5 ms·
This is like when on a cli application -h displays a hint that you probably meant --help (or the other way around). If you already know someone wants to display
by atoav 5y ago
This is like when on a cli application -h displays a hint that you probably meant --help (or the other way around). If you already know someone wants to display the help, why not just display it?
- cute_boi 5y agosounds like python which don't accept ctrl + c and says you to do ctrl + d or something (i don't know python)
- klodolph 5y agoctrl + c is accepted, it means "interrupt the current operation", like it does if you are in bash. If there's no current operation, Python has no way of knowing for sure if you intended to exit, or if you intended to interrupt an operation, but the operation finished before you pressed the key combo. Python's behavior here is good UX. A key combo that does two different things depending on the current state of the program, and the program's state is changing right in front of you... that would suck.
- Freak_NL 5y agoUsing Ctrl + D to exit a shell and Ctrl + C to interrupt/break off the current line is a rather strong convention. Bash does this too, and many other REPL's and shells (Ruby's irb for one). A lot of technical folk who rely on this immediately notice when some shell doesn't do this (exiting instead of breaking of the current input line). I have this with Hbase's hbase shell. I've dropped out of that by accident dozens of times because Ctrl + C interrupts the whole shell.
- xrisk 5y agoFWIW, Ctrl+D is not "magic". It works because Ctrl+D is EOF. Applications that read input should expect that the input is done when they encounter EOF.
- tpxl 5y agoI like this feature because I'll use ctrl+C to cancel the current line I'm writing like I would in a terminal. Psql does the same thing, but I started using mysql recently and I keep getting booted out of the app because I want to cancel the current line ):
- pansa2 5y ago>>> exit Use exit() or Ctrl-Z plus Return to exit
- klodolph 5y agoIn Python, it is expected that typing an identifier will not cause an action to happen... so this is consistent with that expectation.
- gertlex 5y agoIn Python3, that is. I'd love to find (never looked...) a python3 repl where `print`, `dir`, `help` all behave like python2's `print`, since they're debug/lookup tools. It's rather often I'll open a terminal and want to check one of those things, and... typing () characters just adds significant effort (for lack of better description).
- wcoenen 5y agoThis is different, there is no special case handling here for you typing "exit". Python functions are invoked with parenthesis, while typing a name without parenthesis retrieves the content of a variable. The Python CLI helpfully sets the "exit" variable to that string so that you don't get a confusing NameError when you make this mistake.
- yatac42 5y agoIf the `exit` variable were set to a string, `exit()` would be an error because you can't use `()` on strings. `exit` is a callable whose `__str__` method returns that message. Note that this isn't specific to the REPL. Running `print(exit)` in a Python script will print the same message.
- johnchristopher 5y agoLast time I complained about something like that https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27951099 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27951099 (it's okay to quote myself, right ? I am allowed to ?) I was told it's a UX FEATURE and apparently some people like to be treated like that when interacting with computers. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- atoav 5y agoWhile I agree with that usage in the example you mentioned in your post over there, I don't think it applies here. Some applications use -h and some --help. Many support both. So unless we get all software to agree on one standard here, expecting your user to remember which one it was is actually bad UX in my book. Best is to just support both, so people don't have to think about how to get the help. Displaying a notice when some option changed makes totally sense tho, but -h/--help is not that kind of issue.
- dylan604 5y agoor just build in both options to getopts
- atoav 5y agoThis is the way.