7 ms·
The US can change their tax system, if they want to. Eg they could tax land value. It's very hard to move land out of the country or hide it. https://en.wiki
by eru 5y ago
The US can change their tax system, if they want to.
Eg they could tax land value. It's very hard to move land out of the country or hide it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
Or they could tax sales / consumption instead of trying to tax company profits.
Company profits are just a bit too nebulous to tax properly.
Eg you can reduce your profits just fine by shifting your capital structure from being financed by equity to being financed largely by debt. (And as we all know, too much leverage is not all that great for the resilience of the economy.) That doesn't even need any Hollywood accounting, it's very orthodox accounting.
Yet, we keep pushing companies in that direction with the incentives that most tax systems around the world set.
- nikitaga 5y agoThe extent to which you can take a sizeable cut of corporate profits by taxing land / real estate is pretty limited because many profitable companies don't need much real estate. There is no rate at which you can sufficiently tax Netflix, Apple or Jane Street just with LVT while not impossibly over taxing most other businesses that use more real estate per dollar of corporate profit. And the solutions to that are not any better than those that are based on taxing corporate profits directly.
- eru 5y agoSorry, I didn't imply that taking land would be a backdoor into taxing corporate profits. No, not at all. (Though the companies you mention do use quite a bit of real estate by value.) Taxing corporate profits is silly, and we shouldn't even try to do it. I suggested LVT just as the least bad way to get revenue for the fisc.
- rPlayer6554 5y ago> Eg they could tax land value. It's very hard to move land out of the country or hide it. Remote work would be their solution.
- eru 5y agoSo? The land is still in the country, and if it won't be used for offices, it will be used for something else. If I was a bit unclear: I am not suggesting LVT as a better way to tax corporate profits. In fact I think taxing corporate profits is a silly thing to even try. LVT is just the least bad way to raise general revenue for the fisc.