3 ms·
Journalism doesn't really have the tools to deal with a good idea that will take decades to implement in specific niches. Something either needs to be dramatic
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Journalism doesn't really have the tools to deal with a good idea that will take decades to implement in specific niches.
Something either needs to be dramatically failing, or an overnight success to make a good story.
Something being an obvious evolution and way forward in the future as part of a portfolio of other complementary technologies doesn't really come across well in this medium.
I think the story is trying to capture that the continued success of renewable energy means green hydrogen is inevitable now and that's becoming the consensus.
- the8472 5y agoOccasionally journalists do pay respect to the gods of straight lines, even in mainstream news. PV has been a topic for decades long before prices reached grid parity. Learning curves are mentioned in many articles about renewables. Moore's law would be another instance.
- nine_k 5y agoI think you meant straight lines in log scale.
- the8472 5y agothat was implied, yes
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago> PV has been a topic for decades long before prices reached grid parity. Personally, I assume that's part of the reason no-one believes it's at grid parity and beyond, and half the users of this site are waiting for fusion to save them. Decades of stories about how expensive PV is, because that worked as clickbait/propaganda, while "this is the early stages of a sensible long term investment" didn't.
- InfiniteRand 5y agoActually the story is pretty pessimistic about widespread hydrogen use, but says that there are emerging niche use cases: "Instead, hydrogen can help in niche markets, involving complex chemical processes and high temperatures that are hard to achieve with electricity" The article title is a little misleading, although as misleading titles go, it's not that bad.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI was specifically talking about green hydrogen use for a specific range of applications that it is suited for and has no bettwr options. We already use generic hydrogen for things on a wide scale, so that makes the headline basically meaningless. And niche in this case means about the same size as nuclear or hydro power at their peak and working in conjunction with other techs to completely decarbonize the world. Again, the lack of nuance is a problem inherent in the medium, but they gave it a try.
- bobthechef 5y agoJournalism is the art of converting abysmal ignorance into execrable prose.