3 ms·
Economists helped Big Oil obstruct climate action for decades
- ahevia 5y agoIt’s heartbreaking to learn how many were (& still are) involved in denying reality. [1][2][3] Crazy to think we’ve had experimental evidence of CO2’s warming effect since late 1800s! [4] Yet as evidence began mounting in the mid-late 1900s of any problems, the cultural or political will to take action was struck down or weakened by so many parties. [2][3] I’m optimistic we’ll get through this. Will be interesting to see if the recent shift in the financial/insurance sector to begin factoring in climate risk will sway more denialist over [1]:https://www.npr.org/2021/07/01/1012138741/exxon-lobbyist-caught-on-video-talks-about-undermining-bidens-climate-push https://www.npr.org/2021/07/01/1012138741/exxon-lobbyist-cau... [2]:https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/ending-the-climate-crisis/exxon-and-the-oil-industry-knew-about-climate-change/exxons-climate-denial-history-a-timeline/ https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/ending-the-climate-crisis/exx... [3]:https://drillednews.com/podcast-2/ https://drillednews.com/podcast-2/ [4]:https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/features/Tyndall https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/features/Tyndall
- rapnie 5y ago> will sway more denialist over I wonder if "denialist" is still the best term to describe. Maybe for those who've been truly misled. But I can't help but feel that a large part of those among them that could affect real change know very well what's going on. They are just confident (or determined) it will not impact their life, and others will pay the price.
- HamburgerEmoji 5y agoDenialist really is a bad term. It's meant to invoke a parallel to holocaust denial, and assumes the correctness of one's own view. I might as well call you a denialist. It's also begging the question to say your adversaries have been misled; I'm on the opposite side of the fence from you, and I think you're the one who's been misled. So that's a waste of time. This stuff about how I and other people who think like I do just don't care about the future or other people, that's nonsense. That's just thinking "oh, well, perhaps they haven't been misled, perhaps they're just bad people." Lazy. The real cause of disagreement is taste about what measurable artifacts a person deems important, how they weigh them, etc.
- HamburgerEmoji 5y ago> its own scientists were aware for decades of how fossil fuels warm the planet I see this repeated over and over, and it's wrong. The issue is, we live in a complex system. We cannot know how changing one thing will affect the system. It can't be calculated, and it's not amenable to simulation. So the correct way to state this would be something like "its own scientists suspected for decades that fossil fuels warm the planet". I mean, if they were dishonest, call them out for that. Just don't say they were certain of something back then that we're not capable of knowing even now. Being insiders does not help -- it does not give them any special ability to calculate things about a complex system.