3 ms·
> It's not a high rate; 15% is low - is there a lower income tax rate for any entity? Yes, there are plenty of entities that pay no tax. There'd be a great num
by roenxi 5y ago
> It's not a high rate; 15% is low - is there a lower income tax rate for any entity?
Yes, there are plenty of entities that pay no tax. There'd be a great number of clubs for example. Churches, charity and trusts often get some sort of exemption too depending on country and circumstance. The only reason it might seem like all entities pay taxes is because once something is taxable it has to be given sharp, forceful boundaries otherwise it disappears and gets renamed.
I don't actually mind a 15% global minimum, to me that seems like it can only hurt poor countries in theory so if they want to sign up for it that is their problem. But companies are part of the things societies need to operate. A society with no Apple had to wait another decade - maybe more - to see real smartphones. A country without an Amazon has measurably worse logistics & distribution than one that does. It is not at all obvious that companies should be taxed. All they do is work to benefit consumers (within a moral-less, economic understanding of the word benefit).
- omnimus 5y agoYes corporations are very much like churches and charities. We should exempt them from paying taxes.
- wolverine876 5y ago> There'd be a great number of clubs for example. Churches, charity and trusts often get some sort of exemption too depending on country and circumstance. Excellent point. > companies are part of the things societies need to operate Agreed, and so are individuals, and in fact individuals are what society exists for. Companies have no special place or status - they idea that they are somehow superior to rather inferior to real persons, is shocking. > All they do is work to benefit consumers The theory is that all they do is work to benefit their shareholders, to maximize profit. Certainly, they do many things that provide no benefit to their customers; as a simple example, Apple could charge much less, benefiting consumers, be just as effective (they don't need trillions of dollars of assets), but that would reduce profits for shareholders. Capitalism, for good or ill, benefits the capital-holders.
- roenxi 5y ago> Apple could charge much less, benefiting consumers, be just as effective (they don't need trillions of dollars of assets) If we ignored 2nd order effects yes. In practice, no. This is the only way for other phone companies to realise that their products are bad and that they need to improve. We can observe that when Apple came in to the market and started selling their phone at absurd volumes and profit margins, the other phone OEMs moved like lightening to catch up. The market for mobiles completely reformed in a few years. If Apple had charged razor thin margins, it would have been much less obvious how much value was being created, and Apple wouldn't have had the cash reserves to reshape the market as fundamentally as it did. Consumers would have been much worse off. Since nearly nobody is forced to buy an iPhone, all that money that Apple has represents at least value created in the past and that value probably wouldn't exist had Apple been forced to go slowly and work with slim profits. One of the fun observations of economics is while capitalists would like very high rates of profit they can't actually achieve them long term in a relatively free market. Other capitalists will figure out what is valuable, muscle in and bring the rates of profit down to a return consistent with the risk.
- wolverine876 5y ago> This is the only way for other phone companies to realise that their products are bad and that they need to improve. If Apple charged less, they's have even more market share, reducing competitor profits even more. Other companies would get the message.
- roenxi 5y agoYou say that, but the rise of Apple has pretty much revealed that the industry consumers rated as most in need of a shake-up was being run by vision-less suits who got shown up badly as having no idea what the future of phones looked like. In hindsight, it was an emergency - as has been revealed by the sickening amounts of money Apple managed to make by doing it right. We all had no idea how bad the situation was relative to where it needed to be. It seems quite reasonable to speculate that the margins they were charging on phones were just too low to attract capable people. Apple smelt blood and took on pretty much an entire industry, and attracted the focus of the likes of Samsung, Google, Microsoft, Huawei. Prior to that it was the focus of, y'know. Nokia. Who turned out to be way out of their depth when serious people got involved. If they'd gone with a lets just not make money strategy, the market just wouldn't have the sort of energy behind it that it actually attracted. It would have taken a lot longer to figure out what was going on.