3 ms·
That article is misleading - there are no scenarios where a billionaire is going to withdraw their wealth as income where it might be subject to an income tax.
by roenxi 5y ago
That article is misleading - there are no scenarios where a billionaire is going to withdraw their wealth as income where it might be subject to an income tax. Of course the amount of income tax they pay is tiny and comparable to a multi-millionaire. That is the level of income where all their material wants are met.
Even ignoring taxes why would anyone ever want to get paid billions dollars in a direct cash transfusion? Nothing they would be buying regularly costs that much!
They should be leading with how much of the tax burden the billionaires are responsible for shouldering, not how much they are shouldering via one specific tax that isn't there to tax them. Income tax isn't for business owners, it is for people who earn an income!
- taurath 5y agoSure, but then all their real estate, cars, etc is also there and tied to a business. They never have to take money out for any reason, and if they do it’s just forever rolling over low interest loans. Besides, the money amount never goes down unless there’s a big crash.
- moonchrome 5y agoDon't know how it works in the US but here if you own property or cars etc. through business you can't use them for personal reasons and if you get audited this is considered tax evasion. I would be surprised if the US is any different.
- GDC7 5y agoThis is very much like the speed limit on highways. You can't put a private investigator on the tail of every business owner. Personal expenses will be justified as business expenses, it's a matter of catching the very big and obvious cases, doing it so very publicly with the help of the press and try to scare all the other business owners in order to scale down the amount of personal expenses that they claim as business expenses
- Aerroon 5y agoBut the non-obvious cases will also be the one where only a fraction of the assets in personal use will be owned by the business. Depending on the size of the fraction it might very well be not much different than what regular people do (eg using a company laptop to watch YouTube at home).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]