from Siemens-Ganesha, Vestas and some other corporations, available now. Those do not need a lead time of ten+ years with huge initial investment and permanent high security and waste management overhead like new nuclear power plant do. 75 of those replace one nuclear plant block, as most of those output ~1 GW. > Also because we need baseline power for when the wind isn’t blowing and the sun isn’t shinning. Wind turbine towers have heights of 100 to 250 m, there wind is not as restricted as at ground level, at least if not in very mountainous regions and rather steady. No wind is just not a thing in the atmosphere at that level, albeit too much wind can happen in storms. For the theoretical no wind and the more real, but not frequent, too much wind you can use power storage and load management, which needs to be (and is already) implemented anyway. Same for sun, albeit not shining can be a real problem there. Now, Lithium or soon also NaCl batteries, to Pumped-storage hydroelectricity to storing energy mechanically are all great but just help for very short to a day or so, what do for the rest? Well, the problem for too much wind (or the hypothetical no wind) is always local to a few 100 km radius, continental Europe (for example) has huge in-sync grids with a bunch of 360 kV AC or 10+ kV DC interconnects to move around 100s of GW for a reason, so just take it from somewhere else (often things even cancel out).
- willcipriano 5y agoWhat's the price/MWh ratio at night?
- bryanlarsen 5y ago$40/MWh. That price includes batteries. Without the batteries, the price has dipped below $10.
- willcipriano 5y agoIf you aren't missing something, wouldn't this happen naturally? They claim it's cheaper and scalable, what's stopping them from doing this everywhere and putting everything else out of business? There is plenty of money floating around lately if it's viable they should be able to get capital.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThey are doing it like crazy in Texas, where regulatory delays and incumbent opposition are negligible. https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/report-renewables-are-suffering-from-broken-u.s-transmission-policy https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/report-renewabl... Look at the graph, there are about a TW of green energy projects stalled in the regulatory queue. And that graph is 2019, it's gotten way worse since.
- willcipriano 5y agoThanks for that. That gave me a new perspective. I always sort of assumed that these solar projects were just over optimistic, because if the unit costs were true they would eventually just win the market. Having spent some time looking at atomic energy it seemed that a lot of the issue was regulation, that 20 year build delay seems to be 17 years of lawsuits and lobbying and 3 years of construction. I see now that isn't unique to nuclear. The reasons we aren't building out cleaner energy all that fast are human reasons not technical ones.
- specialist 5y agoMaybe the old guard, and its commitment to PWR, had to die off before society could try alternatives. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reactor#Reactor_types https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reactor#Reactor_types The advocates of PWR (and adjacent) actively suppressed all the alternatives. For their own reasons. Like military and civilian dual use technologies. We have new reasons. Like finance, flexibility, and tech. We can and should do what we want, unbeholden to the founders of nuclear age.